Several times over the years I've wanted to run games in which the PCs, as a fairly major central activity, do performances for an audience, and have those performances have a central, combat-like mechanical role in the game. In some games, it's a circus performance, in others a musical performance, it could be acting in a play or something, probably you could even use it for giving speeches. I've slowly felt my way towards a mechanical system that I think is a good fit for this kind of thing, and I thought I'd present it here.
This won't be a full-fledged finished mechanic, it's a template for making a mechanic for your games, in the same way that you might tell someone, "Oh, okay, so here's how to make a combat mechanic: use an initiative thing, then roll to hit, then roll damage, and people have hit points, and if they reach zero hit points they get knocked out or die." Like, you aren't telling the person exactly what those rolls should be or anything, and obviously they might complexify that template in any way, but it's nice to have a starting place.
The Basic Idea
Fundamentally, what you're doing here is making a series of rolls to add excitement to one or more audiences. Your audience starts at zero or low quantity of excitement, and you have a fixed number of rolls available to get them over some thresholds which causes you to "win" the performance and get some reward.
However, you need to match keywords with the audience. A given audience is excited more and less by certain things. For example, they might like Thrilling circus acts, or they might like Funny circus acts, or they might like Melodic music or Danceable music. If you give a well-executed performance that's delivering something that the audience doesn't really like, you get zero or low amounts of excitement for it.
There might be multiple different groups in your audience! Maybe half of your audience really likes Fast music, and the other half of your audience really likes Melodic music. You might be able to deliver fast, melodic music, or you might have to choose one or the other for a given roll. We treat each group in the audience that has different tastes as a separate entity, like they are a different monster in a multi-monster encounter.
Figure Out Your Keywords
Keywords should be largely decided before the start of the game. You probably want to figure out like maybe five to ten total keywords -- that gives enough that you can have a pretty diverse set of audiences (which will be important for driving diversity in performances), without giving the PCs so many bases to cover that they just can't do it. PCs will likely specialize to one degree or another in delivering a couple of different keywords, so if you have more PCs, you might want more keywords.
Generally, keywords should be sort of moods or emotions or styles that a variety of different performances might be able to activate. It's tempting to have keywords be genres or types of performance (like, for example, for music you might think, "Okay, Rock, EDM, Folk, Classical"), but what you want is something that the PCs can deliver. Are they a band that can play both Rock and Classical music? If so, cool, but if they're a rock band, you want different keywords that a rock band can deliver without morphing into a classical symphonic orchestra. So you might go with "Melodic, Anthems, Intricate, Danceable, Angry, Sad, Happy" or something. The keywords don't need to be all tightly the same thing -- you can have some emotions and some styles, for example. This is a good place to think about connecting your performances to the ultimate themes and aesthetics of your game. It can be productive to design your keywords in collaboration with your players if you're that kind of group.
Design the Audience
Audiences basically have keywords they like, maybe keywords they dislike, and excitement thresholds.
You can either just give them keywords they like ("Okay, these guys like Happy and Melodic music"), or, if you crave more fine differentiation, you could rate how much they like each keyword, potentially including negative numbers for disliked keywords.
Thresholds are just sort of the overall difficulty of the audience. A tough crowd has high thresholds, an easy crowd has low thresholds.
Again, there can be multiple "audiences" in one audience -- that is, multiple subgroups of the audience that have different tastes. You just track each group separately -- they have their own thresholds, their own excitement levels, their own keyword preferences. Start off with one audience in your first performance and ramp up to multiple audiences as the players gain facility with the system.
The size of the performance
After you set up the audience, you have to figure out how many rolls the PCs get in the performance. This should at least abstractly and loosely correlate with how big a show they're doing. If the PCs are doing a tight 15 minute set at a local bar, they get fewer rolls than if they're doing an hour-long concert, right? If you want you could make it one roll per song, or one roll per act of the circus, or scene of the play or whatever, or make it abstract, like this is for the first part of the performance, but just communicate the limits to the players in advance. Make it so that the performing PCs each get at least I would say two rolls in a normal performance.
If you want to add complexity here, you could make the limit somewhat uncertain, like maybe add a mechanic for encores or whatever -- like the thing in 8 Mile where Eminem/Rabbit goes extra long after the supposed cut-off in his final rap battle. If so, you want to do some kind of push your luck thing here. Maybe increased difficulty for the rolls the players make, with an excitement penalty if they fail them.
Performance Actions
Okay, so now the PCs make actions that are in the basic format of "I do a performance that's <keyword(s)>, I roll and <succeed/fail>." So "I do a Melodic performance, I got an 18, basic success." Performance actions, generally, affect all of the audiences in this performance simultaneously (everyone's listening/watching). If the action is successful, you add an excitement amount to each audience that's determined by a combination of the keywords of the action, the keywords that that audience is interested in, and potentially the degree of success of the roll if your game supports that.
So a really basic thing would be: "Choose a single keyword, roll at basic difficulty. If you are successful, add 1 excitement to each audience, and a second excitement if they like the keyword that you chose."
How do you determine the keyword(s) that the player is targeting? Some combination of player choice and character skill. Different PCs should be better and worse at hitting different keywords. Your acrobat is good at Thrilling performances but isn't as good at Funny performances, right? Your moody singer is good at Sad songs but less good at Fast songs.
This can be as mechanical or non-mechanical as you prefer. You can nail everything down ("You can do Danceable or Anthems actions at difficulty 1, Angry or Happy actions at difficulty 2, and Intricate or Sad actions actions at difficulty 3, and if you want two keywords add their difficulties together and then add 1 to the total"), or you can say, "Describe your performance to me and we'll discuss what keywords it activates," or something in between. Think of this a lot like the difference between games where you have a laundry list of precisely specified attacks versus ones where you do a lot of description in-game.
Especially for a band, you might want their actions to be literally in the form of songs, like your song Brass Butterfly has keywords such-and-such and requires this roll, you need to choose which song you're executing for each roll.
You can use all the mechanical knobs and levers that you'd expect in any kind of mechanical subsystem here. Give players resources to spend to add additional keywords to their actions or get bonuses on their rolls. Give them the ability to make higher-risk/higher-reward actions where they get more excitement if they succeed but cost excitement if they fail. Do team-up actions. The normal RPG design toolkit can be pretty easily put into place here. You might have an intermediate audience threshold level (they're "warmed up") which unlocks better actions for some players -- that creates a niche within the performance where player A is good at warming up the audience and then player B comes in once they've hit another level.
In general, I'd say that audience excitement levels should always be changing. The crowd is either warming up or cooling down. In most games, it'll feel better if you can't no-op on a performance roll -- if you fail, the audience (or that particular audience) loses excitement instead of gains it.
In terms of which players get to roll at which times, you want something that prevents the player who has the highest rolls or the easiest time hitting particular keywords to do all the rolls for the group. It's totally fine to just rotate around and have each player take a turn as though this were a conventional initiative system in a combat. Or you can have some other system that allows more flexibility, but gives the players all a chance to contribute and have some spotlight. Just don't put a mechanical incentive in place for a single player to just be the only performer.
(Performance actions -- especially in things like a band or a choir -- might be inherently to some degree cooperative, but I'd still spotlight certain players. This song has a guitar solo, so the guitarist plays and other people can roll to assist. This song really depends on intricate bass playing. Nobody wants their player to do nothing but roll Assist actions, so move that spotlight around, and be wary of setting up a situation in which everyone rolls for every action, which can be a lot of rolling for little movement).
Figuring out the keywords
So how do you as a player know which keywords to target? A few options:
- The GM might just tell you what the audience likes
- You might have to figure out by doing -- take your best guess, see whether the audience warms up or cools down, now you have some information for the next action
- But also it might be something where some pre-performance roleplay or mechanical actions can play into the game -- basically do some reconnaissance. Chat with the patrons in the bar, maybe observe the audience as they mill around in your sideshow, observe other bands play for the same group, whatever, this can all add a lot of flavor to the idea that you're performers.
- If you have a "manager"-style character, or a PC who performs but isn't as focused on being The Best Performer/Soloist, a mechanical role for them might be the person who figures out keywords during the performance -- while you make your Performance Action, they take a Perception Action and get some info about how many audience groups there are and what keywords each gets.
Rewards
Ultimately, if you get over a threshold for an audience, you're successful (think: you defeated that monster). If you take all of your audiences over their thresholds, you defeat them all. You should get some kind of reward. It might be that your band's Fame level increases. It might be that your happy audience goes into your sideshow and spends a ton of money there and you get Mad Loot. It might be that there's some system where experience or some kind of metacurrency gets paid out to the players if they succeed.
You can have multiple thresholds for an audience for normal rewards and extra rewards, or scalar rewards past some threshold. If you get some of your audiences but not all of them over the threshold, you might get partial rewards, or maybe you need everyone past the threshold for it to be an overall successful performance.