r/MusicEd • u/melodic-rhythms • 13h ago
Advice for self flagulation?
Hey, I'm currently a music education student and I'm getting beyond frustrated with myself in regards to my main instrument. Every time I practice I get into this loop of 'you're a subpar player', 'even the freshman play better than you', 'you really suck at this', 'you'll never get this, so why are you trying?', and it's making it really hard to advance, or even to like my instrument. I've been struggling in other ways too, but sometimes wind ensemble feels like a humiliation ritual. In all honesty, I'm considering a break. To step away from playing in a group setting so I have less to compare myself to, but I need to be enrolled in an ensemble with my main instrument to be in studio, which is also required.
I know this is a common problem, but it's making me really depressed, and I've gotten into this belief that while I will get there, it'll be another 5 years until I'm able to play at a reasonable speed, and I just can't do that. I was wondering if anyone here has been where I am, or has some advice that may help me to overcome this. If I need to step away, am I even cut out to be a music teacher? Do I just lack tenacity? Or is this something that will eventually pass? I know exactly what my issue is, exactly what I want to fix (speed, I'm a flute player who can't play fast), but I've been working on a piece for 3 months and it's only at 74 bpm, and even that is unsteady. I'm just not sure where to go from here, was hoping maybe one of you did.
Thank you.