r/RPGdesign • • 3h ago

Mechanics Avoiding free 'perception' 'insight' or 'knowledge' checks

20 Upvotes

Every roll in a scene is structured more or less like this: You try to climb this fence before the dog gets you- success is getting over the fence, failure is the dog gets you. There is never a roll to climb a fence under no pressure, and there is never a roll to avoid the dog that doesn't involve also solving the obstacle (whether that's hiding, fighting, or playing dead, the player has to attempt something).

Easy for physical actions or social plays. But how does that work for perception, insight, or knowledge?

"perception checks' don't work like most games- I combined stealth and vision into one stat, Scout, and you roll this to determine if you have the jump on whatever's around, or whatever's around has the jump on you. Otherwise everything that could be perceived in a calm scene is described.

'Insight' rolls combine people reading and manipulation. If you want information, you have to probe for it- ask a leading question, give false information and see if they notice, slip in a dogwhistle. You gain information from how they react if you succeed, but the probing action gives penalties for failure- you reveal your motive, your fear, your suspicion and get nothing from it as you fail to manipulate them.

So far so good. But then we come to knowledge rolls.

Your party comes upon a twelve foot tall bipedal fur clad creature with a penchant for sucking out brains through its victims eye sockets with its long prehensile tongue. Someone asks if they got any clue what this is. it seems to me the options are:

  • The free roll I want to avoid: A zero consequence roll that can only provide a reward and which the whole party will dogpile. It's fine but it's inconsistent with every other roll in the game.
  • The always costly option: Time passes as you think through the possibilities. Whether you succeed or fail, the enemy accomplishes something (unless they don't know you're there, in which case it's the free roll). Probably fine, but again, inconsistent, 'you succeeded the roll but the monster escaped' isn't how any roll should work.
  • The silly option: Give false information on failure that the player will know is false but the character wont. Oh you rolled a 1 on this DC6 knowledge roll? Yeah this is zombie bigfoot, and he's allergic to bubblegum. Hate. Despise. The worst.
  • Somehow doing an opposed roll. I want to know if it fears fire, so I'm going to throw a molotov cocktail but instead of rolling aim to throw it I roll the relevant knowledge skill and if that roll is good I learn something without getting hurt (doesn't necessarily mean the fire works or doesn't), and if it's bad I get mauled and learn nothing? Weird, don't like it, head hurts just thinking about how this works in the best case let alone edge cases.
  • Knowledge rolls are free but have to piggyback another roll. Throw the molotov as normal, then understand what you're seeing happen. Ends up with the dogpiling again.
  • No rolling allowed, the character knows or doesn't based on their history and/or the relevant skill, and/or a resource they can spend. Just amounts to a lot of "Hey DM tell me please." Effectively the same as the free roll, but it's consistent with other rolls because it's not a roll at all.
  • Knowledge skills are for downtime only- all you can do in the moment is gather evidence by attempting things. You can shoot it in the head and see it's resistant, run away, use that evidence as you do your research and learn it's a Capelobo and you can shoot it in the naval next time.

Some of these I like more than others, but I'm not happy with any. Any mechanics y'all use/recommend looking at from other systems?


r/RPGdesign • • 6h ago

Moving off Homebrewery for layout, what should I try?

4 Upvotes

I've done all my layout in the Homebrewery so far, which was fine while I was making 5e stuff. Now I'm working on sci-fi and it's getting painful. Everything is built around the D&D look, and getting anything else out of it means fighting with CSS.

I want something with more control that's still easy to pick up. InDesign feels like overkill for me. Is Affinity worth learning, or is there something else people use?

Bonus if it handles print on demand without a headache.


r/RPGdesign • • 0m ago

What I Believe to be a Step in the Right Direction.

1 Upvotes

A few months ago, I decided to really dive deep into game design, ludology, and ludonarrative. This sub has definitely been a big positive influence on me, and it took me a long time to realize one of the main things holding back my ideas and personal projects...

I didn't really have anything I wanted to present, anything I genuinely wanted to offer to potential players. I had a million ideas for adventures and scenes that I wished were possible with the systems I played, and that led me to create some pretty simple homebrew content. Later on, I decided to take a chance and start writing my ideas for my own system. I was spreading my attention across too many things, too many concepts. I kept thinking about different ways to read dice, different ways to track Hit Points, inventory systems, and so on. But the most important thing, the most fundamental one, was something I never had: a finish line. And that surprised me in a way. In several books I've read, right after the section titled "What is game design and what does a game designer do?", the next paragraph is usually "it all starts with an idea."

For those who have been here for a long time, this might seem like a pretty obvious and even silly realization. But I know that whenever I thought about creating a system, I wanted to reinvent the wheel. I wanted to come up with something nobody had ever thought of to solve a problem like bookkeeping in more tactical systems, or something along those lines. And I can say that studying hasn't killed or diminished my dreams. If anything, I think it has made me more certain about them.

For a long time, I kept thinking that if I built an engine, people would find a way to make the car run, even though I didn't even know if I was building an engine for a car, a truck, a train, or a plane.

I still have millions of ideas every day, just like I always have. But now I stop whatever I'm doing, write them down, and get on with my day, almost as if I'm letting those ideas settle for a while. I believe I'm still a long way from making something I'm truly happy with. Even when it comes to a setting, I'm passionate about so many genres, and so many different works inspire me.

But the point of this whole post is that I'm happy to be taking a new direction toward making this dream come true, and I have a lot to thank this community for. Even though I sometimes come across rude comments, there's one thing that shows up quite often in the comments of pretty much every post, and it was one of the keys to this new way of thinking: "What do the characters do?"


r/RPGdesign • • 13h ago

Mechanics Concentration Mechanic

10 Upvotes

Hey everyone, in D&D Concentration is a mechanic used to limit how many powerful and persistent effects a single magic user can maintain at once. It also opens up some strategic counterplay where you can attempt to break concentration on someone to end a concentration effect. Is this pretty common among other TTRPGS? What other methods are you using to achieve similar ends, or do you prefer a more abundantly accessible approach to persistent effects?


r/RPGdesign • • 20h ago

Mechanics How to make a Classless system?

19 Upvotes

I am making a TTRPG, and I would like some input on How to make a Classless system work.
(This post has an overview of the Resolution mechanics)

Since I want all types of different Playstyles to be possible, I have been tinkering with a simple Feat system, Where Players get 1 Feat of their choice per level up, and Where Feats have no pre-requisites between themselves, and focus more on mechanical diferences rather than just bonuses. This system works, in the sense that characters have a concise number of Feats at the end (6 Feats total), and each Feat feels pretty unique.
(Important: The system has some other forms of progression related to the setting, I didnt go in further detail, simply because this post is already a wall of text)

But this idea also has some clear limitations and drawbacks, the biggest one being that my self imposed limit of “not having other feats as pre-requisites”, kinda makes it hard to buiild specific Playstyles further, since they kinda exist in isolation, multiple Feats can touch on the same mechanic and complement each other, but they cant build on the mechanics other Feats introduce.
The obvious solution would be to just ignore this limitation, but I am afraid that this Will “force” a players hand, and make similar builds kinda the same.

Overall I would like a small number of Feats, just cause other versions of the system had like 20+ Feats at higher levels, and they became WAY too much to keep track of.
I even experimented with gating certain Feats via Level, but this ended on Players always choosing the “higher level” feats.

Thats about it, I just want some direction some other ways to make a Classless system work, and How to avoid some of the issues I am currently facing.


r/RPGdesign • • 23h ago

Promotion Level One Realms: a free game designed for people who have never played a TTRPG

30 Upvotes

Hello! Today is the launch of my game, Level One Realms!

You can download it for free at:

wiredangel.itch.io/levelonerealms

It's a rules-light game, specifically designed to provide an accessible and easy entry point for new players into the world of TTRPG (All the core rules fit into just 28 pages), so I hope it brings in a lot of people!

The Corebook is ready to play, including a one-shot adventure: IN SEARCH OF THE DRAGON CROWN!
It is also available for download a Player Handbook, pre-generated characters, and a GM screen.

It took me nearly 6 months to finish it, from the rules, layout, and artwork to the playtesting (with a little help from my friends!) but I am very satisfied with the final product, given that it is my first finished game.

Thank you for your interest! I hope you enjoy the game (or at least give it a try!) :)

I’d be happy to answer any questions you might have. Thanks so much!


r/RPGdesign • • 18h ago

[Design Discussion] Making non-combat guild archetypes (Merchant, Craftsman, Artist, Pettifogging Lawyer) genuinely viable in a lethal OSR

5 Upvotes

One of the classic traps when designing non-combatant archetypes in old-school or rules-light RPGs is turning them into either "useless baggage once initiative is rolled" or "bards/rogues wearing a different hat."

While designing Fosse & Fracassi (a D100 roll-under OSR set in a grotesque, Mediterranean Middle Ages), I wanted bureaucracy, trade, and civic guilds to carry as much weight as steel and magic. So I built an entire Strain around it: the Fraglia - a mutual-aid guild gathering workers of every art and trade to dominate the civilized world through contracts, coin, and red tape.

Instead of combat paths, the Fraglia branches into four Castes:

The Merchant: Controls supply chains, trade leverage, and resource scarcity.

The Craftsman: Shapes matter, repairs/modifies gear, and spots shoddy equipment before it breaks mid-fight.

The Artist: Manipulates culture, patronage, and public reputation.

The Pettifogging Lawyer (Azzeccagarbugli): Bends local laws, loopholes, and charters to their advantage.

To give a concrete mechanical example from our QuickStart, our pre-gen Lawyer (Messer Pettola) wears zero armor, carries only a dagger, a toga, an inkwell, and a book on regional laws, and relies on skills like:
Fine Calligraphy (55%), Legal Knowledge (40%), Persuading/Deceiving (40%), Intuition (40%), Negotiating (35%), and Drafting Contracts (35%).

Even our introductory adventure hooks the party through a Fraglia salt merchant trying to get a monthly supply contract signed by a local petty lord.

I'd love to hear your thoughts from both a design and GMing perspective:

  1. When players bring a pure bureaucrat, lawyer, or craftsman into a lethal, survival-focused game, what mechanics or scenario structures actually make them shine without bogging down table pacing?
  2. Have you played or run non-combat career systems (like WFRP's) where a civil archetype ended up steering the whole campaign?

r/RPGdesign • • 15h ago

Mechanics tearing my hair out over type charts

1 Upvotes

I'm working on a game where the core concept is "what if your standard dnd party was collecting the monsters you find like a certain monster catching game". In the process, I'm trying to develop a type chart of various elements and non-elements the creatures can have.

For the most part this is kind of easy, but things get weird when I try to apply the logic to PCs. That's because some classes (cleric and druids) have obvious elemental associations, but the rest of them don't. I suppose I could create types for them (e.g. arcane for mages, martial for fighters, technical for rogues) but these types can be so esoteric it's kind of hard to figure out how they would balance each other out


r/RPGdesign • • 1d ago

I think I might have finally gotten my pitch sorted.

15 Upvotes

I've been working on PC ECO for six years this month and it's still in alpha even with 60+ hours a week full time solo-ish dev.

I think I might have finally gotten my pitch sorted.

My key issues was I kept to trying to over explain the game because it's huge kitchen sink of stuff rather than just narrowly defining the key hook which took forever to realize.

That said, I made a key revelation in my most recent effort:

Anyone who already isn't interested likely dropped out before the end of the pitch or the "self select yes" options ended. That means I realized the "don't" for this game was actually an opportunity to educate the person who is interested with further green flags for the type of person that IS interested and still with me at that point. That insight I think is what made me hit the right balance between education and excitement. Telling them reasons why to not play, need not be negative press and I think that's the most valuable lesson, which I kind of knew, but didn't functionally incorporate till this draft.

I was also stern on not overpromising anything and doing my best to avoid buzzword and hype language, anything claimed needed to be actually supported with evidence within the game... ie not what it's trying to be or wishes it was, but what it actually, identifiably, is.

I may revisit if the game is more before the end, and it's almost certain to be, but only in the sense that it adds critical data for the hook, not what the game is in total, and I think this version strikes the right chord, less operational lingo and acronyms, but enough to make it feel relevant to the game.

Give it a read. Tell me about the impact of it. I'm strictly not trying to sell you the game, so you don't have to be interested, just explain whether or not the information hits like it should for a good pitch, given the stated values I mentioned.

Draft:

In Project Chimera: Enhanced Covert Operations (PC:ECO), you are an augmented operative on an elite crisis-response squad for a global private military contractor; genetically modified, heavily trained, and backed by black-budget tech. You deploy into deniable conflict zones, corporate proxy wars, covert black-sites, or undercover on a near-future Earth where megacorps are the real governments and celebrity "superheroes" are mostly just corporate PR assets.

Your team has the firepower to level a building, and every reason not to. Risk of injury and capture, evidence discovery, overwhelming security responses, and geopolitical blowback make open combat the riskiest and last tool you’ll want to reach for in your kit. Built around prep work, tradecraft, and social engineering, the system rewards sharp intelligence gathering and desperate improvisation under strict client or corporate command constraints. When violence erupts, it’s fast, visceral, and lethal, but a proper ghost run leaves zero witnesses, zero bodies, and zero trace your team was ever there.

How to self select for PC: ECO.

Say "Yes" to PC: ECO if you want:

  • High-Tension Prep & Tradecraft: You love casing targets, spoofing credentials, manipulating informants, and executing complex operations where the legwork is just as thrilling and impactful as a breach.
  • Apex Capabilities with Real Consequences: You want to play a Tier-One augmented specialist, not a street-level scrub, knowing that the bigger your budget and abilities, the higher the stakes and the uglier political and tactical fallout when things inevitably go sideways.
  • High-Stakes Combat and Missions: You hate slogging through 90-minute "hit-point sponge" turns. You want gunfights to feel terrifying, tactical, and decisive—making a clean, bloodless ghost run feel like an actual rush or wave of relief.
  • Coordinated Squad Play & Gray-Area Ethics: You thrive on tight team synergy, creative problem-solving, and navigating murky contracts where shadow buyers insulate themselves from your dirty work but still have all their fingers in the operational pie.
  • A System That Proactively Assists the GM: Whether you’re a new GM learning to run reactive sandboxes or a veteran tired of heavy prep, the book streamlines session startup so you can focus at the table on improv, pacing and story instead of micromanagement; plus the game has built-in options for rotating-GM and organized-play backstops so nobody gets stuck carrying the table forever. 

Skip PC: ECO if you want:

  • Kick-Down-the-Door Power Fantasies: If your favorite game loop is recklessly charging rooms, tanking assault rifle hits with a grunt, and looting bodies for "loot-candy" upgrades without worrying about QRF blowback, media spin, or other direct consequences this system will actively punish you.
  • Black-and-White Heroics: If you want clear-cut villains, moral certainty, and saving the world with a clean conscience, you won't find it running deniable ops for shadow buyers with agendas hidden inside agendas.
  • Pure Rules-Lite Improv with Zero Prep: While the system streamlines GM workload, players who dislike tactical planning, legwork role playing, and weighing hard operational trade-offs won't click with the core game loop.

Edit:

Appreciate the insights so far.

For the record, the bits you guys did zero in on some things that were subconsciously bugging me, namely comparative stuff that should be stripped. Also the checklist wasn't made clear but wasn't meant to be a follow up inclusion, so that's understood as well, but it was intended to be early on. The min first two paragraphs are the main pitch.


r/RPGdesign • • 17h ago

Of professions and classes

1 Upvotes

So after talking a bit with ppl I know i saw that my original plan on how i handle professions needs to be looked again in what versoin would REALLY speak to people.

my plan was: profession pseudo classes, that give you (gatherer as example) the ability to gather different things as you level or become more efficient in it. But I was told that is just book keeping and ppl dont want it. and if these professions would be giving combat abilities that would be worse. Then again I heard that the shin megami tensei approach (which has classes like playboy) is fully okay.

Thus my question here. I will use Morrin (a dwarf...his classes are irrelevant for this small question of mine) as example. My main thing is: which of the options would speak most to people and...why?

He was once a temple guard and later a sellsword, he also skinned the wolves he slay and cooks meals (lets call it cooking).

Temple Guard (level 3), Sellsword (level 2), Tanner (level 2), Cook (level 1)

Variant a: Only proficiencies (fixed)

Temple guard: 1 single heavy armor, 1 single light weapon, perception, lore: temple guard



Sellsword: 1 single light or heavy melee weapon, insight, perception, lore: sellsword



Tanner: crafting, survival, knife (light weapon)  lore: tanner



Cook: knife (light weapon), crafting, constitution save test, lore: cook

Variant b: Only proficiencies (Prosa)

Temple guard:

	\-1 single heavy armor

	\-1 single light weapon

	\-Noticing anything out of order (general hearing,...)

	\-Sensing lies



Sellsword:

	\-1 single light or heavy melee weapon

	\-Haggling

	\-Sensing lies

	\-Noticing ambushes and traps



Tanner:

	\-Get leather off of animals and treat it

	\-Identify leather types and which animal it belongs to

	\-knife (light weapon)



Cook:

	\-Cooking

	\-Resisting  toxins and bad food

	\-Identifying food and its ingredients

Variant c: Profession classes

Crafter (1st Speciality: Cook)

	\-Creation/Destruction

	\-Identify and analyze



	Skills (1 chooseable per level, additional speciality takeable multiple times):

	Proficienices:

	\-Efficient Crafting

	\-Material Efficiency

	\-Quality Work

	\-Improvisation

	\-Reverse Engineering

	\-Salvage

	\-Additional Specialty



Gatherer (1st Speciality: Tanner)

	Proficienices:

	\-Gathering/Harvesting

	\-Identify and analyze



	Skills (1 chooseable per level, additional speciality takeable multiple times):

	\- Efficient Gathering

	\- Improved Yield

	\- Rare Finds

	\- Careful Extraction

	\- Faster Gathering

	\- Resource Appraisal

	\- Additional Specialty



Warrior (1st Speciality: Temple guard, 2nd Speciality aka taking additional speciality once: Sellsword)

	Proficienices:

	\-Choose a single weapon

	\-Choose a single armor



	Skills (1 chooseable per level, additional speciality takeable multiple times):

	\-Weapon Training

	\-Armor Training

	\-Shield Training

	\-Combat Drills

	\-Battlefield Awareness

	\-Combat Conditioning

	\-Additional Weapon/Armor Training

Variant D: shin megami tensei like approach

There is ONLY classes.

	Like swordsman (charge, mighry gust, birght might, cover, heatwave,....)

	black mage (bufu, limited demon summoning, grimoire contract, forbidden knowledge,...)

	but also things like: hacker (computer operation, analyze, limited demon summoning, ...), playboy (lucky, financial resources, seduce, sexy gaze, taunt, ...), detective (think like a snake, detectives hunch, art of persuasion, ...).

r/RPGdesign • • 1d ago

How to Defeat Your Players?

22 Upvotes

It's no coincidence that the vast majority of TTRPG's involve combat in some form or fashion. Whether it's true combat with sword or guns, or other kinds of contested conflict in the form of "sanity" or "willpower". But a big-big problem I notice consistently with games like D&D and your fantasy heartbreakers is that a party defeat and a TPK are functionally the same thing.

The option to run away is there only in technicality and players are essentially never incentivized to break off an encounter and dip before it gets too bad. Usually because the first indication that they should run is that multiple party members are already down. And if the remaining ones flee, the expectation is that the downed characters will die. This often leads to the cycle where the moment a party member goes down, the ability to flee is essentially lost and the remainder is forced to stay, live or die.

So when you run these games, the vast majority (if not all) of encounters are victories for the players. Either that or every TPK becomes, "you all wake up in cages." But this doesn't make for very exciting storytelling. Sometimes it's nice to introduce a threat and have it kick your player's butts, forcing them to back off, regroup, and come up with a better plan.

Have you included defeat mechanics that solve this problem and create more interesting storytelling moments? I'd like to hear them if you have!

EDIT: I may have written this confusingly that it seems like I'm personally asking how to incorporate defeat mechanics, but what this topic really is is a discussion post for people who've come up with cool defeat mechanics for their games that isn't just a TPK! Sorry if that wasn't clear! Lol.

I am not looking for assistance. I'm creating a discussion post about the concept.


r/RPGdesign • • 13h ago

Mechanics Lore Deck: a easy way to manage lore on the fly and during prep.

0 Upvotes

My pitch: go get a deck of cards and a sharpie to fix your issues with getting the right amount of lore for your custom campaigns involving sandbox exploration.

If done right, it sets up foreshadowing and keeping players on track. On each card write a few words to help encompass a critical piece of lore that obviously has more details in it, but is represented by the card, such as "Shadowfell" or "Tiamat", depending on your campaign.

What's critical lore exactly and how do you know when you have it? In this method, it's lore that's ever present even if you feel your players have finished the arc of that lore, where even it's absence has a impact. Have a big war that's unresolved, perfect, if it gets resolved it still has impact, especially if your players resolved it. A big war that changed everything, it's already over but that change has memorials and whatnot. Big questions like "what happens when someone dies in the campaign?" Maybe leave the question half answered and leave some mystery for the table.

But into the details, ratios of your lore matters. Of 52 to 54 cards, you should only draw about 8 cards, 4 for prep and 4 for when your players won't drop something, so about 15% of your lore each session, of those cards you should have 16 be your main story or your BBEG, 4-6 your plot twists/MacGuffin/BBEG backstory, 8 for general world history, 12 for side quests, and 12 for general themes like holidays (put every holiday you've considered here), local politics, wanted poster, all that small stuff. If you decide to not reshuffle the deck until you've drawn every card, that's about 7 sessions to subtly plant every seed.

Beyond that, I suggest you draw cards for prep beforehand and the unexpected moments in game. The power is in your hands after that, but it was a nice tool I use to keep my main plot in mind while not always feeling like I'm beating my players over the head with it. Plus it's always nice if a player goes to a library, gives a unexpected dungeon a theme, maybe even some character lore during session 0, or give a character you didn't flesh out something deeper your players can find, and you might enjoy the small twists you didn't plan or expect to come out of this system.


r/RPGdesign • • 13h ago

Resource Create and roll dice tables

0 Upvotes

I created this website so I could easily put new tables into them, the site is ad free, No need to verify your email, and there's a chain for credits. You can choose to make your tables public or keep them to yourself.

You also have the ability to roll a table on site, the results aren't stored though.

The website is https://dicetables.fyi/


r/RPGdesign • • 1d ago

Mechanics How do I flip this target number around?

3 Upvotes

I'm working on a somewhat hard-scifi game where the main idea is to make "bridge command"-style play, where each player is one of the command crew on a space ship, fun (I know, it's a tricky subject, but I have some ideas I haven't seen implemented in any game before so I'd like to give it a shot).

The mechanics are a counted (success counting) dicepool, your pool is normally attribute+skill+gear bonus (max 5 each, so at most 15 dice) or, when acting "through" a ship, you use the ship's attribute, your character's skill, and a bonus from the ship module you are using (again max 5 each). The pool is currently d10s with success on 8+, but I could change my mind and use d6s with success on 5+ instead without really affecting the system much. Rolls have a difficulty they're trying to meet or exceed, meaning the number of successes required to pass, with extra successes beyond that adding additional effect. I avoid opposed rolls as much as possible, and try to use static values as difficulties instead.

So to give a more concrete example, a ship's Evasion is calculated as its Engines attribute, plus its helmsman's Piloting skill, plus the bonus from its Manoeuvring Thrusters, divided by 3. That's the difficulty when firing, say, a railgun at it, which would use a dicepool of the firing ship's Weapon Systems attribute, plus the gunner's Gunnery skill, plus the railgun's Accuracy.

That's all well and good, and not really the focus of this post. I am, however, a bit stuck when it comes to electronic warfare and sensors. A ship would be easier to detect the bigger it is, and the more radiation (thermal exhaust, drive plume, EM from active sensors, weapons fire etc) it is giving off, so I'm imagining a Signature passive value derived from those things, probably fluctuating somewhat round-to-round depending on actions taken, and modified by distance. The problem is that a ship's Size trait is logically higher for larger ships, but the difficulty needs to go down for bigger ships so I can't exactly use that directly. Emitted radiation has a floor (zero, for a cold asteroid for instance) but not really a ceiling, so doing something like 10-Size-(radiation) feels weird and arbitrary.

How do I create a value that makes sense here? What formula can I use to turn a big number into a small number?


r/RPGdesign • • 1d ago

Attrition Mechanics: 3 Separate Stats vs. 1 Single Stat

1 Upvotes

I homebrewing some rules for an RPG with a more tactile, boardgame approach. And the thing I’m stumbling on this week is attrition. I very much want to track stamina/fatigue and have it affect HP, but what I wondering is: how would you feel about having three separate stamina trackers; fatigue, hunger, and thirst? Is this an interesting idea or is it too much and should I just have a single stamina bar and not overcomplicate things?


r/RPGdesign • • 1d ago

Zombie Apocalypse TTRPG Mechanics - What's good and what's bad?

6 Upvotes

Hey all!

I am looking to build a system for a zombie-apocalypse-centric world. Before I make any of my own mechanics or ideas, I want to know what other people have played and what they liked or disliked about them!

I am honestly not too familiar with a lot of systems; I've only watched some here and there, but I love the genre and want to know how to make it the best it could be!


r/RPGdesign • • 13h ago

My rules say to spend an eye. My playtester wants change.

0 Upvotes

“If I pay with this one, how many little ones do I get back?” Kit has a finger on the biggest eye in the village treasury. The rest of us had been spending them like coins in a game about a giant who lends his sight to people going underground.

My rules say that you give the giant one eye to see through a closed door. On the prototype sheet they’re all the same black dot. On the table I wanted something that would rattle when you shook the bag. That’s where the five different sizes got me. Kit fished out a fat one and set it beside the eye on a watchman’s card. They were exactly the same size. She thought she’d discovered who owned it.

“That one's worth more now,” said our thief. He meant he could sell the secret. Kit meant she should see through a thicker door. The third player had been hoarding the tiniest ones because he liked the noise.

I could replace the counters before the next run. I keep coming back to the fact that our most interesting negotiation happened over an accident in the materials. If you were revising the rule, would you let the size tell you whose sight you’re borrowing, or make all the eyes identical and see whether the bargaining survives?


r/RPGdesign • • 1d ago

Mechanics Dynamic Environment and Dealing with Different Movement Speed in Theater of the Mind.

0 Upvotes

TL;DR: Use a 2d6 system that accounts for things in the environment and player movement speed with faster speeds being adjusted to 2d8 or higher dice values for more benefits and a more reliable way to give benefits to those who like to build faster characters and like a reactive environment. If I want anything from this, I would at least like to temp DMs to run a tavern brawl with this mechanic.

I won't argue that using both systems will speed up your games or that they're even appropriate in every situation or table, but if you have ever seen a show or movie and always thought "Why does my combat in my game feel so empty" this was my solution to that feeling. Now I can have a barbarian that doesn't feel like they need to draw their weapon, a archer that enjoys feeling like they can move cover to cover, and if someone starts flying around at fast speeds, they get a sudden feeling of freedom and choice everyone else can feel a bit envious of. It turned my combat into less of a chess game and more like a movie with my players helping me write the script.

Edit: To translate distances divide by 5ft to make a distance point, this will be the number a player needs to roll using their movement dice. To determine a player's movement dice divide their move speed by 5ft, that number will be the dice value they use and they will roll two of them (30ft/5=6 or 2d6, 40ft/5=8 or 2d8), if the number is odd then use one lower value dice with one higher value dice (35ft/5=7 or 1d6+1d8). Whenever a player's move speed is halved by a spell or difficult terrain, roll one movement dice, the higher value one on a odd move speed value. Whenever a player's speed is reduced, recalculate their new move speed.

On a player's turn, they can pick a target to move to and the DM can decide the amount of movement points needed (assume nothing is between the target and player) or they can roll their movement dice, decide the prop, and DM will give them options (assume props are impeding, available for aid, or player is moving quickly). If a player underrolls, DM can give them a skill check to move needed distance (skill check is against a prop in a interaction) or can roll their movement dice again to sprint or possibly use a action to deal with a prop (DMs choice). If a player over rolls or rolls high, their prop can be anywhere on their way to their objective, though assumed not right next to them. I found these two mechanics make a dynamic environment and provide somewhere to put some of DnDs crunchier distance and movement systems when using Theater of the Mind (TotM).

For the DM this makes combat prep easier as every room now only needs six props, a room size, and a running list of props in the room, though if you have fast characters that sprint around, fly, or move fast, knowing what's outside the room is recommended. Depending on the situation, some props can be excluded if it makes sense, though even in a open field I would suggest making props like rocks, grass, and bushes. For things like swimming, waves, shallows, or something odd in the water make good props too. The limits of props is the table's imagination, though props will typically be mundane.

Potential abuses, problems, and addressing them. Too many convient props? Remember that decor and visual props are not meant to be always helpful, simply in the scene, and as the DM, you get final say on whether something would be in a scene. Someone keeps rolling 11 or 12? Consider that a place might not have more than one of these props of any at all, how many dangerous appliances do you have around you normally. Prop page feeling a bit cluttered given the size of the room? Stop writing down props of it seems too much, not every room needs more than 10 props. Space is too large and distance is a big part of the combat? Put props on the prop sheet into groups, write them down in a way that conveys distance or paths if needed, this isn't the only tool you'll ever need, just another tool to consider.

End edit, thanks for the feedback.

The Explained Mechanics:

Theater of the Mind Movement substitute

Movement is a core mechic in DnD that gets overlooked often by players and DM, which feels odd when compared to fight scenes in movies or video games. In Theater of the Mind, it basically doesn't even exist, just listen to most DnD podcasts, they either don't move at all or they move in a empty feeling space. This is my attempt to give a bit more feeling to repositioning and maybe a reason to start moving in the first place. Calculating move speed: 2d6 = to 30ft, to increase by 5ft, upgrade one dice to 1d8. To increase by 10ft, upgrade both dice to 1d8. 2d4 = 20ft, 1d4+1d6 = 25ft, 2d6 = 30ft, 1d6+1d8 = 35ft, 2d8 = 40ft, etc.. To reach a destination, DM can calculate the distance like they would on a grid system and simply count each "square" of movement as 1 point. So if a player wants to move 40ft, they would need to roll a 8 or higher, anything less will subtract the needed points from the total. If a player over rolls the needed total, a DM can lower risk during travel if there was any, such as a skill check or attack of opportunity, situation dependent. If a player underrolls, the DM should explain the reason they cannot reach the destination due to the path not being direct and needing additional sacrifice or a additional skill check to achieve (don't worry, the next mechanic below covers this part in depth). Not all movement will have risk. When speed is halved, roll one of the two movement dice, usually the bigger one. When sprinting, roll twice as many dice. With movement feeling unpredictable, I found it added a new layer of intention when my players go to act, it really gave a feeling of a room feeling crowded and changing or the combat feeling oppressive and dangerous depending on how I described it.

Dynamic Environment

To do this right, I look to using multiple Theater of the Mind (TotM) props instead of a overly descriptive wall of text or even a very detailed grid that will challenge if the creator knows as much as each player might about the environment. It puts the player in the moment one might have in a tense situation and makes a battlefield a list of things to make a stage rather than a cutscene that feels like it fades into the background of the mind. I feel the two mechanics work well together as a combination as a slower movement felt like a great way to justify more props, or maybe explain why a character can move across a battlefield quickly when they use a prop to help them move quickly.

No Prop (6): the path is clear and full movement with no hangup is possible.

Visual (5 or 7): a insignificantly small item with no contextual relevance to the situation. Think cup, plate, forks, coins, or fragments. They might make a character stumble, maybe even a bit further than intended. I even let players let this prop act as a minor treasure after the battle or to pick up during.

Decor (4 or 8): a significantly large item with no contextual relevance to the situation. Think painting, large rug, mirror, rope, or shelving. A player might trip or slide on the object. Usually a good way to set up the location of a minor prop later.

Minor (3 or 9): a small object that helps given the context. A latern with a low amount of oil, a pouch of coins, bag of dirt, mug of ale, bucket, mop, or anything a player can throw and would possibly give a minion a condition. A player might actually fall and get up when they try to move, or use it to vault themselves into combat.

Major (2 or 10): a large object that helps given the context. A table, chair, breakable wall, or anything you'd expect to see used in the WWE or backyard wrestling. This should be your table to flip, chandelier to swing on, or anything big enough to all but stop a character trying to move into action.

Environmental (11 or 1): messy props that change the context, but not the environment enough to matter. Fire barrels that set other props ablaze, a sewer pipe that might flood the area knee high, a giant keg of beer that makes slippery mud, or a growing potion that someone dropped to make some props irrelevant. You should think more about how the prop will effect other props rather than influence on enemies and players, though if it does that's fine.

Event (12): you ever see a item, button, or switch and think "I should pull that but I don't want to get in trouble." This is that item. Something so big you would change the situation if you used it, create a fire too big to ignore, cast a spell that really should have been thought through.

Off stage (13+): I consider this a chance to have a player hide, leave combat, or change the scene by leaving the stage that's built. A way to let them avoid consequences of what happen in that area or maybe even set up their own scene. It also has a way of feeling like a significant amount of distance was made compared to what they might normally do, so I let them pick a prop if it makes sense. Great for that chase scene feeling when anything less than 13 feels like it could suddenly end in failure of catching up.

Spells, weapons, shields, and even armor can function as a prop too, though this is where personal, costume, or consumable props are considered. I feel its best to have a spell make a prop and/or act as a environmental or event prop, give weapons/shields a <blank> prop control tag that prevents enemies from getting a prop or aids with their own use of a prop, and have armor with a <blank> prop resistant tag that helps them maneuver around a prop or even avoid the negative effects of a prop type. Arrows, potions, throwing spears, projectiles and other consumable props also work well here to influence a area and make strategic use of warning shots, wacky martial arts jumping on spear nonsense, a race through a maze of combatants to get a item knocked out of someone's hands, or even a improv weapon for someone to use in a pinch. Altogether it makes for memorable moments in combat of a thief chasing after a gem being kicked around, while a fighter shrugs off a chair being smashed on their back, a bard using a whip to chuck a mug of ale into the face of minion, while all hell is about to break loose as the wizard is thinking between using a fireball or thunderclap in the cluttered tavern.

Final note: wildshape is crazier with this, spells are so much more destructive, cutting a table in half has become a go-to for my melee characters, and my thief player has enjoyed making small trinkets for their character to steal as a justification for moving slow at times in combat. Really let my players feel like they're part of the fun and I've had fun as a DM taking a bit less stress off myself to build every environment and simply ask the table what props make sense, if any, when they get into trouble in the most unlikely of places.


r/RPGdesign • • 1d ago

Mechanics Pains of inventory and encumbrance management

16 Upvotes

Ran games and nerded out at a local gaming convention this past weekend.

Inventory management came up more than I'd expect in discussions about pros/cons of difference systems and frequently home-brewed components.

What's this Reddit channel's take on the rules of carrying stuff?

I've seen it abstracted several ways and I'd say they're rules that feel more tolerated than enjoyed.

Track inventory by weight: the "classic" method introduced in AD&D. Your Strength score determines how much you can carry comfortably without a penalty. Item "weight" is a generalized abstraction of its actual mass and volume.

Bag of Holding: hand wave away all inventory management with magic

Slot and card based inventories: I've personally used these in Blackhack, Mausritter, Knave, and Shadowdark. It's prevalent in a lot of other systems too. Characters have a set number of slots modified by a Stat (usually Strength, Constitution, or equivalent). Something is either a negligible size, takes up a slot, or is exceptionally difficult to carry and takes up 2 to 3 slots. It's easy on paper - but can be difficult to adjudicate "free to carry" items.

Quantum inventory: Your inventory is abstracted into a Stat or some other roll to see if and how much of an item you have. This can get fiddly for players who want to intentionally pack or have items on hand.

Eyeball it: I've seen this most recently in Mothership and Fatherfog. Someone can carry whatever it makes sense for them to carry. Table uses its best judgment - which inevitably breaks down over how much loot everyone can carry.

Questions:

  1. What system do you use in your games? What lead to that decision?
  2. Which ones have you played? What are your best and worst experiences?
  3. Are there other systems I haven't listed? What are their pros and cons?

r/RPGdesign • • 1d ago

Mechanics A Template for Games Mechanics for Performances

9 Upvotes

Several times over the years I've wanted to run games in which the PCs, as a fairly major central activity, do performances for an audience, and have those performances have a central, combat-like mechanical role in the game. In some games, it's a circus performance, in others a musical performance, it could be acting in a play or something, probably you could even use it for giving speeches. I've slowly felt my way towards a mechanical system that I think is a good fit for this kind of thing, and I thought I'd present it here.

This won't be a full-fledged finished mechanic, it's a template for making a mechanic for your games, in the same way that you might tell someone, "Oh, okay, so here's how to make a combat mechanic: use an initiative thing, then roll to hit, then roll damage, and people have hit points, and if they reach zero hit points they get knocked out or die." Like, you aren't telling the person exactly what those rolls should be or anything, and obviously they might complexify that template in any way, but it's nice to have a starting place.

The Basic Idea

Fundamentally, what you're doing here is making a series of rolls to add excitement to one or more audiences. Your audience starts at zero or low quantity of excitement, and you have a fixed number of rolls available to get them over some thresholds which causes you to "win" the performance and get some reward.

However, you need to match keywords with the audience. A given audience is excited more and less by certain things. For example, they might like Thrilling circus acts, or they might like Funny circus acts, or they might like Melodic music or Danceable music. If you give a well-executed performance that's delivering something that the audience doesn't really like, you get zero or low amounts of excitement for it.

There might be multiple different groups in your audience! Maybe half of your audience really likes Fast music, and the other half of your audience really likes Melodic music. You might be able to deliver fast, melodic music, or you might have to choose one or the other for a given roll. We treat each group in the audience that has different tastes as a separate entity, like they are a different monster in a multi-monster encounter.

Figure Out Your Keywords

Keywords should be largely decided before the start of the game. You probably want to figure out like maybe five to ten total keywords -- that gives enough that you can have a pretty diverse set of audiences (which will be important for driving diversity in performances), without giving the PCs so many bases to cover that they just can't do it. PCs will likely specialize to one degree or another in delivering a couple of different keywords, so if you have more PCs, you might want more keywords.

Generally, keywords should be sort of moods or emotions or styles that a variety of different performances might be able to activate. It's tempting to have keywords be genres or types of performance (like, for example, for music you might think, "Okay, Rock, EDM, Folk, Classical"), but what you want is something that the PCs can deliver. Are they a band that can play both Rock and Classical music? If so, cool, but if they're a rock band, you want different keywords that a rock band can deliver without morphing into a classical symphonic orchestra. So you might go with "Melodic, Anthems, Intricate, Danceable, Angry, Sad, Happy" or something. The keywords don't need to be all tightly the same thing -- you can have some emotions and some styles, for example. This is a good place to think about connecting your performances to the ultimate themes and aesthetics of your game. It can be productive to design your keywords in collaboration with your players if you're that kind of group.

Design the Audience

Audiences basically have keywords they like, maybe keywords they dislike, and excitement thresholds.

You can either just give them keywords they like ("Okay, these guys like Happy and Melodic music"), or, if you crave more fine differentiation, you could rate how much they like each keyword, potentially including negative numbers for disliked keywords.

Thresholds are just sort of the overall difficulty of the audience. A tough crowd has high thresholds, an easy crowd has low thresholds.

Again, there can be multiple "audiences" in one audience -- that is, multiple subgroups of the audience that have different tastes. You just track each group separately -- they have their own thresholds, their own excitement levels, their own keyword preferences. Start off with one audience in your first performance and ramp up to multiple audiences as the players gain facility with the system.

The size of the performance

After you set up the audience, you have to figure out how many rolls the PCs get in the performance. This should at least abstractly and loosely correlate with how big a show they're doing. If the PCs are doing a tight 15 minute set at a local bar, they get fewer rolls than if they're doing an hour-long concert, right? If you want you could make it one roll per song, or one roll per act of the circus, or scene of the play or whatever, or make it abstract, like this is for the first part of the performance, but just communicate the limits to the players in advance. Make it so that the performing PCs each get at least I would say two rolls in a normal performance.

If you want to add complexity here, you could make the limit somewhat uncertain, like maybe add a mechanic for encores or whatever -- like the thing in 8 Mile where Eminem/Rabbit goes extra long after the supposed cut-off in his final rap battle. If so, you want to do some kind of push your luck thing here. Maybe increased difficulty for the rolls the players make, with an excitement penalty if they fail them.

Performance Actions

Okay, so now the PCs make actions that are in the basic format of "I do a performance that's <keyword(s)>, I roll and <succeed/fail>." So "I do a Melodic performance, I got an 18, basic success." Performance actions, generally, affect all of the audiences in this performance simultaneously (everyone's listening/watching). If the action is successful, you add an excitement amount to each audience that's determined by a combination of the keywords of the action, the keywords that that audience is interested in, and potentially the degree of success of the roll if your game supports that.

So a really basic thing would be: "Choose a single keyword, roll at basic difficulty. If you are successful, add 1 excitement to each audience, and a second excitement if they like the keyword that you chose."

How do you determine the keyword(s) that the player is targeting? Some combination of player choice and character skill. Different PCs should be better and worse at hitting different keywords. Your acrobat is good at Thrilling performances but isn't as good at Funny performances, right? Your moody singer is good at Sad songs but less good at Fast songs.

This can be as mechanical or non-mechanical as you prefer. You can nail everything down ("You can do Danceable or Anthems actions at difficulty 1, Angry or Happy actions at difficulty 2, and Intricate or Sad actions actions at difficulty 3, and if you want two keywords add their difficulties together and then add 1 to the total"), or you can say, "Describe your performance to me and we'll discuss what keywords it activates," or something in between. Think of this a lot like the difference between games where you have a laundry list of precisely specified attacks versus ones where you do a lot of description in-game.

Especially for a band, you might want their actions to be literally in the form of songs, like your song Brass Butterfly has keywords such-and-such and requires this roll, you need to choose which song you're executing for each roll.

You can use all the mechanical knobs and levers that you'd expect in any kind of mechanical subsystem here. Give players resources to spend to add additional keywords to their actions or get bonuses on their rolls. Give them the ability to make higher-risk/higher-reward actions where they get more excitement if they succeed but cost excitement if they fail. Do team-up actions. The normal RPG design toolkit can be pretty easily put into place here. You might have an intermediate audience threshold level (they're "warmed up") which unlocks better actions for some players -- that creates a niche within the performance where player A is good at warming up the audience and then player B comes in once they've hit another level.

In general, I'd say that audience excitement levels should always be changing. The crowd is either warming up or cooling down. In most games, it'll feel better if you can't no-op on a performance roll -- if you fail, the audience (or that particular audience) loses excitement instead of gains it.

In terms of which players get to roll at which times, you want something that prevents the player who has the highest rolls or the easiest time hitting particular keywords to do all the rolls for the group. It's totally fine to just rotate around and have each player take a turn as though this were a conventional initiative system in a combat. Or you can have some other system that allows more flexibility, but gives the players all a chance to contribute and have some spotlight. Just don't put a mechanical incentive in place for a single player to just be the only performer.

(Performance actions -- especially in things like a band or a choir -- might be inherently to some degree cooperative, but I'd still spotlight certain players. This song has a guitar solo, so the guitarist plays and other people can roll to assist. This song really depends on intricate bass playing. Nobody wants their player to do nothing but roll Assist actions, so move that spotlight around, and be wary of setting up a situation in which everyone rolls for every action, which can be a lot of rolling for little movement).

Figuring out the keywords

So how do you as a player know which keywords to target? A few options:

  • The GM might just tell you what the audience likes
  • You might have to figure out by doing -- take your best guess, see whether the audience warms up or cools down, now you have some information for the next action
  • But also it might be something where some pre-performance roleplay or mechanical actions can play into the game -- basically do some reconnaissance. Chat with the patrons in the bar, maybe observe the audience as they mill around in your sideshow, observe other bands play for the same group, whatever, this can all add a lot of flavor to the idea that you're performers.
  • If you have a "manager"-style character, or a PC who performs but isn't as focused on being The Best Performer/Soloist, a mechanical role for them might be the person who figures out keywords during the performance -- while you make your Performance Action, they take a Perception Action and get some info about how many audience groups there are and what keywords each gets.

Rewards

Ultimately, if you get over a threshold for an audience, you're successful (think: you defeated that monster). If you take all of your audiences over their thresholds, you defeat them all. You should get some kind of reward. It might be that your band's Fame level increases. It might be that your happy audience goes into your sideshow and spends a ton of money there and you get Mad Loot. It might be that there's some system where experience or some kind of metacurrency gets paid out to the players if they succeed.

You can have multiple thresholds for an audience for normal rewards and extra rewards, or scalar rewards past some threshold. If you get some of your audiences but not all of them over the threshold, you might get partial rewards, or maybe you need everyone past the threshold for it to be an overall successful performance.


r/RPGdesign • • 1d ago

Mechanics How do I improve my system?

5 Upvotes

Basically, I have been working on a TTRPG for a while, and even though I like the current version, I feel like it can still improve quite a lot. The basic resolution mechanic is this:
Players have 4 attributes, each represented by dice (d4 -> d12, d20 is reserved for some other stuff), and each Skill has a number from 1 to 5, that determines How many dice the player Will roll. The result of the roll is the sum of all dice rolled. So for example, a character with a d8 in Reason and 3 in investigation, Will roll 3d8 in an investigation check, they get (2,5,7), the result is 14.

This basic system works well, but I had some issues adapting it to the combat, especially because I would like a system without the basic AC, with players having to choose when, and how to defend themselves. My solution to this was Guard, basically, every character (including some enemies) has Guard Dice equal to the value of a Skill, that can be used outside their turn to mitigate attacks. There are 3 ways to use your Guard Dice, Parrying, Dodging, and Blocking, each having its own mechanic. When attacked, a Player can use as many Guard Dice as They want, but if they have none, the attack automatically hits. (Guard Dice return at the start of your turn)

Parry- Pair each rolled Guard Dice with one of the attack roll, each defender’s dice that is greater or equal than the paired one, cancels that dice out.

Dodge- Compare the highest Guard Dice rolled with the highest dice from the the attack roll, if the defender’s is higher, they take no damage

Block- Each equipament has a dice size, the player can choose to roll the Equipament die as one of the Guard Dice, it them subtracts the result from one of the damage die (will explain this soon). If you still take damage, that equipment Goes down a dice step (1d6 -> 1d4), if it Goes below a d4, it breaks.

So I had this system, and I really like it, but I had trouble deciding How the damage worked, at first I used simple damage rolls, but I felt like this bogged down combat a bit, so I changed to the same logic of Ordem Paranormal II (a brazillian system currently being developed), that uses the highest roll in the attack roll to determine the damage, so if I roll (5,2,1), I would deal 5 damage, I expanded this a bit, so that each weapon “reads” a Number of dice, so smaller weapons like a knife or a pistol would deal the highest roll, a Sword or a Rifle would real the 2 highest rolls, so and so forth.

Finally, here is what I need some help with, the main issue comes from how Firearms interact with the system, since I dont want Players to be able to Parry or Dodge bullets (at least not at the lower levels), this makes it so guns effectively cant miss their shots, which feels super weird, and kinda made me doubt the Guard system a bit. I feel like adding an AC or something similar is the fix, but I feel like it undermines the Guard a bit…

On top of that, the current Action Economy feels way to simple as well, characters only have 1 Action, Movement and their Guard Dice (that kinda work as reactions), but the other alternatives I tried didnt mesh well with the rest of the system.

I do have some other gripes, but since this post is already huge, I Will let them be for now. I would love to hear your suggestions, and feedbacks!


r/RPGdesign • • 1d ago

Light Within Clay: sandbox adventure design

5 Upvotes

Hello, fellow travelers. I just released a free adventure for my game called Light Within Clay. It's about treasure hunters exploring a lost city of golems.

https://purplepeoplegames.itch.io/light-within-clay

I've been playtesting some form or another of this adventure for almost five years. One idea that I think works really well: the bad guys arrive partway through the adventure, and the GM decides when this happens, as a kind of failsafe "increase pacing" button.

The structure has the heroes arriving at the lost city ostensibly to loot it, encountering its traps and strange denizens, and (hopefully) developing a connection with some of those denizens. The bad guys are also treasure-hunters, but they are much more depraved, and outnumber the heroes.

I give some guidance for criteria that might trigger the villains' arrival, but I think it's nice as a GM to just be able to decide when this happens, depending on how much time I have to run the game and how much the players are (or are not) having fun exploring.

The two act structure also helps encourage heroes to get into "base defense" mode after becoming familiar with the location, and maybe even come up with some Home Alone style antics for the interlopers.

If you check it out, thank you—I hope it helps you with your own adventure design. And if you've written or ran sandbox-y adventures, I'd love to hear your perspective too.


r/RPGdesign • • 2d ago

Mechanics How do I make PbtA Archetype moves that are better than the generic moves?

13 Upvotes

One thing I've ran into in some less-well-designed PbtA games is that sometimes moves you get from an archetype are actually barely better than that game's 'base' moves.

There are usually 'generic' moves, like "act under pressure" which is catch all for all sort of a dramatic action. And then say you have a Ninja archetype, with some Skulk Around move or whatever. Needless to say, the archetype's move should be 'stronger' than the base move, more enabling.

Sometimes it's easy to figure out how to top a 'base' move, but sometimes it's harder, due to PbtA's less-numerical nature. I've even seen (in a playtest so no finger pointing) games that had archetype specific moves end up playing up worse than if you were to just use the bas move.

For example:

You want to exist the scenes by parkouring around buildings. GM asks you to "act under pressure", where on 7-9 something complicates things, and on 10+ you just succeed with no notes.

But if you are playing Ninja, you might have some "Master of Rooftops" move instead, where on 10+ you select benefits from a number of bullet points - things like "put distance from your pursuers", "get to a better position", etc.

And the way it works out at the table, if you stop and think about what have transpire and what could have transpired, you realize that actually if you were just "acting under pressure" GM would (very likely) have given you all of those bullet points' narrative effect simply because "well it makes sense and you rolled 10+", which means that having to choose only some of them is actually a debuff!

And that happens sorta naturally. Generic moves says you just succeed full stop at 10+, while more specific move is... well, more specific, and through that necessarily more limited.

Now, not all moves suffer from this, there are ways to avoid this - for example, some moves give you permission so unique that they cannot be replicated though a general move, or you can just add some numerical things to the game after all. Some games if a move would be too similar to a generic one would instead turn it into a rider for a generic move.

But I've been thinking about it, since I am writing some PbtA-adjacent moves now, what are some good practices to setting up those relational things? Have you seen any interesting concepts in this field?