r/MusicEd • • Mar 05 '21

Reminder: Rule 2/Blog spam

36 Upvotes

Since there's been a bit of an uptick in these types of posts, I wanted to take a quick minute to clarify rule 2 regarding blogspam/self promotion for our new subscribers. This rule's purpose is to ensure that our sub stays predominantly discussion-based.

A post is considered blogspam if it's a self-created resource that's shared here and numerous other subs by a user who hasn't contributed discussion posts and/or who hasn't contributed TO any discussion posts. These posts are removed by the mod team.

A post is considered self-promotion if it's post about a self-created resource and the only posts/contributions made by the user are about self-created materials. These posts are also removed by the mod team.

In a nut shell, the majority of your posts should be discussion-related or about resources that you didn't create.

Thanks so much for being subscribers and contributors!


r/MusicEd • • 19h ago

Movable solfége > Fixed solfége and I'm ready to die on that hill.

Post image
173 Upvotes

And I also wanted to take the chance to show off the posters I made for my classroom, which took many, many hours!

EDIT: sorry about the garbled text on the top posters. I tried to remove the glare from the lamination and ended up with more than I bargained for. The posters are real, I promise. Proof in the comments.


r/MusicEd • • 6h ago

Only 1 song for the Elementary Choir Concert

12 Upvotes

First-year teacher here. I’m in charge of 4th-6th choirs, and it’s like these kids have never been in a classroom before. Talking, interrupting, arguing, threatening each other, the whole nine yards. That being said, I had three songs planned for this Christmas concert. Due to behavior, and interruptions from other teachers pulling students, we’ve only learned one. The band and orchestra are doing a combined concert with us, and are doing multiple songs per grade level, while the choir is only doing a combined ‘You’re a Mean One, Mr. Grinch.’

Is this something that is normal? I feel like I’m really behind the other teachers and I’m letting my students down.


r/MusicEd • • 3h ago

Robust/Competitive Ear training Resource

1 Upvotes

I've been building a browser game that matches what I always wanted from ear training, and this seems like the right place to ask whether it actually helps.
Head-to-Head: you and an opponent hear the same melody, chord, rhythm, drum beat or progression and both answer. It starts beginner-friendly and gets close to expert by round 20.

Practice: six sections (intervals, chords, scales, melodies, progressions, drum beats), sessions of 5 to 30 questions, presets from Beginner to Expert or your own, and a progress chart. Much more customizable then any other app I've found on the market.

Daily Song: Play through an entire song by ear/

What I'd love to hear:
Does the competitive part keep you practicing, or get in the way?

Comment or DM me, any feedback helps. It's a one-person project.
https://jland123.github.io/eartrainer-site/?utm_source=reddit&utm_medium=organic&utm_campaign=early-feedback&utm_content=r-eartraining-feedback#/


r/MusicEd • • 4h ago

Masters advice

1 Upvotes

I have a btech degree in Electronics engineering and I have been working as a software engineer for a year and recently I have been thinking about masters and I've been really passionate about music so I'm now considering masters in music most likely in production,mixing/mastering, sound design from Europe (Germany,France, Italy). I've been making music for a like 5 years now as a "hobby" and now I'm really considering to make it my profession and having a music school experience. I want some advice on the courses , institutes or experience of people in general.


r/MusicEd • • 1d ago

Transitioning students from “ta, titi” to “1, 2+”

14 Upvotes

Hi all,

My third grade classes have been doing excellent with reading rhythm as well as treble clef pitches. As they progress, I want to make the transition from ta and titi to having them count the rhythm and begin to understand counting/how it fits into a measure, etc. When introducing this, they were quite confused. I want to be able to make it easier for them to grasp. What has worked and how can i bridge the gap so they can make the connection that it’s the same concept, just being spoken differently? What has worked for you?


r/MusicEd • • 11h ago

Can anyone recommend a good music college for a 16-year-old drummer after GCSEs?

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I'm hoping to get some advice from other parents, musicians or anyone who's been through this with their children.

My son is 15 and will finish his GCSEs next summer. He's a very dedicated drummer, currently working towards Grade 6, and is predicted a 7–8 in GCSE Music.

We're trying to find the right music college for him to attend from September 2027, ideally a two-year course for 16–18-year-olds.

We live in Liverpool and have been looking at places like LIPA Sixth Form, LMA, Access Creative College and Chetham's School of Music in Manchester. We've also looked into BIMM, although I'm not sure whether they still offer courses for 16-year-olds.

The problem is that it's quite difficult to work out what these colleges actually offer beyond what's written on their websites.

My son loves rock, pop, playing in bands and performing live. He would love to become a professional drummer one day, and we want to give him the best possible opportunity to develop his skills.

What concerns me is that some music courses seem to be mainly about working on projects, playing in bands and music production. All of that is great, but who actually teaches these young musicians to become better at their instruments?

We're looking for somewhere that provides proper individual drum kit lessons with an experienced teacher, regular technical training, opportunities to practise every day, as well as band rehearsals, concerts and studio experience.

I don't want him to spend two years on a music course only to discover that he's expected to improve his actual drumming skills entirely in his own time.

We'd prefer somewhere in Liverpool or the North West, but would consider a school further away if it has proper boarding facilities. Daily travelling to Manchester wouldn't be practical, and London is too far for us.

Has anyone had a child attend one of these colleges, or studied there themselves?

I'd particularly love to know:

  • Did you actually receive regular one-to-one instrumental lessons?
  • How much time each week was spent improving your playing technique?
  • Were the teachers genuinely good musicians and educators?
  • Could students use the practice rooms and instruments outside lessons?
  • Was it a proper five-day college experience?
  • Looking back, was it worth those two years?

I'm also very happy to hear about other music colleges we might have missed.

I'm not necessarily looking for the most famous school. I just want somewhere that will take a young drummer who is passionate about music and really help him reach his potential.

I'd be grateful for any honest experiences, good or bad, especially from parents who've already been through this.

Thanks so much.


r/MusicEd • • 14h ago

Advice for self flagulation?

0 Upvotes

Hey, I'm currently a music education student and I'm getting beyond frustrated with myself in regards to my main instrument. Every time I practice I get into this loop of 'you're a subpar player', 'even the freshman play better than you', 'you really suck at this', 'you'll never get this, so why are you trying?', and it's making it really hard to advance, or even to like my instrument. I've been struggling in other ways too, but sometimes wind ensemble feels like a humiliation ritual. In all honesty, I'm considering a break. To step away from playing in a group setting so I have less to compare myself to, but I need to be enrolled in an ensemble with my main instrument to be in studio, which is also required.

I know this is a common problem, but it's making me really depressed, and I've gotten into this belief that while I will get there, it'll be another 5 years until I'm able to play at a reasonable speed, and I just can't do that. I was wondering if anyone here has been where I am, or has some advice that may help me to overcome this. If I need to step away, am I even cut out to be a music teacher? Do I just lack tenacity? Or is this something that will eventually pass? I know exactly what my issue is, exactly what I want to fix (speed, I'm a flute player who can't play fast), but I've been working on a piece for 3 months and it's only at 74 bpm, and even that is unsteady. I'm just not sure where to go from here, was hoping maybe one of you did.

Thank you.


r/MusicEd • • 17h ago

Laptop options for MusEd major

1 Upvotes

Hi! I’m currently a MusEd major, senior year going into credential. I just wanted to ask what laptop is enough for some of you. I go into laptop subreddits asking for advice but most of the time it’s some computer wiz trying to upsell me on specs. So I wanted to come in here and ask people who are using laptops with similar needs and work. I’m honestly doing a lot of my course work on my gaming laptop rn but find myself more outside of my house with student teaching and observations, and my iPad is just not cutting it anymore. While I do want a MacBook, as a college student I can do what’s affordable and then once (hopefully) I get my big girl job invest into a newer MacBook. Thank you!


r/MusicEd • • 18h ago

First Year Director Woes

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/MusicEd • • 1d ago

I underprogrammed a concert

54 Upvotes

Soooo I have an event/program coming up for 1st grade, and I unfortunately don't think I programmed enough music. They are performing four songs, 2 of them are a little over 1 minute long, and the other two are a little over 2 minutes. I added some speaking parts for the kids, but I still feel like it's going to be too short. In the moment when I was teaching them, I was just thinking about how many songs they were learning, not how long it would take. I also didn't know what they were capable of, as I am a first-year teacher. Any advice or things I can do to lengthen it at the last minute? Or just hope for the best?


r/MusicEd • • 1d ago

What is Going on with Future Music Educators ?!

44 Upvotes

I’m a college freshman( first semester btw) pursuing a music ed degree with my main instrument being the piano. The piano studio in my college is known for being rigorous. By no means am I the best in my studio I have my weakness and strengths. I commute 3-4 hours round trip to go school, plus I’m taking 16 credits. I show up to class before lectures start, turn in assignments early, I engage with professors when I struggle, and I do my best to keep up with the program.

While on the other hand, the majority of my class mates who live on campus ( who are ed majors, or performing majors) show up 20-10 minutes before lecture ends, don’t turn in their assignments, and when they do its ai generated or straight up copied from a another student, they don’t master their repertoire for recitals (sloppy performances), during lectures they are straight up on their phones and computer entertaiNing themselves, and to top it all off when they are called out by professors they react disrespectfully. These are future educators and musicians, who don’t care of doing the bare minimum to do Theory, Repertoire, manners or simply learn. They just want a passing grade to go to the next level and have fun in ensembles. And they expect to teach with this character.

I had a conversation with one of the faculty members in my school, and they opened up on how today’s test we take are easier compared to the one’s students took 10 years ago. Standards have had to be lowered for students to join the program so the school can meet its numbers.( FYI my college is really big) Even though I’m not the best, This faculty member was very happy to actually see me trying despite my long distance commute. He gave me solid advice and encouraged me to stay strong.

This is not a problem that only freshmen have, it goes up to the juniors in my school. It’s a bit scary, that when I speak to others students that are not music majors, or simply high school students, they carry this same behavior of simply enjoying the ride and not doing the bare minimum; They rely on a machine to do their work for them. If this is what we are becoming as a society, mindless-sloppy- creatures, It really saddens me but also encourages me to become a teacher and help this new generation that is being exposed and taught such behavior.

If anyone else experiencing this, or is it just my school’s problem? I’m curious and worried


r/MusicEd • • 2d ago

Don’t do a DMA in Music Ed

49 Upvotes

I am a recent former grad student who was pursuing a DMA in music ed and was catfished by my former program. They lied about funding and support and the type of courses and program design I would actually be able to do. The more I’ve talked with people in the field, do a PhD in music ed NOT a DMA in music ed. And for sure don’t pay for your degree where it takes most people 6-7years! What a horrible experience, don’t be fooled like I was.


r/MusicEd • • 1d ago

Seeking Advice

8 Upvotes

I'm sorry if this isn't allowed in this sub, I thought it might be appropriate.

I'm a freshman majoring in Music Education, and I know I really want to teach music in the future, I'm just having trouble with motivation in general when it comes to music. I feel like I'm so far behind all the other students, and I'm also having trouble getting myself to practice every day.

I guess what I'm asking is if anyone ever experienced a problem similar to this while working towards their degree, and what kept you from giving up and switching majors. I'm 100% confident this is what I want, I just can't get myself to prove it.

Any guidance or anecdotes from a similar experience would be greatly appreciated.


r/MusicEd • • 1d ago

Seeking Interviewees for an Elementary Music Songwriting Study

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/MusicEd • • 1d ago

I’m making a series of guitar tab practice videos for jazz standards. Would this be useful in your lessons?

0 Upvotes

I’m starting a series of timed guitar practice videos with tab for Real Book standards. First up: “500 Miles High.” The channel is new and I’d love feedback from teachers. Would you use something like this with students, and what would make it more useful? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xgk77Zfmmq0


r/MusicEd • • 1d ago

3rd Grade Song Choice advice

4 Upvotes

My 3rd graders are doing recorders for a winter performance, Jingle Bells is in the rotation, I didn't want to go too heavy on all recorder music so I gave them 2 selections they could pick... they wanted Raining Tacos on Recorder, that was OK since it was thier choice BUT 3rd choice they want to sing Ariana Grandes "Santa Tell Me" lyrics are I feel too spicy for 3rd graders BUT I also had my 5th grade parents last year give me the OK on Keisha Cole Love.....

Do I go ahead with Ariana Grande or pull it and replace with a more age appropriate song?


r/MusicEd • • 2d ago

Audiating, do you have a physical response?

8 Upvotes

I'm observing a HS choir while they work on sight reading, and after tonicizing a pitch they audiate the example. One thing I noticed is that whenever I audiate something, I actually have a physical response like a movement in the throat and tongue in response to higher and lower pitches, even though no sound is coming out. This seems to help A LOT. When I force myself to be still, the pitch isn't anywhere near as strong in my mind's ear. I'm wondering if anyone has a similar experience before I bring it up with the choir director.


r/MusicEd • • 2d ago

Nervous about upcoming auditions and returning to School at 30

5 Upvotes

Howdy folks, as the post suggests, I'm 30 years old, and looking to return to school as a music education major. After being kicked out of my home at 17 for being gay, I joined the Army for 3 years, then transitioned to the national guard so I could go to college. I went into an intensive Chinese language program that I did successfully for about 3 years up until my NG deployment. After the deployment, the program I was in didn't have the classes I needed until the following fall (11 months away) and I was forced into the workforce.

I had a pretty solid career in supply-chain management -> client management for 7 years, but was eventually laid off in early August. I had a lot of time to sit with my thoughts, as this was the first time in my adult life I wasn't in school full-time or working full-time. I realized that the well paid career I had fallen into was not "the dream job" childhood me wanted, and that my entire career path had come from a place of reactionism. Growing up, I had always wanted to be a high-school band director.

Looking back, I took every opportunity available to me as an adult to participate in some type of ensemble, whether that was my college's wind ensemble/marching band/chorus, the Philadelphia Gay Men's Chorus, Tuba Christmas, pit-orchestra for local theatres, or the Philadelphia Freedom Band. My favorite parts of each organization or ensemble I participated in was the community outreach and getting to work with kids/teenagers. When a kid sees my tuba, they are always in AWE and I love the opportunity to sit down, talk about the instrument and foster that little musical light in their eyes.

I want to be a music teacher for a few reasons, but the biggest reason is that when I was a closeted kid in Georgia, my band teacher was the one who was always there for me. He was the reason I switched from trombone to tuba, gave me private lessons, quelled the bullying I received, and helped me work my way into honor bands. He taught me that music is hard work, but that hard work is extremely rewarding. He and his wife (our chorus teacher) also let me hang out in the band room after school for "extra practice time" so I could avoid going home. I'll never forget Mr. and Mrs. Clark, and I want to be that person for others.

All that to say, I'm very nervous about my upcoming audition and the prospect of returning to school in my 30's. I had the opportunity to chat with my band director and our assistant band director about the audition, and they helped me pick out my audition pieces. I'll be playing Tyrell's #4 and #5 as well as Suite for Tuba mvmt 1 and 2 by Haddad. I've got the pieces down pretty well, but I'm nervous that I'll whiff the audition the day of. I'm worried that they're seeking perfection, and that the tricks I've picked up over the years playing tuba will end up being my downfall. I think I'm even more nervous about the idea of being the oldest person in every class for the next few years.

I would love any advice I can get on quelling nerves, both for the audition itself and for being the oldest person in my classes.

Thanks in advance, everyone!


r/MusicEd • • 2d ago

Hello, I post here a survey on a ways in which people learn and find music to learn more on this topic. This should take around a few minutes for you but will be greatly appreciated.

Thumbnail
forms.gle
0 Upvotes

This is generally to find out how most people find of music are learning in this current age


r/MusicEd • • 2d ago

I'm working on this for my bachelor thesis – what do you think?

1 Upvotes

hey all, I'm 24 and from Germany

I'm building this since 1 year. I'm genuinely after fedback because im also writing my bachelor thesis about this Program (business informatics).

I built a browser beat maker (Make a Beat) with a free school link: put a QR code on the projector, kids scan it with a tablet or chromebook and they're straight in their own studio. No accounts, no emails, nothing to install, no tracking. Free for up to 40 kids.

They can make drum beats, write melodies in a piano roll, play with a synth and record vocals.

would you actually use this in class? and what would stop you?

Everything helps, thank you!!


r/MusicEd • • 2d ago

i’m so tired

6 Upvotes

i am a junior choral music ed major, and i don’t even know how long i have left before i graduate. the past couple semesters i’ve had this issue where i start strong but then something happens that tanks the semester and ends with me failing classes. i also work with a theater company and do a crap ton of work for them, including teaching 16 lessons a week (my first time teaching lessons). i just keep getting beat down by both classes and this company, and i don’t know what to do. i’m about to fail probably 3 classes, and i might lose a very good scholarship.

i really don’t know what to do. i know i should quit the company, but i can’t leave all the kids with the current staff who doesn’t care about them. and i can’t take a semester off because i need to keep moving forward. i’m so lost and i can’t talk to anyone about this. i’m scared that people think i just don’t care or im lazy and thats why im failing but im genuinely falling apart.


r/MusicEd • • 2d ago

Winter program

2 Upvotes

What websites are best for purchasing backing tracks for winter program songs? Ideally a vocal and non vocal version.


r/MusicEd • • 3d ago

Crazy High School Orchestra Fundraiser

7 Upvotes

Currently, I am in my second year as an instrumental music teacher. I took over a thriving high school orchestra program with great students and supportive parents.

I am feeling slightly apprehensive about an upcoming "pie-in-the-face" fundraising event that our booster club is organizing. The event has become a popular tradition every few years at our school. Following a concert, students (and their director!) change cloths and parents and friends get to throw pies in their faces. I have seen footage of past events, and it its total chaos with the students getting covered from heat to foot.

I'm wondering how other music teachers would feel about this kind of event. Have you ever gotten a pie in the face in front of your students and parents?


r/MusicEd • • 3d ago

How to start teaching yourself to play the accordion in three minutes.

52 Upvotes