r/anime • u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • Mar 05 '23
Meta Meta Thread - Month of March 05, 2023
Rule Changes
Comment Karma Post Requirement Trial
We are beginning a three-week trial in which users must have at least 10 comment karma on /r/anime in order to be able to make a post. Posts from users who do not meet this threshold will be removed with an AutoModerator message directing them to participate in the Daily Thread.
Moderator Applications Now Open
- Open applications are still going for another week, see this thread for details and the form!
A monthly meta thread to talk about the /r/anime subreddit itself, such as its rules and moderation. If you want to talk about anime please use the daily discussion thread instead.
Comments here must, of course, still abide by all subreddit rules other than the no meta requirement. Keep it friendly and be respectful. Occasionally the moderators will have specific topics that they want to get feedback on, so be on the lookout for distinguished posts.
Comments that are detrimental to discussion (aka circlejerks/shitposting) are subject to removal.
Previous meta threads: February 2023 | January 2023 | December 2022 | November 2022 | October 2022 | September 2022 | August 2022 | July 2022 | June 2022 | May 2022 | April 2022 | March 2022 | Find All
New threads are posted on the first Sunday (midnight UTC) of the month.
•
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Mar 05 '23
Everything in here has already popped up in one form or another over the past month, so hopefully no major surprises.
February Mod Report
February by the Numbers
16
u/SmurfRockRune https://myanimelist.net/profile/Smurf Mar 05 '23
Not sure if it's just a coincidence, but I noticed the amount of activity on /new plummeted once you introduced the new 10 karma filter. Part of me think it isn't working properly, or has there really been a very small amount of new threads?
8
u/DrJWilson x5https://anilist.co/user/drjwilson Mar 08 '23
The wonderful /u/Thrasher439 has updated the WT! Archive!
https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/wiki/watchthisarchive
Go ahead and look back on WT! past, including WT! of the Month/Year winners, or maybe check out a couple of series you've been meaning to get to. I've had a lot less time to maintain the page so I'm grateful to Thrasher for taking on the (admittedly tedious) work.
8
u/EuclaseBlue Mar 24 '23
Never got a direct answer to my question nor its follow-up, so I guess I'll ask again regarding clips:
Is it okay to clip a much longer official source video so long as attribution is given in comments? E.g., this post which is from a much longer video.
Also, going back to the original parent comment from the Feb meta thread, this post currently on the front page - that's been up for 8 hours - is clearly not linking to the original source, but rehosting it on reddit, so why hasn't it been removed yet? One of the top comment threads points out the rehosting nonsense and the OP even basically admits they're shirking the rules.
8
u/entelechtual Mar 26 '23
Would it make sense to have a “new anime” or “anime announcement” post flair, for when a new show/movie/season gets announced? Not just for busy days like today where there were like 50, but also so you can easily go back and look for anime announcements if you weren’t active on here for a while. I looked at the weekly roundup post too and it’s not super helpful/exhaustive.
7
u/Puddo x3https://anilist.co/user/STPuddo Mar 20 '23
I’ve a question about the not linking to illegal content. Obviously not linking a certain animal sound is a rule for a good reason. But would I be able to link for example this short film on Youtube in a post? It’s been on Youtube for 10 years with ¼ million views but it even says in the description it’s not uploaded by the rights holder.
7
u/Verzwei Mar 27 '23 edited Mar 27 '23
So during the third and final week of the subreddit comment karma trial (explained in the body of the OP above, in this comment in this thread, and this comment in last month's meta thread) we held a feedback thread alongside an internal vote to make the trial permanent. The idea behind the concurrent vote was so that if we decided to "keep" the karma filter, we could simply continue it directly from the trial rather than disabling it at the end, then voting to keep it, then re-implementing it, resulting in fewer potential back-and-forth rule changes and reversions.
That vote has passed, and the subreddit karma requirement for posting is now a permanent feature. We also carved out some exceptions to remove barriers for certain kinds of posts, and those exceptions will take effect in April. More details will be in next month's Meta Thread, coming this weekend.
7
u/cppn02 Apr 01 '23
Is there any particular reason why the Kaguya special isn't getting an episode discussion?
6
u/ZapsZzz https://anilist.co/user/Zapszzz Mar 08 '23
Just want to clarify some rules - I completely understand the point about the rules aren't exhaustive nor exclusive.
I had a post deleted because that post was something I posted for a fellow user who is happily reflecting the error of his ways in the sin bin.
Now I understand that if I was posting for him so he banned behavior would persist by proxy, it is definitely not allowed. But if the post in and of itself is not in breach of any sub rules, with the only "offence" being "because the post was from a temporarily banned user", isn't this reaching beyond the expectation of acceptable conduct?
Already the "punishment" aspect of it is in place and being served - the binned user would not be able to interact. Whether he get to "shadow post" is entirely at the mercy of his peers, which is another form of punishment. But since the actual content of the comment / post itself does not violate any rules, doesn't that punish those what would have liked to see and share the thoughts as well and not just that of the binned user?
For example, some posters produce high effort high value contents that is of benefit to the sub community. That they got temporarily banned for some behavior that was inappropriate but not to the extent that warrant a permanent ban should not "wipe off their existence" - the propagation ruling of "their input cannot be shared second hand" turned this into a form of permanent ban (their input on time sensitive topics e.g. rewatch in progress are permanently cut).
At the end of the day I just want some basic guidance - I will of course abide by the ruling, provided the ruling is clear for me to follow.
Rule in question:
Disclaimer & Code of Conduct
Though the above rules are /r/anime specific rules, you are still expected to adhere to the Reddit user agreement and to use common sense when interacting with others. Trolling and shitposting mean walking a very fine line, and we will ban you if you take it too far. Posts advocating suicide or mentioning that you feel a user should kill themselves are never appropriate, and are grounds for an instant ban even when used as a joke.
Despite the verbosity of this page, it should not be considered a complete list of things that are against the rules. Moderators will remove posts at their discretion if they feel it is not appropriate for /r/anime. Additionally, the rules should be considered fluid, as they and our interpretation of them evolve over time. In addition, the mods will use their judgment to remove any post or comment that they believe is likely to incite drama that may be linked to from elsewhere on Reddit, as we could do without that sort of attention. This list is not exhaustive - we've tried to be as verbose as possible in explaining the rules, but ultimately moderator actions are done on a case by case basis. If a moderator determines that a user's post or behavior negatively affects /r/anime, they can and will take action.;
6
u/chiliehead myanimelist.net/profile/chiliehead Mar 18 '23
Based on the removal of this comment, I think this falls under "specific sources"? Where is the difference between mentioning the title and just saying "[niizk]"? It's not like it makes any difference for people who know.
6
u/Akiyabus https://anilist.co/user/yabus Mar 31 '23
It just occured to me but did you guys get permission for the art used for Hyouka rewatch on the sidebar?
Because that is actually a fanart and not an official art.
1
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Apr 07 '23
This thread has been locked, please use next month's meta thread or find the latest thread.
9
u/Abyssbringer =anilist.co/user/Abyssbringer Mar 05 '23
March Bounty Board:
The first bounty board was a great success. We added 58 new flairs from it. Thank you to everyone who submitted. I noticed a couple of things that I think might help people who want to submit more bounty flairs in the future.
March Bounty Board!
Submit Here
We need your help to make even more flairs for everyone on /r/anime! We have 5000 emoji slots we would like to fill up with a plethora of anime from all different types of genres and demographics.
The bounty board is a system that allows normal users to be able to submit a flair or flairs of their choice to be possibly added to /r/anime. To promote variety and make the system more interesting we will have various restrictions in place with the bounty board hopefully changing periodically.
Flairs will be chosen by the mods. Similar to how Comment Faces are currently chosen. We will be looking for things like overall quality, visibility, necessity, and creativity. Flairs chosen by this system won’t be guaranteed to exist on the subreddit forever. We are hoping to get to a state where unused/unpopular flairs can be retired once we hit the emoji limit.
General Rules:
No flairs for a show that already has a general flair
Nothing overly ecchi
Must come from anime (screenshots or production material) NOT fanart
Height must be 64-128 pixels (128 recommended)
Width must be a multiple of height so that it can evenly divide into multiple square emoji (e.g. full image is 128x128, 256x128, or 384x128. Nothing larger unless asked for specifically)
Flair must fit into one of the categories below
Categories:
How to Submit a Flair
Please submit flairs to this Google Form. For any images please upload them to Imgur and give us the appropriate link. If you aren’t very technical we don’t require users to crop and edit their submissions if they aren’t able to. Link us to the full uncropped image and we can handle the rest. If you do have the fully cropped and properly sized image please send that as well. It makes our lives much easier.
We will require:
4
u/FlaminScribblenaut myanimelist.net/profile/girlbeast_val Mar 05 '23
Do y’all have the WT! of the Month visuals album for 2021? I want to add my Gakkougurashi! one to my MAL bio
4
u/EuclaseBlue Mar 11 '23
Never got an answer to my following question here so just want to follow up: https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/10tvdq3/meta_thread_month_of_february_05_2023/j9vpjme/
I'm guessing it's okay to clip a much longer official source video so long as attribution is giving in comments? E.g., this post on the front page right now which is from a much longer video - is this a valid post?
4
u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ Mar 30 '23
Is the Netflix Original Anime™ series, Scott Pilgrim, directed by Abel Góngora, and produced by Edgar Wright, Bryan Lee O’Malley, and BenDavid Grabinski, anime?
10
u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian Mar 05 '23
I'm not in episode discussion threads as much as I used to be but have you seen a decrease in blatant source reader comments outside of the Source Corner?
I swear I still report multiple comments per episode still...
7
u/TriTexh Mar 10 '23 edited Mar 10 '23
I really wish this sub eased up on the spoiler warnings bit.
Not the actual warnings themselves, mind you, but the sheer level of anal the filter gets on silly things like a straggler whitespace between the [context] and the actual spoiler
Edit: From the missing replies to my comment, I assume they got nuked(?)
7
u/notathrowaway75 https://myanimelist.net/profile/notathrowaway75 Mar 13 '23
Joke spoilers are spoilers. You got your work cut out with 100 Girlfriends.
8
u/michhoffman :Ij::Ik::Il:https://anilist.co/user/michhoffman Mar 16 '23
I like the thought, but so far the karma requirement for posting on r/anime seems to have made this sub less interesting than it was before. I never realized how many posts were coming from brand new users before.
3
u/mr_beanoz https://myanimelist.net/profile/splitshocker Mar 05 '23
I wonder why does the automod bot sometimes detect twitter links on comments as "linking to pirate sites".
3
u/_Ridley https://myanimelist.net/profile/_Ridley_ Mar 07 '23
FYI the link to the meta thread link on the sidebar still points to the December thread.
3
u/GreenstreetRoyal Mar 15 '23
How do you know when you’ve passed the 10 karma mark?
3
u/Tarhalindur x2 Apr 01 '23
Bug report: at least two of the new flairs appear to not be working somehow.
5
u/odraencoded Mar 25 '23
So many announcements jesus christ.
7
u/Theleux https://myanimelist.net/profile/Theleux Mar 05 '23
Any updates in regards to the misinformation posts that get shared every now and again? It doesn't seem to be a very common occurrence, but when they do pop off they hold on within the community for quite a while.
I think a positive initiative would be to construct a FAQ thread or section that explains certain aspects, which can be updated as trends in the industry changes over time.
4
u/entelechtual Mar 05 '23
I don’t know how pervasive of a problem it is, or if there is overlap, or what this will change, but I like the minimum karma as an alternative to retiring topics for discussion posts.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '23
Mods of this subreddit, can I know the primary reason why so suddenly there's a frequent removal of 90% posts in this subreddit?
2
u/Manitary https://myanimelist.net/profile/Manitary Mar 11 '23
I'm fairly sure I just saw a juror flair on someone who's not listed in any of this year's categories; they were a juror last year, perhaps an oversight when reassigning the host/juror flairs? (or vice versa, missing credits on the website? or a juror who dropped out but didn't get the flair removed, or an open juror and they also get a flair, etc.)
2
u/mr_beanoz https://myanimelist.net/profile/splitshocker Mar 29 '23
I wanted to promote a community poll from outside reddit, how can I do so?
2
u/AnimeHoarder Apr 01 '23
I don't see a discussion post for episode 13 of Tokyo Revengers: Seiya Kessen-hen. It's currently on Hulu, though the air date is shown as 4/2?
3
u/nitrohigito Mar 08 '23 edited Mar 08 '23
I wonder if an '-engdub' / ' (DUB)' version of every relevant flair would actually make sense. I would legitimately prefer to filter dubbed clips / news out, and many users fail to mention in the title if the given content is dubbed.
Would allow for a more heavy handed moderation under dub threads too, which I'm sure the pro-dub and dub-neutral folk would both appreciate as well.
2
u/LightChargerGreen Mar 26 '23
Is there a way to blacklist some threads about specific anime ? I'd rather not even see topics about mushoko tenshit.
1
u/Lorguis Mar 31 '23
I really don't understand the point of the karma rule, especially with no way around it. If you already know someone is a bot, and are already moderating low effort content and spam, what purpose does it serve except to fuck over new users?
0
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 29 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment