I was ruminating on the Profaned Flame recently and had some thoughts about what it is precisely. It’s mostly been a source of irritation to me because it’s yet another flame in a game of many flames lol. And I wasn’t sure where it fits in with the lore.
But a thought struck me that it may be humanity’s (or a particular kingdom of humanity’s) take on the First Flame.
Similarly to the Chaos Flame. Which was the hubristic attempt of the Witch of Izalith to copy the First Flame (or create her own essentially). This backfired and created the Chaos Flame, which I think the Demon’s Greataxe gives the best commentary on:
The demons, born of Chaos, harbor fire, and yet they are twisted and malformed, such that they were never meant to be.
I think it’s possible that the Profaned Flame was an attempt by the humans of what became known as the Profaned Capital to bypass the first Flame. Specifically something as antagonistic to both the Flame and the linking of it. It’s possible the oracles linked together humanity, pieces of the Dark Souls, with the First Flame itself or some facsimile of it. This is why the Profaned Flame cannot die, as it is linked to the Dark Soul or humanity itself or the Abyss. Andre says the Profaned Coal is much too Dark and he sees the Abyss in it.
I think there’s evidence to suggest that the Capital was home to quite an avaricious population due to the many Mimics there. This suggests a population that is prone to sin. The Profaned Flame is called the Flame of Sin in JP. The Monstrosities of Sin could be the human version of the Chaos Demon backlash felt from such an attempt.
Naturally, this is an act full of hubris, and perhaps was punished accordingly. When Yhorm went on to link the Fire, flame was said to come down from the sky and devour nothing but humans. Perhaps retribution from the First Flame for the Profaned Flame’s creation. We know Yhorm became a Lord to put the Profaned Flame to rest. He knew that linking the Fire would suppress the Profaned Flame.
Since the Profaned Flame cannot go out, a young Sulyvahn discovered it and a burning ambition took root in him. Was the ambition borne out of his discovery that it was unfading or did it impart to him some of the hubristic ambition involved in its creation?
Thoughts on this approach? Any Profaned Flame experts out there with a solid rebuttal? I’ve always had difficulty placing it in the lore but I like where I’ve landed unless there’s solid evidence that I’ve misinterpreted something.
Thanks!