r/darksouls
•
u/wozglas
•
1d ago
r/darksouls • u/e_0 • Mar 25 '26
Video Embedded video posts are now allowed
I literally don't know who the hell turned this off or when, but videos are now allowed on /r/DarkSouls. No more need to link to YouTube or other external sites.
Enjoy!
r/darksouls • u/KevinRyan589 • Aug 19 '24
Guide How To Protect Yourself From the Hacker in Anor Londo
EDIT: Added a comment below the post briefly discussing Cheat Engine and how it could be used as a pseudo method of restoring lost progress for anyone who didn’t have a backup save. The caveat might be that you can’t play online anymore after using it so double check me on that before deciding (I’ve not personally used it).
EDIT2: Thanks for the sticky! Any questions about the PvP Overhaul Mod should be asked on it's Nexus page. I personally don't mod the DS games so I have absolutely no idea what will or won't get you banned. Perform your due diligence! :)
=======================
Long story short, some doofus is ruining people's games by instantly killing Gwyndolin and any other NPCs in Anor Londo (blacksmiths, Solaire, etc). I believe this is only occurring on PC.
I've messaged the Mods requesting a stickied thread be made warning players of this and how they can protect themselves but in the meantime, I can make a thread myself that will at least get eyes on for like......today? lol
====================================
Does This Mean I Can't Play Online?
No.
You can absolutely still invade and be summoned for Co-Op to your heart's content. But it's important to be aware of the danger that's currently plaguing (seemingly specifically) Anor Londo and of the steps you can take to mitigate its impact on your experience.
This first tip is the BEST way to defend yourself, bar none.
1. Back Up Your Save
Backing up your save is the difference between a hacker mildly inconveniencing you, and soul-crushing devastation that you'll literally need a day or two to recover from before deciding to even play again.
If a hacker ruins your game by killing NPCs or an unfortunate glitch has softlocked you or any other disaster befalls your play session, simply deleting that save and restoring a recently made backup can solve those woes immediately.
Here's how to do it (PC)
- Make sure the game isn't running whatsoever (later games allow you to remain on the title screen but not DSR)
- Navigate to your Documents folder
- Open the NGBI folder
- Open the folder labeled DARK SOULS REMASTERED
- Open the next folder (it'll be a folder labeled as a sequence of numbers)
- The DRAKS0005.sl2 file is the save file
- Copy it
- Create a new folder for your saves anywhere else on your computer and paste the .sl2 file you just copied into it
- You've now made a backup of your save!
So let's say you get hacked and the Gwyndolin cutscene immediately plays and every NPC in Anor Londo dies. To restore your backup, you'll just delete the .sl2 file containing the "corrupted" game save and replace it with the copy you made earlier.
It's advised that you don't just paste and replace the .sl2 file when restoring your backups. Actually delete the compromised .sl2 file first.
This is just to protect yourself from any mistakes you might make as deleted .sl2 files can be recovered later. If you just paste and replace, the replaced file will be gone for good.
I recommend making a new backup after each hour of play to minimize the effects of a hacker or other form of corruption. That way if it happens, it won't be a big deal.
NOTE: The DRAK file contains all of your data for all of your characters. Backing up this file will back up ALL of your saved characters.
2. Download the PvP Overhaul Mod
Full disclosure, I've not used this mod whatsoever as I don't often PvP, but word on the street in the wake of this string of hacks in Anor Londo is that it'll help prevent those hacks with it's own slew of anti-cheat and netcode improvements.
Understand though that these things are never foolproof and that backing up your save is still the BEST defense against hackers or other forms of corruption.
===========================================
Hopefully this helps. Feel free to comment below if you have any other tips for preventive measures!
r/darksouls • u/soundwavesuperiors • 1h ago
Discussion My gf killed andre and the merchant Lady in seamless co-op
Seamless co-op
She accidentally killed andre and The lady and for some reason both in our world they are dead.
We both Playing Seamless Co-op we need to upgrade our weapons and stuff hoping if joining other's world in seamless would allow us to do that.
She's a newbie and well would be needing help before reaching Anor Londo where we can meet the Giant Smith.
(Para written by my gf ) I really need help updating my weapon and get more items I lowkey killed Andre and the lady near fire link shrine and was hoping if I could join someone world where they are still alive and I can trade with them and upgrade the weapon
Can someone help us please ?
r/darksouls • u/Jam_99420 • 21h ago
Lore Velka: the Goddess of Sin, Sacrifice, Atonement, and Medicine
This was originally posted on r/DarksoulsLore and I thought it might be appreciated on here as well. I’ve also made some changes and corrections, as well as a few new observations, so that this is will be an up-to-date and hopefully near comprehensive analysis of Velka’s character. Some of this post will, however, be a matter of interpretation, and there are still a few unanswered questions. It also goes without saying that since Velka is an incredibly shadowy figure within the lore, and there’s always the possibility that I may have overlooked something, my conclusions should be regarded as tentative rather than definitive. Nevertheless, I believe I may be able to provide you with a viable explanation for what the purpose of Velka’s cult [by which I mean religious following] actually was. Before I begin I’m going to leave links to a few other posts which I make reference to within this one, especially since I wanted to give due credit to the two which were written by other users:
post by user Electrical-Test proposing that the New Londo sealers are devotees of Velka:
https://www.reddit.com/r/DarksoulsLore/comments/1kvnbgg/thoughts_on_velka_the_moon_and_potentially/
post by user Meat-Puppet proposing that Velka is Gwyndolin:
https://www.reddit.com/r/darksouls/comments/154ukbm/lore_velka_is_gwyndolin/
my post on the symbolic role of Velka:
https://www.reddit.com/r/DarksoulsLore/comments/1xpgbng/velka_the_truth/
older post of mine on the Occult Club:
recent post on Priscilla’s original narrative purpose:
https://www.reddit.com/r/darksouls/comments/1xssfgw/priscillas_original_purpose/
Dark Souls design work’s interview:
https://darksouls.wiki.fextralife.com/Dark_Souls_1_-_Design_Works_Interview
Section 1: Item Descriptions
The logical place to begin is with a review of every item known to be associated with Velka, and to extend our investigation to items suspected to be associated as we construct our understanding.
Velka’s Rapier: this weapon is used by Oswald the Pardoner, and indeed it’s description suggests that this kind of sword is specifically created for use by “the Pardoner serving Velka”. The most interesting thing about it is that it has an innate occult auxiliary effect, and that it scales with intelligence despite the fact that occult normally scales with faith. An important thing to point out is that occult does not mean Dark. To make an occult weapon, you use a Divine ember and a Dark ember, therefore an occult weapon possesses the power of both halves of the Disparity. The reason this deals increased damaged against the gods is explained in my post on the occult Club [linked above], and it’s interesting to note that such a weapon would be employed by the servant of a deity.
Velka’s Talisman: a talisman for casting miracles, but it scales with intelligence. This is another instance of something that would normally scale with faith converted into a version that scales with intelligence instead. We can infer from this that Velka harbours a bias favouring intelligence over faith [at least in her priesthood, since those are the individuals who are expected to actually use these objects], but you do still need to fulfil a miracle’s faith requirement in order to cast it from this. The implication is that in order to use this talisman you’ll need both faith and intelligence, despite the fact that these are sometimes seen as opposites or even mutually contradictory. It suggests a unification of opposites, just like the occult weapon which requires both Light and Dark. It’s also worth noting that this talisman is apparently made out of Velka’s hair, which is black.
Karmic Justice: the description for this miracle tells us that Velka’s role as the “goddess of sin” is to decide what sin actually is [i.e. which actions are sinful, and under which circumstances] and what punishment is appropriate. This begs the question: if sin is defined by Velka’s personal opinion, how do we know that her decisions on the matter will be reasonable? How do we know that she will not turn a blind eye to certain injustices? What guarantee do we have that Velka’s ideas about sin and punishment are fair and just? Indeed, Oswald carries a sword with which to enforce Velka’s judgements: an instrument of violence. On the other hand, he does not normally use it, preferring instead to offer absolution via confession. Although he does recognise Petrus as being “drenched in sin”, he does not attempt to bring him to justice, nor does he try to persuade Petrus to confess, and this is why i raise the point about Velka [and her enforcers] potentially turning a blind eye in certain cases.
Vow of Silence: the description for this miracle tells us that Velka is a “rogue deity”, although this is actually a mistake in the localisation. The japanese calls her a heretical deity, which is why the localisation team have interpreted it in the way they have, but actually the term used in japanese does not necessarily imply opposition to an established religion or state of affairs. A better translation might have been "unorthodox", with the implication simply being that Velka takes an unconventional approach compared to other deities. I am not familiar with the japanese language myself, and so am dependant upon those who are to identify these localisation mistakes. Regardless, my analysis does end up favouring this view. DS3’s version of this miracle connects it with the Sable Church rather than Velka, so we should consider the Sable Church to be connected with Velka in some way.
Rings of Sacrifice: the item description says that these are created from a “sacrificial rite” of Velka, and the image in the magenta stone version strongly suggests that the thing that’s sacrificed is Humanity. This is reinforced by Snuggly, who will give you such a ring if you trade Twin Humanities with him. This is the beginning of a recurring pattern connecting Velka with the concept of sacrifice, specifically the sacrifice of Humanity.
Black Set: this is the clothing worn by Oswald, and confirms his connection to Velka although this is not surprising since he talks about sin and sells her talisman, one of her miracles, and her ring of sacrifice. The most interesting part of this set is the hat which supposedly symbolises “separation from worldly desires”, so we can infer that Velka does not approve of material indulgence, or even the desire for it. Yet the mask may suggest a certain hypocrisy in this considering it is a somewhat opulent design.
Section 2: Velka and the Painting
Many of these items are found in the Painted World, as is the Dark ember used for creating occult weapons [it is in fact right next to the rapier, black set, and the vow of silence miracle], and let’s not forget that the area is filled with crows, as well as people who have half turned into crows on account of their devotion to Velka. This led me to also investigate the painting guardians and Priscilla. The painting guardian set says that their reason for guarding the painting has been forgotten [very helpful Miyazaki, thank you] but i’m inclined to doubt a direct connection to Velka purely on the grounds that the colour of their robes is white rather than black. That being said it is interesting that the painted world contains a set of white clothing as well as a set of black clothing, perhaps very much like the white and black embers required for the creation of occult weapons.
We also have very little useful information on Priscilla, although the weapon you get from cutting her tail does have an occult auxiliary, which is interesting. Miyazaki says that Priscilla was originally supposed to be “the heroine of the story” in the design works interview [linked above], and I’ve written about what I suspect this “heroine” role to have been in a much shorter post [also linked above] on Priscilla. Although her narrative role has been scaled back in the final game, her existence suggests that the gods may have attempted to crossbreed with dragons in a failed attempt at transcending the disparity. We can also infer that Priscilla’s “lifehunt” ability is the thing that makes her the “antithesis of all life”, as well as the reason that she was trapped in the Painted World in the first place. Indeed, the Painted World appears to have been used by the gods as a sort of dumping ground for undesirables. In some cases it may be that exile to the Painting was a form of punishment, and this explains the connection to Velka. But in Priscilla’s case I suspect that she was merely considered to be dangerous and subversive, perhaps even an embarrassment, and that she was hidden within the painting for these reasons despite her unaggressive temperament. I don’t think that Priscilla ever did anything wrong, but rather that the gods feared that she might have been used to undermine their precious status quo. Interestingly, Miyazaki suggests [in the design works interview] that Priscilla might have fled to the Painted World because she was being chased, and also implies that the same thing might be true of some of the Paintings other inhabitants.
But despite the suggestion that some beings might go willingly into the Painting, the general idea seems to have been similar to Gwyn’s restraint on the Dark Soul: to keep something hidden and out of sight, but also under control at the same time. We might infer from Velka’s strong presence inside the Painted World that she is related to Priscilla in some way. I know some people think that she’s Priscilla’s mother but I’ve never been shown any actual evidence. It’s not impossible, but my suspicion is that Velka’s association with the Painted World was intended to communicate that this is a place of punishment rather than to suggest a relation to Priscilla. The painting itself is housed within a building that appears to have been a temple dedicated to Gwynevere. Not only this but a rare ring of sacrifice [associated with Velka] is located next to a divine blessing [associated with Gwynevere] in the two chests found within Ricard’s tower. I do have an explanation for the association between these two goddesses, but it has more to do with Velka’s symbolic role, but that discussion exceeds the intended scope of this post. I have, however, already written a post on that subject and it’s linked at the top of this one.
Section 3: Servants of Velka
Because Oswald is a priest of Velka, it makes sense to investigate the other items that he sells even if their item descriptions do not explicitly mention Velka. These include two of the three rings associated with Arstor of Carim, as well as Purging Stones which are also associated with Arstor of Carim. Now the question arises: does Oswald have these items because he is from the same country as Arstor, or was Arstor also a devotee of Velka? In all likelihood, the answer is both. The Purging Stone’s description says that it was once a human, or similar being. These stones also drop from the giant clam enemies in Ash Lake which appear to be digesting human remains. I suspect that it is an accident of the function of their digestive systems which causes these clams to create Purging Stones, and that Velka’s followers use an artificial version of the same process. The description of Arstor’s rings tell us that there are dreadful rumours about their creation, and this, combined with the fact that the Purging Stones are made using human remains, plus the fact that the Rings of Sacrifice [which Oswald also sells] are created by means of a “sacrificial rite”, might lead us to infer that these things are created by means of ritual human sacrifice. This might be the case, and indeed this could be the fate reserved for those that Velka judges to be the worst sinners. But there is another possibility to consider, since these are only rumours after all.
Bonfires have human bones among their ashes, implying that someone has thrown a body on the fire to kindle it using the Humanity within the corpse. But we know this this is not actually necessary for kindling Bonfires: we can use a Humanity sprite instead. Notice that the description for the Purging Stone tells us that it was once a person, or some other being. What exactly is this “other being” likely to be? My suspicion is that it is a Humanity sprite. To be clear, what I’m saying is that I think Purging Stones are fundamentally made using Humanity. For this reason they can be made using human remains [which inherently contain Humanity], but this is not necessary if you happen to have some spare Humanity sprites available. The giant clams’ digestive system may have difficulty processing Humanity, and therefore they convert it into a stone in the same way that real clams form pearls to deal with indigestible detritus that gets trapped within them. But the “dreadful rumours” about the rings may reflect an in-universe confusion concerning the practice of sacrificing Humanity sprites with actual human sacrifice.
An older post on Velka by user Electrical-Test [which is linked above and I strongly recommend reading as it makes several interesting connections] suggests that the sealers of New Londo might also be followers of Velka, and that they flooded the city under her orders. This was based on the fact that their masks look a bit like bird’s beaks, the fact that a Rare Ring of Sacrifice is found right next to Ingward, and the inference that Velka may well have judged the Four King’s dark-overload to have been sinful and punished them accordingly. Furthermore, Velka is likely to be a lunar deity, since DS3’s Greatsword of Judgement associates the moon with the concept of judgement, but Inward also wears a crescent shaped pendant, possibly further connecting him to Velka. The hole in the roof of the cave in which New Londo is built also resembles the moon, as if to suggest that the city is under judgement. Electrical-Test also suggested that the Red Soapstone [which is found in the Painted World next to several mutated crow people] might be the Velka approved alternative to the Red Eye Orbs, since it’s description suggests that it is considered to be the more honourable option. You are inviting willing participants to duel rather than invading someone who may not want to fight and may be unprepared to do so. I’d also propose a similarity between this and the Atonement spell from DS3, which is a Sable Church miracle that obviously originates from Velka despite the fact that she isn't mentioned in it's description.
This post intrigued me and so I decided to incorporate the sealers into my investigation. In doing so I have found more evidence supporting the idea and am now basically convinced. First of all, there is another Velka related ring found very close to Ingward: the Cursebite. Secondly, Yuria’s “Billed Mask” bears a significant resemblance to Ingward’s “Mask of the Sealer”, and these likely suggest a connection with Velka since Oswald’s “Mask of Velka” also has a bit of a beak over the nose. Ingward himself says that New Londo was “sacrificed” to contain the Darkwraiths, which could be a hint at his allegiance to Velka. But most important of all is Ingward’s spell: Resist Curse. The description of this spell says “sacrifice Humanity to undo curse”, and given what we’ve covered so far in this post it practically screams of Velka. I have tested this spell in-game and it doesn’t actually require you to spend a Humanity in order to cast, despite what the description says. I think the devs probably planned for the spell to cost 1 Humanity per cast, but this was removed because why would anyone use it when you could just boost your curse resistance? The Cursebite ring is right next to Ingward, and the Bloodshield and Paladin Armor aren’t too difficult to obtain. Equip all three and you’re basically immune to curse. Even on a sorcery build, the only time I actually used this spell was to quickly remove the curse build-up that is automatically applied when you put on the Cursebite Ring. Why disincentivise use of the spell even more by making it cost a Humanity? I probably would have just waited for the bar to go down like I normally do. Despite this, I don’t doubt that the spell is actually supposed to cost a Humanity to cast in lore. And this fact supports my earlier suggestion that it’s possible that the Purging Stones, Arstor’s rings, and Rings of Sacrifice, may have been created from the sacrifice of Humanity sprites rather than the sacrifice of actual people. This will become relevant later on in the post when we talk about the purpose behind Velka’s cult.
Section 4: Velka and the Darkmoon
There are two more Velka related items that I have not yet discussed: Indictment and the Book of the Guilty. I’ve chosen to allocate a separate section to what is revealed in their descriptions because it leads in an unexpected direction. According to the descriptions of both items, those who are judged by Velka to be guilty of sin will be punished by the Blades of the Darkmoon. This gives us yet another association between the moon and the concept of judgement, since this covenant uses a crescent symbol and it’s main function is to punish wrongdoers. Furthermore, the Book of the Guilty tells us that those who have been judged as sinners by Velka are people who have “disrespected the gods or their covenants”, which is very much at odds with the idea of Velka as a “rogue deity” who sides with mankind. But the Darkmoons are Gwyndolin’s covenant, and this is where the complication sets in. I also remembered that the crow-people in the Painted World sometimes drop Souvenirs of Reprisal: the item used to advance rank in the Darkmoon covenant. Furthermore, Gwyndolin has a catalyst for casting sorceries but it scales on faith, the inverse of Velka’s talisman. It’s also made of tin, which is significant because tin was associated with Jupiter in alchemy. In the bronze age, tin was one of the two primary ingredients of bronze, the other being copper. But tin was the harder to obtain, and so if a country had access to a reliable source of tin they would inevitably become wealthy and powerful. The association of tin with geo-political power lead to a further association with the king of the gods, Jupiter being the example that the alchemists inherited. For this reason it is likely that Gwyndolin possesses a catalyst made of tin because he believes himself to be the rightful heir to the throne of Anor Londo. Logan has a tin catalyst because he has achieved a power equivalent to that of the gods, and outright rejects their authority. The final tin catalyst in DS1 belongs to the New Londo sealers, and in this case I suspect that it’s because they wielded god-like power over the city when they flooded it, after all there is a similarity to the biblical story of Noah’s flood. But for the sealers to have a tin catalyst creates yet another potential link between Gwyndolin and Velka.
Now at this point I googled “Velka is Gwyndolin” and was utterly unsurprised to find an older post with that exact title since you can find people proposing that Velka is basically anyone. But the post in question [which is linked above] actually makes a very well constructed argument, although I did find a handful of the proposed connections to be a bit of a stretch. For example I don’t think that the visual similarity between Velka’s Talisman and the Darkmoon Talisman is clear evidence of anything. I could just as easily point out the similarity between Velka’s Talisman and the Witch’s Locks weapon in DS3 [both made of black hair that originally belonged to someone described as a witch] and argue that Velka is a daughter of the Witch of Izalith. The “Velka is Gwyndolin” post is well worth a read though, and I fully encourage you to take a look through it for yourselves. However, I tend to be sceptical of “character x is character y” type interpretations, and this one is no exception. The main issue I see here is that Gwyndolin is dead in DS3, with all that remains of him being a corpse that is merely puppeted by Aldrich. Yet it is still possible to receive absolution from Velka’s statue, suggesting that she is still alive and active. If Velka and Gwyndolin are the same person, and especially if Velka is a form that Gwyndolin possessed in the past as user Meat-Puppet suggests, then how can it be possible that Velka still offers absolution and reverse-hollowing via this statue?
As of writing this post I am unconvinced that Velka = Gwyndolin, but would be very interested to hear your thoughts about it in the comments. There is clearly some connection between these characters, but the exact nature of this connection is unknown. One possible solution was suggested to me by user Barry the Butcher, who proposes that the Blades of the Darkmoon were originally servants of Velka before she abandoned Anor Londo, at which point the covenant fell under the control of Gwyndolin. Although there is no conclusive proof, Barry’s suggestion seems to me to be the most likely explanation and does resolve the issue quite nicely. So for now I shall proceed under the assumption that Velka and Gwyndolin are distinct.
Section 5: Velka and the Way of White
This connection is not immediately obvious, but evidence does exist which indicates it. We know that the Undead Parish is a church of the Way of White because Rhea can be found praying at it’s altar, where a firekeeper is enshrined. Yet this is also the same location where we meet Oswald, and where he remains throughout the entire game. Oswald also chooses to stand in an interesting spot: hidden away in an obscure and high place, up among the rafters like a crow and barely visible in his black robes. It suggests someone who is watching everything, but is seldom seen himself. What’s more, when spoken to for the first time, Oswald will say:
“Thou appearest to lack faith, yet magnanimous are the Gods”
Unless you are a member of the Way of White, which will cause him to say instead:
“Thou art a friend. For thee, a warm welcome.”
Interesting difference. And this is something that I have tested in-game myself, having taken numerous builds through NG+: Oswald will not recognise you as a friend if you speak to him while you are a member of the Warriors of Sunlight, Princess Guard, Blades of the Darkmoon, or any other covenant. You must be in the Way of White to get this dialogue, which strongly suggests that Velka is aligned with this particular religion during the events of DS1.
Velka appears to have served a role in Anor Londo’s government, no doubt one that revolved around law making and enforcement. But when the city was abandoned, power was instead transferred to Thrololund where the gods are still in control. Considering the evidence, I think it likely that she serves a similar role on behalf of Lloyd’s regime, which is why she now has a deeper connection to the Way of White than to the Blades of the Darkmoon, who remained in Anor Londo under Gwyndolin’s control.
Section 6: the Cult of Velka
One of the things that’s obvious about Velka is that she does have some kind of active following among humans, although this seems to be entirely forgotten by the time of DS3. But the question is: why do people worship her? Every single religion in the real world, irrespective of how different they are, is unified by a single common trait: the followers of the religion are expected to be able to benefit from it in some way. The expected benefit is not always the same, however. Most Christians expect to be able to go to heaven after they die, but Buddhists don’t believe in an eternal afterlife and instead see Nirvana as the ultimate goal. In antiquity there were people who worshipped sun gods, not just for the sake of it, but because the movements of the sun correspond to the seasons. If the sun doesn't start moving back the other way after the solstice you'd have an eternal winter which would kill everybody. No one knew what caused the solstices, or why the sun rose at all for that matter, and our natural tendency for agency detection caused us to ascribe intention to the sun's movements. Once you've done that, you'd better make sure the sun is appeased so that it continues to maintain conditions in which your crops can grow. Similarly, gods of the sea were worshipped by sailors who didn’t want to get capsized, and by fishermen who hoped to boost their chances of a bountiful catch. Gods of war were worshipped by soldiers who wished for success on the battlefield. You can see the pattern emerging: no religion ever existed that didn’t have some kind of point to it. This is always useful to keep in mind if you ever write your own fiction or start a worldbuilding project or something. But we must ask the question: what is it about Velka that has earned her so many devotees? What does she offer people?
We know that Velka punishes sin, but also accepts the confessions of sinners. Velka offers atonement, which suggests that people will be spared punishment if they give a confession. Could it be that people only follow Velka out of fear of punishment? That may be part of the reason, but I don’t think it explains why there are people who are so devoted to her that they started to morph into crows. Fear can buy a kind of loyalty [the kind that stabs you in the back at the earliest opportunity] but it does not usually produce genuine devotion.
One thing that should not be overlooked is Velka’s association with sacrifice, and the thing that’s being sacrificed is always Humanity: we have the rings of sacrifice that are strongly implied to have been created from a sacrifice of Humanity, Arstors rings and Purging stones that may carry a similar implication, Ingward’s anti-curse spell that requires a sacrifice of Humanity to work, and even the sacrifice of New Londo occurred because the Four Kings overdosed on Humanity. We know from the descriptions of the Dark Sorceries, as well as the covetous serpent rings, that Humanity and the Dark Soul represent our darker impulses, such as greed and the capacity to harm each other. But there is also an association with strength and vitality: for example if you use a Humanity [consumable item] it will instantly refill all of your health and also boost your resistances. Furthermore, characters known to ingest human remains also tend to gain increased size as well as great physical strength, examples include: Smough, the butchers in the Depths, the giant rats [the largest of which is extremely strong], Aldrich, etc.
But what if these sacrificial rites do not require the use of someone else’s Humanity, but can also be performed by siphoning one’s own excess of it? I’m going to propose that confession and sacrifice are effectively the same thing, since by confessing a sin you are acknowledging the darker aspect of your nature rather than hiding it and allowing it to fester in the core of your being. At the same time, the rite may involve surrendering some amount of your own Humanity so that it can be repurposed by transforming it into something useful [such as one of these rings], or offering it to a bonfire so as to reinvigorate it’s flame. This explains why it’s called a sacrifice: you are giving up some of your own strength instead of hoarding everything for yourself [remember that the description of Velka’s mask suggests that she doesn’t approve of material greed], and you do it for the sake of generosity or some sense of supporting the greater good.
On the other hand, if you should fail to confess your sins and sacrifice your humanity, Velka’s agents may hunt you down and extract it from you by force. We’ve already mentioned that she may have had control over the Blades of the Darkmoon, but even someone like Oswald may be expected to do this on occasion. The description on his rapier makes a point about how “inhumanly skilled” these confessors supposedly are, so we can say with confidence that Oswald does actually use this sword from time to time. He wouldn’t need to be so well trained if he’s not expected to do any actual fighting, so perhaps his priestly role sometimes involves defeating transgressors in armed combat.
One interesting fact pointed out by user Meat-Puppet is that Oswald and the Darkmoon Knightess both use rapiers, and the same is true of Sirris as well as some of the crow things from DS3’s version of the painted world. I think there are two reasons for this, the first being that the movesets on these weapons are fast, difficult to react to, and involve a lot of faints and other tricky manoeuvres. This isn’t too useful in PVE gameplay since the game’s enemies can’t be tricked by faints, so it almost seems as though this is class of weapons is designed for use against other players. Something similar can be said of Lautrec’s sickles [although Lautrec himself has no direct connection to Velka, he is from Carim and the sickles were apparently invented by Arstor] which can bypass an opponent’s shield. If used against a player who isn’t expecting it, it can cause that player to panic and therefore make mistakes. But in addition, I want to return to the Painted World to take note of all of the hollowed bodies impaled on stakes, and especially the “phalanx” enemy. The phalanx is important because the texture used on the bodies shows the characteristic tendril-like scarring caused by Dark/Humanity on flesh, but these are specifically trailing outward from the spots where the body is impaled by spears. So I think that impaling is a method used by Velka to extract Humanity from a victim by force, just as the Dark Sigil in DS3 is a hole in the body made to allow the Dark within to flow outward. This explains why her servants use rapiers: thrusting and piercing weapons. We also see that the mutated crow-people have an attack that involves repeatedly pecking [and thus piercing] the victim with their thin beaks.
As we’ve seen, Velka has an association with a ring that helps prevents blood loss, and another that improves resistance to poison. One of the sealers also had a spell that outright cures both of the game’s poison effects. But Velka is most strongly associated with cures for, and preventatives against, the “curse”. Now as far as I can tell, “curse” appears to just be another word for hollowing, and possibly a propagandistic term at that. I know that DS2 took a bit of an edgelord direction with it by suggesting that life itself is a curse, but the impression I get is that Miyazaki had intended to say that eternal life would be a curse. If you want to argue that curse has a meaning that is distinct from hollowing then go ahead in the comments, I will hear you out. But as of writing this post, all of the evidence that I’m aware of has left me unable to tell the difference between the two.
Velka has a ring that boosts resistance to curse build-up, another ring that prevents you from getting the curse effect if you do die from curse build-up, a spell that completely removes any curse build-up you may currently have, and a “stone” that cures the curse effect if you do end up with it. In DS3, Velka can reverse any hollowing that your character may have accumulated, and she’s also associated with the “clutch” rings. If we look at the description of these rings we see that they have offered new inspiration to the “crestfallen”, who might otherwise have been “overcome by despair”. We already understand from DS1 that the “crestfallen” are undead who are on the verge of hollowing, so this means that the clutch rings prevented people from going fully hollow.
Now that we’ve put the pieces in place, the reason for Velka’s devoted following should be obvious: she is a healer! A goddess of medicine as well as of sin and punishment, who takes the “evil” that is inherent in the human soul and turns it into a remedy. We know that many undead are terrified of going hollow [just listen to Rhea’s dialogue], and it’s easy to understand why. It also goes without saying that people are invariably averse to sickness and disease. But along comes Velka’s confessors with suitcases full of cures and preventatives, no wonder she inspired such loyalty. This is actually another thing that makes me sceptical of the Velka=Gwyndolin hypothesis: Gwyndolin doesn’t have any such association with healing as far as I know.
There is a certain danger in Velka’s approach however. In treating these dark impulses as “sins” that deserve punishment, she risks cultivating an attitude of shame around them. This could lead to even deeper states of repression and self-denial, and so Velka might actually be worsening the very problem she aimed to solve. If we really think about it, is Velka’s approach really anything more than another way of trying to restrain the Dark Soul? Is it not doomed to failure for that very reason? She also seems to be interested in preserving the transient and illusory human forms caused by Gwyn’s brand [which restrains the Dark Soul] despite her connection to the occult.
Section 7: Velka and the Sable Church
Velka has long been associated with the Sable Church for a variety of obvious reasons, but I want to draw attention to the fact that the two actually appear to have opposite goals. The Sable Church promote hollowing [via the use of Dark Sigils] while Velka reverses it. This is not only available from her statue, but [as we’ve just seen in the previous section] Velka also provides all sort of cures and preventatives against the extreme forms of hollowing known as "curse". Notice the message being implied by the fact that Velka’s followers carry cures for illness as well as devices that reverse hollowing: it equates the two, as if they’re both medicines. It therefore implies that hollowing is a disease that requires remedial treatment. This is quite different from Yuria’s belief that a hollow is the true form of man.
Everything we know about Velka suggests that she’s opposed to hollowing, and it’s even worth noting that she helps facilitate the Fate of the Undead quest by employing a giant crow to ferry undead from the Asylum to Firelink Shrine. There is good reason to think that Velka may actually favour the Age of Fire rather than the Age of Dark or Age of Hollows. I know that this goes against the more commonplace view of her being a “rogue deity”, but it seems to me that this is probably supposed to refer to her unconventional approach to Humanity [acknowledgement via confession rather than Gwyn’s approach of outright denial and restraint] instead of her being opposed to the other gods. And yet, her priests carry a sword that does increased damage against the gods. So there’s a lot of mixed messages going on here, and it’s impossible for me to say with absolute confidence what Velka’s goal actually is. I will point out that if you kill Yuria she says “Kaathe, I have failed thee”. Very interesting. Not “Velka, I have failed thee”.
I don’t doubt that the Sable Church was derived [in some way] from Velka’s old priesthood [i.e. the same organisation that Oswald belonged to], yet the allegiance may very well have changed at some point even if they have continued to use the same spells and symbols and such. Yuria probably got the idea for the Dark Sigil from Velka's habit of impaling sinners, but she has repurposed it into a form of empowerment as opposed to a punishment. The goals of the Sable Church may not be an accurate reflection of Kaathe’s goals either, since the japanese version of Yuria’s dialogue tells us that Kaathe died at some point before the events of DS3. For all we know, the Usurpation of Fire could have been an idea cooked up entirely by Yuria, and although she probably believes that Kaathe would have approved of it, who knows if this would have indeed been the case?
Section 8: Velka and the Occult
Despite all that is uncovered here, there are still some unanswered questions. The biggest of these is the use of an occult auxiliary on Velka’s rapier. As mentioned, this type of weapon deals increased damage against Gwyn’s race, and this fact [combined with the effigy shield’s description of an occult movement that plotted to destroy the gods] has been used in the past to support the incorrect notion of Velka as a “rogue deity” who stands in opposition to her peers. I want to draw attention, however, to the symbol of avarice. This is a piece of headgear obtained by killing all of the mimic chests, and makes your character’s own head look like one. It’s description tells us that these creatures were once gods who were transformed as a punishment for the sin of avarice.
Ask yourself: who is likely to have sat in judgement of these gods, and to have decided upon this particular punishment? The obvious answer is Velka, and so if she is required to sit in judgment of her own people then it makes sense for her constabularies to use occult weapons. Nevertheless, it does still seem strange that such a weapon would be entrusted to Oswald, who is human and therefore mistrusted by the gods. Unfortunately, we may simply have to accept that there are missing puzzle pieces here. Given that the Dark ember is found in the Painted World of Cut Content, it’s very likely that occult weapons, as well as the occult movement mentioned in several item descriptions, was originally intended to have a stronger presence in the story, but this was scaled back during development. Furthermore, occult weapons do not make further appearances in either of the later games, and neither does Velka’s rapier. For this reason we have severely limited information on what “the occult” is even supposed to be in Dark Souls [which is appropriate in some ways since the word itself literally means “hidden”], and can’t say much about what Velka’s connection to it means. But I very much doubt that she was ever involved in the underground movement that we find evidence of in that one cellar in Anor Londo.
It is interesting that DS2’s character Cromwell [a member of the same priesthood as Oswald] wields a scythe instead of a rapier, perhaps drawing another connection with Priscilla, who also uses a scythe. The possible connection with Priscilla is also another of these unanswered questions, as there simply isn’t enough hard information [that I’m aware of] upon which to base a firm conclusion. Cromwell’s name does tell us something, however, as it was taken from the historical Oliver Cromwell who is infamous for his religiously motivated brutality and oppression. The fact that a pardoner of Velka has this name might imply that we are supposed to ascribe similar associations to her priesthood.
Section 9: Velka in Bloodborne
I want to compare Velka to Eileen from Bloodborne: a hunter of other hunters when they fall to beasthood. The “beasts” of Bloodborne are, I think, directly comparable to the Pus of Man encountered in DS3. In both cases we have a person who is no longer able to contain their darker impulses, which have been accumulating behind some kind of restraint. When this happens, the person’s “inner beast” explodes forth and wreaks havoc. We see this in Amelia and Gascoigne’s transformations, but also in the gigantic Dark serpents that burst out of certain hollows in DS3. Elieen is called “the crow”, and wears a “plague doctor” mask which resembles the beak of a bird [much like Ingward and Yuria’s masks], and even her cloak looks as if it’s covered in crow feathers. Her job is literally to punish people who succumb to beasthood, which is exactly the same thing as what’s going on in Dark Souls only with a slightly different coat of paint.
r/darksouls • u/Middle-Wrangler2729 • 3h ago
Story I feel ashamed
I rage quit again. I did this many times in EldenRing, but I always came back. At least until Maliketh. That was when I quit for good (or so I thought). I had been playing a tanky sword fighter build. A year later, I decided to try a new run with a magic user. I had heard they were easier to play, and boy were they right! This time I actually managed to complete the game and even get to the secret areas and defeat Malenia. Later, my son asked me to reload my old tanky sword fighter character that had been forgotten for over a year outside the hellish realm of Maliketh. I laughed and explained how it was impossible for me to defeat that boss. Just for fun, I booted it up and destroyed Maliketh on my first try while my mouth was open in amazement and shock. My son laughed. I continued over the next few weeks and actually completed the game with the tanky sword fighter also. Two game victories with two different characters! Thousands of frustrating deaths and I had managed to git gud I suppose you could say. Certainly no expert like the insane YouTube videos I've seen people post or anything like that, but good enough to get through that insanely difficult and insanely fun game TWICE!
But now I return to DarkSouls, the game I simply HAD to try after loving EldenRing so much. And it might be a year until I return. Because after working so hard and getting so far, I need a break. I even discussed it with my son beforehand. He thought that I would for sure rage quit if I lost all my money (had around 40,000 after defeating a boss). They even gave me a return teleport I could have used to not lose my money. But did I use it? No, stupid me decided to explore in the dark at the bottom of some catecombs after defeating a boss and fall off a fucking cliff for the thousandth time! I have died in FromSoft's games so much more from falling off cliffs than any other reason. Not even the bosses are as frustrating as the deadly cliffs of the realms. Then trying to recover my money, these fucking unicycle skeletons destroyed my ass. So I'm done for now. Goodbye DarkSouls! Maybe you will see me again, we'll see....
r/darksouls • u/Paidparisley3533 • 6h ago
Co-Op Anyone playing ds2 schooler of the first sin seamless coop
I’m a newish to be a DS2 player can anyone help me
r/darksouls • u/SpeedyPuzzlement • 1d ago
Video Ornstein and Smough with only R1 / L1 / Up.
r/darksouls • u/Signal-Reporter-1391 • 1d ago
Help 100% Rhea questline completion
Hi,
i'm following the guide linked in this old post https://www.reddit.com/r/darksouls/comments/4nq535/dark_souls_1_cheat_sheet/ and just came back from the Darkroot Garden.
Rhea and her party left, Petrus was absent but is now back telling me he has no idea where she could be.
I've read Rhea's wiki page and numerous sources which sometimes seem to contradicts themselves.
To save Rhea and prevent her from going hollow: should i kill Petrus now, save Rhea later from the tomb of the giants and buy all or all but one miracle from her?
Or should i rescue her later from the tomb after which i seem to be on a timer to finally save her?
And should i then buy all her miracles or leave one?
Oh and Lautrec is still alive cause i want to experience his questline as well.
I have no problems with spoilers so just go crazy. :-D
Thank you!
r/darksouls • u/fungus2112 • 1d ago
Discussion Started a new run after maybe 10 years
Just gotta say this game is still amazing. Forgot how fast I can get my build up and running. Maybe two hours in and got my clay plus 7. Vit and endurance up and headed into blight town. Finding my love of Darksouls again has got me excited to play games again after a good time away. Love this game.
r/darksouls • u/Robomol • 1d ago
Lore TIL Cragspiders in Blighttown don't actually walk. They hover!

I've been playing Dark Souls for years, and somehow I never noticed that Cragspiders in Blighttown don't actually walk!
I've always just swung my sword at them, so I never paid much attention. But if you let one get close, you'll notice its legs don't move at all. It's actually hovering with those ridiculously tiny mosquito-like wings on its back!
After all these years, Dark Souls still manages to surprise me.
r/darksouls • u/mayomateo1738 • 1d ago
Discussion Location of the kiln of the first flame
I'm really fascinated by the geography of the souls games, and how it's all interconnected obviously and how on following playthroughs you can see different areas at certain viewpoints and all that blah blah blah. But I always wondered where exactly is the kiln of the first flame?
So you go to fire link shrine which is kind of like the middle meeting point of everything, and you go to the ruins and you get sucked into the hole then that leads to the kiln. So it is below the fire link shrine, but when you actually enter the area covered in ash with the arena where you fight gwyn it doesn't look like your underground at all. So then where exactly is it?
I also think it's really interesting how in ds3 it seems to be way elevated over a lot of the land, though the locations have been kinda mixed up in ds3 cause of land n time being conveluted or wtv, but that in contrast to it being below everything in ds1 feels rly weird.
Maybe I'm thinking about it too deep cause it is just a game and doesn't always make sense, but I feel like fromsoft is so deliberate with the geography and level design that there has to be a reasonable explanation as to WHERE it is in relation to the rest of the map.
r/darksouls • u/Major-Impress5859 • 1d ago
Co-Op Can anyone help me please
Starting a playthrough on PlayStation and would love someone to drop me some useful items or even hang with me psn: mr_obvious_03
r/darksouls • u/No-Significance3599 • 2d ago
Discussion dark souls saved my life.
I was in 6th grade, I had just started middle school and I was bullied heavily because I was different than everyone else. In 7th grade, it had gotten so bad to the point where I wanted to kill myself. One day, i booted up my 360 (yes I had one cause my dad was goated) and I saw dark souls 1 on recently played. I decided to play it because I wanted to take my mind off of what was going on in my life and I fell in love with the game. I have been a fan since that very day I played it for the first time. So I have to say in the words of dunkey, thank you dark souls.
r/darksouls • u/YamatoDefender • 2d ago
Fan Art His very own sun ... [WIP]
Probably not gonna finish this ever so i'm just gonna post it as it is
r/darksouls • u/Lavt_potato • 2d ago
Video my first dex/int soulsborne run (homemade, no guides, just rawdogging it by memorizing item locations and questlines)
this might be the first accidental op build i genuinely didn't know crystal magic weapon and power within would deal this much damage 😭 imagine if i added the red tearstone ring
r/darksouls • u/ca_waves • 2d ago
Video Black Dragon Kalameet - no hit (SL1, NG+6, no roll/red tearstone ring)
r/darksouls • u/UncleSam20 • 2d ago
Video How the hell did you get here?
I'm not even using any mods, cheats or anything. What is a phalanx doing down in the sewers? And also I was today years old when I found out that enemies can break illusory walls and even attack them intentionally to get to you
r/darksouls
•
u/SpeedyPuzzlement
•
2d ago
Video Bed of Chaos but I can only move with R1.
r/darksouls • u/Due-Abbreviations180 • 1d ago
Help what do I do?
* Level: 42
* Souls: 0
* Vitality: 18
* Attunement: 10
* Endurance: 10
* Strength: 33
* Dexterity: 22
* Resistance: 10
* Intelligence: 9
* Faith: 11
* Humanity: 0
This is my status at the moment during my first game at Dark Souls Remastered. I'm now at the end of Anor Londo and I've been trying to beat the bosses (Ornstein & Smough) since August, but I'm stuck. I do now only have the dragon tooth as strong weapon.
I bought the whole trilogy and I've been playing DS1 for months and I already consider that as an incredible game experience and I like this Dark Fantasy atmosphere very much. Shall I begin DS2 or do something more in DS1?