r/writing • • 6h ago

Discussion how do critics pick what piece has the best writing?

1 Upvotes

This all started because I canr fathom at all how they choose the writing winners in olympiads. Ive applied a couple of times and wrote essays but didnt really get past the first phase, and yet to my surprise, people who seemed incredibly shallow in opinions and not even in the least bit artistic, seemed to actually get past me! And at this point, I genuinely dont even know where Im supposed to improve if I seek to do so (for my own stories), assuming something about my writing isnt good enough since EVEN SUCH PEOPLE could pass. And its really not jealousy its just genuine confusion and need to know the truth in order to get better.

Im confused on peoples opinions on my writing in general too. When I was a little kid, everyone praised me for my storytelling skills, then in middle school my literature teacher said I have no talent, then in highschool suddenly all of my literature teachers started liking me and considering me talented, and they were the ones who suggested the olympiads. But something one of my literature teachers in highschool said did again confuse me, and it was that the structure/syntax or whatever she meant wasnt right, bur at the same time her writer husband had really loved my piece so she wouldnt lower my grade.

So then, what does all of this mean? Anyone has a similar situation?


r/writing • • 8h ago

Advice Don't become your own worst enemy by thinking too much

28 Upvotes

If you could only be a doer or a thinker, which would you choose?

Of course you'd be a doer.

Thinkers worry too much about their skill.

Thinkers fancy the opinions of others more than their own.

Thinkers plan more than they write.

Develop the skill to turn your brain off and simply express yourself.

Get things done, regardless of quality, profit, or prestige.

Be a doer.


r/writing • • 18h ago

Discussion Do you write for readers or write to write?

97 Upvotes

I find a good amount of comments that suggest not considering the reader when writing anything for the first draft. I find this quite odd.

In my writing process I consider the reader a lot. I keep myself very mindful of what they know, what they don't know, what they can infer. I consider the reader's emotional bandwidth when decided the order of chapters/scenes. I consider the reader when evaluating sentence variations.

And I do this because my goal is to write something that people would like to read. I think writing something without consideration of a reader is leaving a lot to pure chance.


r/writing • • 20h ago

Advice Criticism Is Part of the Game, My Friend. Believe in Your Story or You’re Doomed.

68 Upvotes

I’m used to the rejections. Criticism is part of the game of creating stuff. Anytime you put something out into the world, people are allowed to say whatever they want. You have to accept it. It’s hard to deal with in the beginning, but you get used to it, or you try to get used to it.

People will criticize the hell out of you. Support is what’s hard to come by. Don’t take it personally. Most people won’t believe in it the way you do. Believe in your story. If you don’t believe in your work, it will become apparent.

I believe in the more-than-half-dead internet theory. They say 55 to 65 percent of the internet is made up of bots. Then there are the trolls. Brace yourself, there is a lot of toxic negativity on the internet. You put yourself in a vulnerable spot.

Creating stuff is the easy part. Getting people to actually consume it is the most brutal sport. Just be thankful people are even criticizing your work. Just think back to that writing class you took and how critical your peers were. Sometimes the criticism will be constructive. Other times, it’ll be destructive. Everybody is a critic, and they’re entitled to their criticisms. Most of the time, people will just ignore your work. Taking it personally will doom you. People don’t care about all the work you put into it. They’ll judge what’s presented to them. And you’ll be judged harshly.

That's my TESTalk.


r/writing • • 8h ago

Discussion [Daily Discussion] General Discussion - November 19, 2026

4 Upvotes

Welcome to our daily discussion thread!

This is the place to discuss anything writing related! Got silly questions? Brainstorming ideas? Need help with research? As long as rules 1, 3, and 5 are followed, this thread is your oyster!

Please refer to the monthly threads for sharing your work and for self-promotion.

---

FAQ -- Questions asked frequently

Wiki Index -- Ever-evolving and woefully under-curated, but we'll fix that some day

You can find our posting guidelines in the sidebar or the wiki.