r/writing • u/Ok-You5223 • 6h ago
Discussion how do critics pick what piece has the best writing?
This all started because I canr fathom at all how they choose the writing winners in olympiads. Ive applied a couple of times and wrote essays but didnt really get past the first phase, and yet to my surprise, people who seemed incredibly shallow in opinions and not even in the least bit artistic, seemed to actually get past me! And at this point, I genuinely dont even know where Im supposed to improve if I seek to do so (for my own stories), assuming something about my writing isnt good enough since EVEN SUCH PEOPLE could pass. And its really not jealousy its just genuine confusion and need to know the truth in order to get better.
Im confused on peoples opinions on my writing in general too. When I was a little kid, everyone praised me for my storytelling skills, then in middle school my literature teacher said I have no talent, then in highschool suddenly all of my literature teachers started liking me and considering me talented, and they were the ones who suggested the olympiads. But something one of my literature teachers in highschool said did again confuse me, and it was that the structure/syntax or whatever she meant wasnt right, bur at the same time her writer husband had really loved my piece so she wouldnt lower my grade.
So then, what does all of this mean? Anyone has a similar situation?