r/buildingscience • • 8h ago

What does breathable actually mean in the context of a building?

0 Upvotes

What does breathable actually mean in the context of a building? Does the building breathe like I do with air coming into my lungs & back out again as carbon dioxide? 
 
No, not exactly.  
 
It means that the building materials can transmit moisture. 
 
Breathable building materials are permeable enough so that any moisture from humid air & moisture from surface wetting can be absorbed & can then easily evaporate during dryer warm periods. 
 
A lot of natural, traditional building materials have inherent properties that allow moisture vapour to pass through them, they are vapour permeable. These materials can also absorb & retain moisture in vapour form [like moist damp air in the background or from a bathroom], this means they are also moisture buffering [the scientific word for this is ‘hygroscopic’]. 
 
Another way to describe these 'breathable' building materials is that they are ‘vapour open’ or ‘vapour permeable’. 
 
This is very different from some modern, synthetic building materials that are made from fossil fuels & plastic and are heavily processed. These are the opposite & therefore classified ‘vapour closed’ or ‘non-vapour permeable’. They don’t ‘breathe’. 
 
Here’s a couple of cross section sketches that show how this works in practice. 
 
Sketch 1 illustrates a breathable vapour OPEN construction. 
 
Breathable vapour open buildings mean that background water vapour is intended to enter the constructional build up, it’s not intended to stop it entering. Over the colder, damper winter months, with higher internal humidity, a certain amount of water vapour moisture can enter the build-up & is temporarily stored in the insulation. Then, over the warmer, summer months, when the internal humidity drops, the stored water vapour moisture can evaporate harmlessly into the room. 
 

Breathable vapour OPEN construction

Sketch 2 illustrates a non-breathable vapour CLOSED construction. 
 
Sealed vapour closed buildings can work but as they rely on internal vapour control membranes that are not vapour permeable, they need extremely good site workmanship [should that be ‘workpersonship’?] to ensure the insulation is fitted tightly without edge gaps and the internal membranes are installed fully sealed without any gaps or holes. In reality it’s likely there will be gaps, as I understand it is impossible to ever build a 100% fully sealed construction. 
 
Nature knows best, who’d have thought it?

Non breathable vapour CLOSED construction

r/buildingscience • • 23h ago

Do any of you building science enthusiasts garden, and have a need to overwinter a few plants?

2 Upvotes

I’ve run out of time on the central coast of NJ, and I need to get my two small citrus trees into their winter home.

Not only have I lost the battle against fungus gnats in the soil the past few years, but I never really had a place inside to keep these potted plants to begin with. No basement, no sunroom, so extra space at home anywhere :(

Unfortunately, the lemon and lime pair were purchased without considering where the plants would live during the winter. Even though I was not happy to see them arrive after they were purchased, I do like them and want to keep them alive.

I need some kind of temporary solution to overwinter these plants for 1-3 cold seasons. I have access to more than enough extra,and scrap, zip sheathing, rockwool batt insulation, and everything else to build a nice little box. All the fasteners, sealant, and tape you can dream of. I can purchase anything else needed, but I wont need much. I even have a bonus bucket of Redgard, extra fiber cement and aluminum siding, and exterior paint if I want it to look nice.

What I was thinking was a mini “shed/greenhouse”. Its joists will rest on those plastic feet people build sheds on. Insulated floor(?), insulated walls. Gable, shed, or reinforced flat roof made of plexiglass, that’s also hinged for watering the plants. Extension cord for a very small space heater with great thermostat sensor and controls. Presumably it would need some kind of waterproofing on the subfloor and a small amount of intake/exhaust, accounting for outside air temp hopefully. It’s only meant to last for 1-3 years, so upmost build quality isn’t a priority. Poor ventilation won’t bother me if I can’t make it work easily enough. Would prefer to build it well, and tight enough to keep out pests, and also not have the space heater running 24/7 trying to maintain temp.

Or is there some kind of bullshit greenhouse thing I should just buy from Amazon that will be good enough to keep the warmth in? And do you know which one would work?

Don’t need to plants to produce during the winter. Minimum need is dormancy.

Interested to hear of any of you also garden and have the same problem.


r/buildingscience • • 5h ago

Question Open cell spray foam for Michigan rim joist - does this need remediation?

2 Upvotes

I had open cell spray foam sprayed into my rim joist in a 1995 era Michigan home with an unfinished basement about four years ago. When I've dug through the foam to run wires the wood behind it seems fine. But I understand that open cell in a rim joist can promote moisture issues. Do I need to remediate this, or is it probably ok to leave as is?


r/buildingscience • • 6h ago

Smart vapor barrier for 1890s renovation

4 Upvotes

I’m trying to decide which smart vapor barrier is better for my 1890s farmhouse renovation. Foundation/ new floor system has been repaired and replaced. I’m getting closer to insulating (northern Michigan winter coming soon). Going back and forth between ProClima Intello plus vs Certainteed Membrain. Exterior of the house is original lap siding over the studs which is covered by vinyl siding ( I’m hoping when the vinyl was added there is a house wrap but I won’t be certain until I replace the windows. I’ll add the house wrap everywhere I am able if it isn’t there when the vinyl comes down for the windows.

I am leaning towards the Intello plus based on my research, only part that I am nervous about is sealing up the wall cavity too good as the house was never originally like this and there has been absolutely no rot. Current plan is to insulate with rockwool, then add smart barrier over the studs, then 1/2 inch osb to prevent further racking etc. drywall after.

Any thoughts? I haven’t reached out to either manufacturer to check thier opinions on osb going over the top and how that changes vapor permeance