r/anime • u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • Jul 06 '25
Meta Meta Thread - Month of July 06, 2025
Rule Changes
- No new rule changes.
This is a monthly thread to talk about the /r/anime subreddit itself, such as its rules and moderation. If you want to talk about anime please use the daily discussion thread instead.
Comments here must, of course, still abide by all subreddit rules other than the no meta requirement. Keep it friendly and be respectful. Occasionally the moderators will have specific topics that they want to get feedback on, so be on the lookout for distinguished posts. If you wish to message us privately send us a modmail.
Comments that are detrimental to discussion (aka circlejerks/shitposting) are subject to removal.
Previous meta threads: June 2025 | May 2025 | April 2025 | March 2025 | February 2025 | January 2025 | December 2024 | November 2024 | October 2024 | September 2024 | August 2024 | July 2024 | June 2024 | May 2024 | April 2024 | March 2024 | February 2024 | January 2024| Find All
New threads are posted on the first Sunday (midnight UTC) of the month.
•
u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Jul 06 '25
Coming off of the two most active meta threads of all-time in April and May, June was pretty mild all told. But I’m still here to give you the big news in the world of r/anime.
June Mod Report
June by the Numbers
35
u/Abyssbringer =anilist.co/user/Abyssbringer Jul 06 '25
This is a general response to everyone who keeps asking for other animation to be added to /r/anime. I think a lot of people are focusing on the wrong things when it comes to this discussion.
I think something a lot of users who ask for this don't realize is that having a bunch of scope creep is not good for the subreddit. The good thing about reddit is that each subreddit is specific and focused. Its the way the site is designed and making a subreddit too broad is going to hurt a lot of content that can't generate a million upvotes because of popularity or having a picture attached to it.
The subreddit only has so much room and by increasing the scope to pretty much all Asian animation it's going to push down anything that isn't the most popular news posts. This subreddit already has problems getting people to interact with high quality interesting posts. Its a huge reason why the subreddit is focused on discussion and limits image posting and other karma farmy content. The sub already gets flooded with a ton of content and doesn't need any more. Hell yesterday the front page was mostly "Official Media" because of big events. I couldn't imagine a world where we keep the posting of "Official Media" and "News" the same but with all Asian cartoons. It would be a spam mess. Reddit is not designed to have that much content in one place.
Its not a bad thing to have separate subreddits for specific things. Anyone can go to any sub and the whole site is designed around these separate subreddits. Its also how things are naturally filterable and sortable for users. If I don't like anime memes then I can unfollow all those subs but still keep /r/anime because those subs and this sub are distinctly different. If /r/anime increased its scope to allow memes then it would be a worse place for me as someone who wants discussion posts and long form writing and not to see anime boob memes on my feed at all hours of the day. If anything I could argue that the current sub should scale its scope down more and have "Official Media" and "News" as its own subreddit at this point.
I really think trying to cram way too much into one Subreddit is not a good idea and doesn't need to happen. Having Donghua focused discussion on /r/donghua is not a bad thing. It gives people who are a fan of that art a place to congregate and focus on that thing. if they want to talk about animation as a whole then a subreddit with a more broad focus could be made but someone has to want to do it. Trying to piggyback and take over /r/anime which has been focused specifically on Japanese Animation for 17 years is not the way.
/r/donghua has a small community and can easily be grown into a self sustaining entity. There's plenty of good Chinese animation being made and people who want to talk about it. All it needs is a couple of mods and users who really care and want to start properly building up that community. Whether it be using the post scheduler or a bot like lovepon to post episode discussions of the most popular shows that are coming. Other smaller things like making Wiki pages and guides to help new users who want to learn and experience more Chinese animation is a great resource for growing the community. I used the /r/anime wiki pages a ton to learn about different shows and other things I didn't understand. Its also something that normal users can help and isn't overly committal.
I don't think its a fair ask of the mods and other users here who have contributed their time, effort, and money because they love Japanese Animation to take in all animation under their umbrella. Its way more work then the countless people who keep begging for scope creep understand and goes against fundamentally how Reddit as platform is structured. All to solve a problem that isn't a problem if people interact with the platform as designed instead of trying to put all the things they like in one place. Just because Donghua isn't allowed here doesn't mean that its any less quality, all it means is that it doesn't fit the scope of what this subreddit is focused on.
17
u/MyrnaMountWeazel x2 Jul 06 '25
Hey y'all, I just wanted to come in and bring attention to the fact that our sub has a wiki page.
I wanted to bring this up because a number of users in this month's Meta Thread have mentioned it, whether it's requesting an update for a specific page or highlighting its use as a resource page for newer anime watchers.
The wiki page isn't just an extended rules page (
though users could stand to benefit from reading it), it also houses frequently asked questions about anime, legal streams/downloads, watch order resource, comment face index/guide (newer users be sure to check this one out!), anime related subreddits, episode discussion archive, r/anime rewatch index, r/anime Awards Writing Club archive, A Brief History of r/anime, and so much more.The wiki page may be a little dusty -- and if anyone has any suggestions to add, please don't hesitate to ask us so we can update it -- but it's still a fount of knowledge for all things r/anime. It's a treasure trove of our sub, and it would be a shame if people never used it simply because they never knew it existed.
14
u/cppn02 Jul 22 '25
No Demon Slayer box office update in
120 hours.13
u/chilidirigible Jul 20 '25
Considering the substantial body of discussion in multiple Meta Threads about the lack of donghua here, I wonder if it would be practical to use a standard autoreply on them to read those previous discussions first before (potentially) (almost certainly) futilely repeating the same arguments, perhaps highlighting a few of the more comprehensive replies/comment branches.
I suppose locking the comment after that would be a bit much.
11
u/MeatballZeitgeist Jul 06 '25
This is a minor thing, but I've always wondered if it was possible to edit the episode discussion threads of the first episode of a new series so that the "Streams: none" is changed to show where it's streaming?
It seems to only be an issue on the very first discussion thread of a new (ie not returning/sequel) series, but that tends to be the time when I'll see a thread for a new series pop up on my reddit feed, think, "ooh! New series, I should check that out! Who has it?" and be mildly annoyed that this is the one time that information is missing.
20
u/Verzwei Jul 06 '25
HEY MODS, ANY CHANCE OF A VOTE ON BANNING ALLCAPS POST TITLES?
THEY COULD GO ON THIS LINE IN THE RULES:
NEW:
IS ALLCAPS THE WORST THING EVER? NO. BUT IT IS ANNOYING AS SHIT SEEING THEM ON POSTS.
10
u/Emi_Ibarazakiii Jul 18 '25
Addressing the issue before it arises: Nukitashi the animation...
50% of the backgrounds in the first episode have a bunch of people fucking. Like, even when the scene is about the main characters saying/doing something, there will be random people fucking in the background.
I played it safe this time and just didn't post any screenshots with background sex, while others posted a bit more, so I'd like to know what's allowed/not allowed for future episodes;
I read the NSFW rules but they're a bit confusing/unclear in regard to this...
Some of these backgrounds have 'clothed sex', others have people obviously having sex but we don't see much (sometimes asses), while others are more explicit, but I wonder what's the line exactly, especially when it comes to background shots.
To go with a few examples: I think these ones are probably not allowed:
[Nukitashi] 1) due to the groping from the guy licking her, and 2) this one due to the bottom right act
But I think these ones are fine:
[Nukitashi] 3) lots of sex act, but fully clothed, and not really in the front, 4) same here (except maybe the girl on the left?), 5) This one seems okay to me, there's a blowjob and some standing sex but they're not showing much (Just an ass), 6) this one is also just showing asses, but a bit more 'in front', so I'm not sure.
Does that sound about right, or..?
9
u/Blackheart595 https://anilist.co/user/knusbrick Jul 17 '25
Can we get an official ruling on the Turkey situation? Policy has always been that anything you don't learn within the first few minutes of the first episode is considered a spoiler here, that's how it's been for shows like [Summer 2015]School-Live, [Summer 2016]Orange or [Summer 2020]Deca-Dence and that's how it is specified in the rules. Now however we had a mod state that thing revealed in marketing material like synopses or late in the first episode are also exempt from being considered spoilers, which is a complete reversal of the existing policy, and there has been no attempt at removing the comment that triggered this dispute since pointing that out.
If the rules have been changed, please update the rules text accordingly and properly announce it in some way (e.g. here in the Mod Thread). If the rules haven't been changed, please apply the spoiler rule appropriately.
9
u/Blackheart595 https://anilist.co/user/knusbrick Jul 17 '25 edited Jul 18 '25
Alright so I went on a bit of a scavenger hunt going through the meta threads until 2020 concerning this promotional material and synopsis thing for spoilers. Apparently it's true that official policy has always considered information from genre listings and synopses fair game, I've found a few references to it here and there including in an answer to one to my one questions. So... yeah, the evidence is there, this has always been policy.
This immediately raises a few questions though. An obvious point of contention is [Summer 2015 show]School-Live which has a pretty drastic twist at the end of its first episode. Both the MAL synopsis and the AniList synopsis don't mention the twist in any way, even if the AL synopsis vaguely alludes to it. Which sounds like a clear case that this twist is a spoiler. Except MAL's synopsis was actually rewritten in 2021/2022 and used to openly talk about this twist before then, so should this twist not have required spoiler tags back then? In practise it certainly did. Additionally, MAL to this day has the relevant tags in its genre listing - while AniList features them as unspoilered tags, while still having some spoilered tags for other things that happen later in the story. So how is this situation? Has the ruling always been correct that this is a spoiler? Should this have been considered a non-spoiler until the synopsis was rewritten, at which point it became a spoiler? Or should this never have required tags to this day due to the openly available genre listings?
Another example is that back around 2016/2017 I used to get comments removed for [[Summer 2016 show]Orange, when I talked about]the main character getting letters from her future self to describe the show. The synopsis always talked about that as well, but the stated reason for those removals was that the relevant information was being treated as dubious information within the show itself until the end of the first episode where it's confirmed.
Another example, this time where things line up properly, is the episode 1 twist in [Summer 2020 show]Deca-Dence. Here, neither synopsis nor (unspoilered) genre listing of either site has ever alluded to the twist, and mention of it has always been considered a spoiler here.
So regardless of actual policy, my experience here has always been exactly in line with the rules as written, "Generally speaking, anything you don't learn in the first few minutes of the first episode should have a spoiler tag." Synopses, genre listings or any other material beyond the anime itself has in practice never been relevant to that as far as I can remember, official policy or not. Then again I haven't really engaged with episode discussion threads since 2020, maybe the experience in there would've told a different story.
As for the policy on information from promotional material, I haven't really found anything as concrete. On one hand there's this comment that pretty clearly states these things to be exempt from the spoiler rule. On the other hand there's this comment that pretty clearly states these things to still be considered spoilers, only exempt in particularly prominent and ubiquitous cases out of practicality. There's also this comment that very clearly doesn't affirm promotional material to be fair game. And then there's also lily's comment about [Precure]the mid-season Precure being considered spoilers despite the heavy and aggressive advertising i.e. promotion of the fact before its reveal in the story (any medium) itself, which iirc was triggered by her comments that were openly talking about that getting removed in CDF (but I can't be assed to search through CDF threads for a comment that may or may not be visible to me). There also the fact of the rule change allowing characters and new forms revealed in promotional material of upcoming anime, implying that those weren't allowed at all before that point even despite any promotional material that might've been there.
Heck, I got comments removed for mentioning a character's name before the name was used in the show itself, despite that name being identical to the characters major visual distinctive feature - requiring me to call him "X Dude" or "X Guy" instead of just "X". That's despite the name itself being clearly provided in the end credits, i.e. within the show itself. If promotional material clears information from the spoiler rule, this should all the more (once he's first appeared in the credits, anyway - this happened in a [[rewatch]Fullmetal Alchemist, the specific detail having been]Scar whom I was required to call Scar Dude or Scar Guy instead of just Scar).
In any case the rules are currently very clearly not clear, so it would be nice to get some clarification - and if the policy in practice differs from the rules as written, it'd be great to have the rules document updated accordingly.
8
u/Blackheart595 https://anilist.co/user/knusbrick Jul 09 '25
Whoever did that AMA sidebar image was cooking
8
u/surgemaster140 https://myanimelist.net/profile/User815 Jul 14 '25
Are there any plans to add more user flairs outside of the usual seasonal ones? The sidebar pic for it uses Yorimoi and there isn't even a flair for that show.
7
u/Mecanno-man https://anilist.co/user/Mecannoman Jul 06 '25
Hanako-kun's episode thread doesn't seem to have been posted; it's on Crunchyroll so probably just a config issue with the bot
7
u/hybrid_hydro Jul 06 '25 edited Jul 06 '25
I'm looking at this post. They requested a source, of which there is none legal, and the reply was removed. Why isn't the request also removed? A request for pirated content is only going to led to linking pirated content. If the latter is prohibited, then it seems a no brainer that the former should also be prohibited. My guess is that they're being given the benefit of the doubt of asking for a legal source and either didn't read the opening post or didn't realize "Netflix jail" means no legal source.
7
u/Responsible_Pain8173 Jul 06 '25
Hey all, what's the appropriate way to ask for help identifying an anime? Is it ok to post in the general discussion?
7
u/Emi_Ibarazakiii Jul 09 '25
For a different type of "Is this anime?" question:
Just making sure, but does this qualify as anime?
(Edit: You have to click on it I think, doesn't show embed).
It's the youtube-only (I think) prequel of this currently airing anime.
It's on MAL but it has less people involved (studios and all) so I'm not sure.
7
u/Ocixo https://myanimelist.net/profile/BuzzyGuy Jul 13 '25
The discussion thread for the latest episode of Toilet-Bound Hanako-kun is missing again. This had also happened last week. Not sure what’s going on with the bot.
7
u/qwertyqwerty4567 https://anilist.co/user/ZPHW Jul 21 '25
[](#azusalaugh)
7
u/OrangeBanana38 https://anilist.co/user/OrangeBanana38 Jul 27 '25
I just noticed that the seasonal comment face survey can be filled multiple times. I wanted to see my own votes, but it just let me fill it up again ( I didn't re-submit). I don't know if Tally has any way to check for IPs or anything like that, but that might be something to take into account to avoid vote manipulation.
6
u/mr_beanoz https://myanimelist.net/profile/splitshocker Jul 12 '25
Episode 2 of Vanguard Divinez Deluxe Finals has been released, yet I have yet to see the thread.
6
u/Hefty-Sky-1144 Jul 14 '25
Minor nitpick, especially since it's already over, but the sidebar banner for the AMA gives two different times, 10AM EST and, in parentheses, 2PM UTC, which corresponds to 10AM EDT, i.e. 9AM EST (and EST isn't even in use right now in places that observe daylight saving time, so that's an odd choice of time zone to include anyway).
6
u/[deleted] Jul 17 '25
Just throwing my two cents in, if the synopsis on a show's official website is part of the basis for what's not a spoiler, that should be specified in the rules.
Crunchyroll, Anilist, and Google don't list the "updated" synopsis for Turkey, so if you don't use MAL or the show's specific website, then you wouldn't know any details about the twist at the end of the episode.
I don't care about whatever the rule for what a spoiler is personally, just that it's specified correctly in the rules. Because allowing for untagged mentions of the "spoiler" for Turkey pretty clearly goes against the current rule and some people might've watched the episode earlier if they knew this subreddit wasn't safe from that spoiler. Especially since the updated visual and the 2nd PV were spoiler tagged.
Personally, I don't think it's a spoiler and anyone who cared a lot about not knowing the genre should've already watched in within the last two weeks but just saying that it's better to have consistent rules than moderating on a whim.
6
u/KendotsX https://anilist.co/user/Kendots Aug 01 '25
Bot-chan's job is being stolen by a human
5
u/qwertyqwerty4567 https://anilist.co/user/ZPHW Jul 06 '25
New month, new subreddit stats theme request.
We are yet to have an isekai or banished from the heroes party themed one and this season has a few opportunities.
WataNare also looks like a good choice to reference.
And lastly, we are once again in renting season.
5
u/KendotsX https://anilist.co/user/Kendots Jul 06 '25
The daily thread is still linking to the old CDF and Meta threads.
5
u/Infodump_Ibis :JY::JZ: Jul 08 '25
It would appear that Necronomico and the Cosmic Horror Show and The Fragrant Flower Blooms with Dignity have undergone binary fusion.
Ep 1 of Fragrant Flower was edited 2 hours ago to say Necronomico no Cosmic Horror Show, episode 1, inculde all the stuff relevant to that like Crunchyroll stream (it's a Netflix Jail show) and has a link to ep 2 of Necronomico.
Ep 2 of Necronomico the ep 1 link goes to the aforementioned Fragrant Flower.
5
u/Ashteron Jul 28 '25 edited Jul 28 '25
Does something like comments from the source material author belong in source material corner? Eg.: in one of In/Spectre volume afterwords it is mentioned that [In/Spectre character trivia] Iwanaga doesn't like being called Kotoko. It's not less related to the content of the anime than the manga. It's just character trivia (with some interesting implications). What if it was posted on twitter instead of being in an afterword?
5
u/cppn02 Aug 02 '25
If a show uses manga panels in the episode is it ok to post the actual page from the manga outside the source corner? Asking for a friend.
8
u/Mitsuyan_ https://anilist.co/user/mitsuyan Jul 06 '25
I decided not to apply for mod this time around. I'm too combative to moderate outside of Discord so I'm happy just to continue with AutoLovepon and make sure we have the most accurate episode threads possible.
I noticed that on the streaming sources page that the UK section was never updated for not only ITVX's failed experiment (Gurren Lagann, Cardcaptor Sakura, and others) but also BBC iPlayer (which has a Pokémon channel! along with One Piece, Beyblade, Dragon Quest rights too) and Channel 4 which hosts Adult Swim with some FLCL and Lazarus among others. As such, I'd like to see the wiki updated with BBC iPlayer and 4OD. I was surprised to see Lazarus there too, don't worry. The service was good though and didn't bitrate out the animation quality. iPlayer is stunning for the Pokémon sakuga, I've not tried it with Beyblade's or One Piece's yet. Maybe we can expand to all dedicated anime stores in the Western Hemisphere one day haha it's 1am Mitsu go to bed
4
u/Mitsuyan_ https://anilist.co/user/mitsuyan Jul 06 '25
Something I forgot to ask actually, can we get a timeskip Pokémon Horizons user flair? There's a few flairs I want but regular users (rightly) only get one. I was thinking this one having Liko, Roy, Dot and Ult all on if it's possible.
4
u/Ashteron Jul 10 '25
It seems that due to Kamitsubaki City episode 0 being labeled as episode 1 the bot failed to post the thread for the actual episode 1? At least I don't see it.
4
u/Time_Fracture https://myanimelist.net/profile/Time_Fracture Jul 19 '25
Regarding Nukitashi OP thread, have we agreed back in July last year to wait for a week before posting OP/ED as a clip? Last year it was Nokotan and now it happened again with Nukitashi.
4
u/Emi_Ibarazakiii Jul 24 '25
Don't know if it's META worthy, but do we have an influx of Portuguese or Spanish bots/trolls or something?
I keep seeing weird ass comments like this one and when I check their profile all their comments are in Portuguese/Spanish in random subs, they just have this 1 comment in English on r/anime for some reason.
Always the same pattern (1 comment in English here, Spanish/Portuguese everywhere else).
4
u/chilidirigible Jul 27 '25
The CITY The Animation top-level AutoLovePon text still does not have the streaming link in it.
4
u/baseballlover723 Jul 27 '25
/u/ussgordoncaptain2
I have updated the spoiler removals to include the match and some context.
Can you please fuck up some spoiler tags (preferably not with real spoilers) and pass some judgement and screenshots on the new removal messages as replies to this comment?
I didn't test it super thoroughly, but it's a pretty simple "include the match + up to 50 characters before and after", so it shouldn't actually affect what it matches, just how much of it it'll actually match (and then putting that in the removal message). So just some of the common fuckups you do is sufficient.
4
u/Infodump_Ibis :JY::JZ: Jul 28 '25
/u/Actual_Muffin9108 noticed something's up with Sakamoto Days Part 2.
The episode 3 discussion didn't get edited to have link to episode 4. In addition the, other episodes (1,2,4) link to this locked and deleted episode 3 post instead.
4
u/NormalGrinn https://anilist.co/user/Grinn Jul 30 '25
Think I'll just post this here cause I think I can make it more clear than just a report
In the awards host thread (https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/s/7QTLGooRib) there's an account that's just copying what other people in the thread already said
https://files.catbox.moe/hvflmo.png
https://files.catbox.moe/ikpqad.png
7
u/notathrowaway75 https://myanimelist.net/profile/notathrowaway75 Jul 28 '25
I've been seeing comments about the apparent abundance of Infinity Castle box office posts so I checked by searching "Demon Slayer" in this subreddit by new. There have been... 4 news posts about the movie.
7/19 - Opening day box office
7/19 12 hours later - Day 2 box office
7/22 - opening weekend
7/27 - 10 day update
That's it.
3
u/sheepbird111 Jul 14 '25
A clip I recently posted of aphrodite got removed since its a clip shorter then 10 seconds but the clip is less the 10 seconds whole so
Can I put together a couple clips of her which add up to 10 seconds and then use the edited video flair?
3
u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ Jul 22 '25
Can we have a moderator vote on the maxinum number of sore demo
clipsvideo edits per month? I think (2) would be consistent with the current rules.5
u/mekerpan Jul 12 '25
Ep2 of Kaoru Hana wa Rin to Saku • The Fragrant Flower Blooms with Dignity seems to have passable English subs already (at one of my "alternate sources").
2
u/Time_Fracture https://myanimelist.net/profile/Time_Fracture Jul 17 '25
I noticed there are 2 Dr Stone threads for Science Future Part 2 Episode 2? This one and this one.
3
u/mekerpan Jul 24 '25
Mille-Feuille ep2 is now up and running with English subs on MY "unofficial source" for it. I did not notice any glaring errors offhand.
3
u/chilidirigible Jul 25 '25
Over in the Seasonal Comment Face nominations I proposed a captioned version of the BIG THINK which was unlikely to be to the satisfaction of anyone, including myself. As a rider to it was a note about the currently-existing captioned meme version of
which we currently have.
So along with /u/baseballlover723 I suggest here that
be changed to a text-free, no sunglasses clean version.
All 69 frames of the original animation, cropped to Kumin's side of the screen but with the cloud background, are in a .zip file here.
3
u/MapoTofuMan myanimelist.net/profile/mTmTBaronBrixius Jul 26 '25
Guess I'll ask again regarding Kaoru Hana threads being posted late.
There are no subs other than the RHOP ones in the first day from what I've seen, so I assume the thread did go up for them in the past two weeks, but is there a reason for the 6-8 hour delay between the upload and the thread?
If QC is needed and mods aren't available at this time I volunteer (if there are any serious issues I don't mind fixing and uploading the fixed version to the usual place either).
But if sub quality isn't the reason, me and everyone else asleep/heading to sleep at 9-10PM Eastern time would really appreciate it being posted a few hours earlier.
2
u/oliverseasky Jul 06 '25 edited Jul 06 '25
I am aware that the topic of including Donghua like To Be HeroX or Lord of the Mysteries in this sub has come up a million times already, and I understand it’s likely never going to happen given that the moderators here seem to strictly follow an “anime purist” philosophy. And to be fair, I can respect that choice. The explanations given are logically sound, I understand where people are coming from and agree with the points made regarding the semantics and definition of “anime.” That said, I’d still like to offer an alternative perspective from a completely different angle.
What is the real purpose of this subreddit? I know the current rules basically define it as a community for animation with Japanese origins. But at the end of the day, subreddits at its core are places where people come together and talk about their shared interests. How that’s moderated varies from sub to sub, and completely depending on the moderators. For r/anime, it at least should be a place where people in the anime fandom can hangout, share what they love, and grow the community. Which brings to the question of whether the current approach serves this goal the best it could.
Take To Be HeroX or Lord of the Mysteries. They don’t qualify for posting here under the subreddit rules and the English definition of “anime”. But it feels that r/anime is the only anime community not talking about these series. Despite being Donghua, they’re clearly embraced by the broader anime fandom. Vast majority of causal anime fans out there don’t even consider anime and donghua to be different (not getting into that debate lmao, and it’s not the point of this post anyways). Furthermore, both of these series are listed on MyAnimeList, released on CrunchyRoll, covered by every anime news site, reacted to by anime reactors, anime content creator etc etc… If we are looking at them in spirit, and in terms of anime community interactions, they certainly belong. Since the anime community clearly engages with these two series exactly like how they would with any other seasonal anime. And I think that might be an important distinction to separate them from other works of animation or even other donghuas.
Ultimately, I’m not trying to redefine what anime is. That debate has honestly already been settled here in other threads and posts. I just think it’s worth asking what’s actually good for the community, and what the community as a whole wants. Some relaxed inclusion will certainly help with community engagement and growth, and make the sub feel more open to the anime fandom. That doesn’t mean turning this into a general animation sub, things like Family Guy and Frozen clearly don’t belong here, we are just recognizing that allowing certain series might help r/anime better reflect and support the community it serves.
That might mean evolving the sub’s identity and shift the focus from “anime = strictly Japanese animation” to “anime = the anime community in the broader cultural sense”. Or it could be something simple that’s based off community demand, like conducting community polls to decide whether a series should be allowed.
TLTR: Community behavior has already blurred the lines, and some level of inclusion could reflect that reality without breaking the sub.
0
u/Ytar0 https://myanimelist.net/profile/alevanderBatman Jul 14 '25 edited Jul 14 '25
For lack of a better place to ask, this is a question about donghua and other forms of animation.
I'm just curious why the mod team decided (perhaps quite some time ago?) to make the subreddit strictly focused on Japanese productions. It feels a bit awkward that this seemingly unnecessary restriction means users have to visit different subreddits for content that often appears on the same streaming platforms.
Also, the whole reason people complain about it is that these other related animation subreddits don't even come close to this subreddit, so it's just a huge loss that these rather huge animation shows don't get a proper place to be discussed.
I could imagine a solution where there's some kind of tiny "popularity poll" or "interest poll" where people could write a comment or vote in a poll to indicate that these occasional non-Japanese animation series would be allowed on the subreddit. And I don't think there's any "slippery slope" possibility, since you can always just veto the interest polls, but I for example just find it very unfortunate that Lord of Mysteries doesn't have an episode discussion here, even though I can imagine a lot of people in this sub are watching it weekly anyways.
1
u/MapoTofuMan myanimelist.net/profile/mTmTBaronBrixius Jul 19 '25 edited Jul 19 '25
Is there any reason the RHOP subs for Kaoru Hana aren't getting a thread?
I know they put [MTL] in their tags, but they said they do use the manga as a reference, and at least as of ep3 there aren't any ChatGPT-sounding lines or major mistakes that I've noticed (if anything the few lines I'd change are definitely a human translation choice).
They're more than passable as speedsubs imo, there's even some typesetting for messages and such.
-9
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '25 edited Jul 06 '25
Pretty sure that there is no chance of this but I request the mods of r/anime to make an exception for Lord of Mysteries (LOTM) donghua and provide Discussion threads for it. Unlike the people who were arguing about TBHX and saying that it was like an anime, I think I can say that Lord of Mysteries is not an anime according to the definitions of Western fans (Japanese fans call even Toy Story an "anime"). So I am not requesting the mods to acknowledge that LOTM is an anime but just requesting them to have it as an exception on the subreddit. But now you might be wondering why you should even bother so here are some reasons:
1.) Animation Quality
I know there are nowadays a lot of anime that have great animation but lackluster storylines(like Lazarus) so this in itself is not a worthwhile point but it definitely matters in an anime where there is action. The OST is also great
2.) Unique Setting
I personally do not like most donghuas due to a simple reason. There is always some kind of cultural disconnect and also because the names are a bit jarring. LOTM on the other hand is inspired from the Victorian era and has a steampunk like feel to it with Lovecraftian elements. Also, almost all the names of the show are english like Dunn Smith, Leonard Mitchell, Old Neil except probably our main character who had a chinese name in his previous life. This not only separates it from other Chinese Donghuas but also all the Japanese Isekai slop anime.
3.) Power System
I have never seen a better power system then the pathway system in LOTM. On one hand the characters can improve by drinking potions of a higher level but on the other hand there is always a risk of losing control and then becoming a monster. This means that there is a high chance that the person who is fighting alongside you might one day be your enemy and you can't do anything to fix that. This creates a system which is sufficiently powerful but also incredibly hopeless. And all of this happens in secret so there are a bunch of people living normal lives and think that the world is normal.
4.) The Grey Fog
The most unique power of Klein Moretti the MC is not some level up system or offensive power but the grey fog. It is incredibly mysterious and was the reason why I was intrigued to read the novel. I like this kind of powers which are sufficiently mysterious.
5.) The Fool & the Gathering
The first card of the tarot card is The Fool numbered 0. This in itself is a very interesting name for our MC to refer himself with. The gatherings above the grey fog are very interesting too and something I can talk about for hours. The misunderstandings and confusions are really funny and something I look forward to a lot in this story.
6.) Characters
While the LOTM novel focuses a lot on Klein and his journey, other characters also are very interesting. You can relate to some of them while like others. There are also meaningful moments of these characters.
7.) Roselle Gustav
Roselle Gustav is an important character who was a transmigrator of the past. Apparently he was also Chinese so Klein can read his personal diary which Roselle wrote in Mandarin. This diary shows Roselle as a very interesting and different kind of character then you would first imagine him to be. Here is one of the most famous diary quote of Roselle in the LOTM community:
You probably get the kind of character he is (but you still don't).
8.) Its Surprisingly funny
Seriously, I never expected it to make me laugh this much but it does. And the jokes are never not funny and always relevant to the story.
9.) It could have great discussions
I think LOTM could have a lot of discussions because there is always a lot to discuss. The author has done his research so there is simply nothing in the story that he has not explained. While some of this explanations could be removed by the donghua, even the main story line itself has a lot of lore that could be discussed. Currently the donghua is skipping a lot of parts of the novel and so some of the plot points come off as unnatural and trust me when I say that this could be intentional. There is a lore reason for even that. This is why I love LOTM. If the donghua continues to cover the first volume then you can be sure that this season will be leaving you hanging for more. Every volume ends in a sufficiently rewarding way for the viewer/reader to continue the storyline
So this are some of the reasons why I think it definitely should be on the subreddit. It has a lot of potential for discussions and r/anime happens to be the biggest subreddit which frequently trends in r/all and r/popular . More people should know of LOTM because that's how good of a story it is. I am sure many people on the sub are tired of isekai slop anime and want something new to watch. While there are already a bunch of excellent shows airing this season, LOTM is also one of them so it would be great if it can have some exposure here. Tencent and Crunchyroll both suck and do not market LOTM internationally for some reason so fans like me are desperately trying to let more people know of it. I know there are some problems which I have a potential solution or suggestion for:
1.) People start posting other donghua related content which the mods and bots have to remove increasing burden on them
On each discussion post of LOTM, just write in Caps and Bold in big font that "THIS DONGHUA IS AN EXCEPTION AND ANY OTHER DONGHUA RELATED POSTS WON'T BE TOLERATED". This should prevent a bunch of potential donghua posts. And to be honest donghua does not have a very big community. It is pretty small community so posts like this will way less than say "Which manga do you want adapted?" which the mods and bots have to remove probably everyday.
2.) This is r/anime so it is only for anime.
I know and that is why I am asking for LOTM to be made an exception. Also strictly speaking this sub is not "JapaneseAnime" so the name "anime" in itself does not mean that it is only talking about japanese anime. If any japanese were to visit this sub then they might expect it to be about animation and could be shocked to know that this sub does not allow Arcane or something. Because referring only Japanese Anime as anime is a western thing and even if the mods believe it is not, I still request them with all of my heart to just make this one donghua an exception. There is just no good place to talk about LOTM donghua. r/donghua is small and does not have much activity, r/LordofTheMysteries is filled with novel readers so spoilers are natural, other communities are too small to have some fun discussion.
So these are some of the problem which you mods might have. It is for the mods to decide whether this should be done or not but I request you guys to atleast try LOTM before deciding on this. I can guarantee that if you mods try just the first volume, you will be instantly hooked and understand why I want this to be an exception. The Donghua episodes are also decent but you will understand how good it is probably by the end of the season and that is just not good enough as I want discussion posts for the episodes while the show is airing. I hope you will understand and take a good decision Praise the Fool!
Edit: Fuck reddit's text formating