r/MEPEngineering • • 1h ago

Tips on finding revit 2020 families for Hvac, fire protection and plumbing equipment

0 Upvotes

Hello there fellow engineers, I am mechanical engineering graduate looking forward to start a career in MEP and I would appreciate some advice as to how to obtain free equipment families if possible or if I should create a replica for the following equipment: 45 ton VRF unit + 20 ton unit VRF 500 GPM diesel and electric fire pump 50 gpm jockey pump. I want to make a decision between creating replicas identical to real life equipment incase i Don't find available models or if i can find catalogs online. Revit is currently a requirement as of date and i am grateful to learn from your experiences as to how i can navigate my way through it. Thank you in advance.


r/MEPEngineering • • 23h ago

I built a 3D + 2D browser simulator (with Gemini Argon) to visualize pump flow-stealing, the 3D separator rule, and why Qp > Qs kills boiler condensation

4 Upvotes

I put together a single-file 3D + 2D hydronic simulator (Three.js + 2D Canvas P&ID) using Gemini Argon to help visualize primary-secondary decoupling and low-loss header regimes for junior engineers and students.

**What is modeled and analyzed:**

- **Direct-Coupled Pump Conflict (No Separator):** A primary boiler loop (DN65) tied directly to 3 secondary zone pumps with different shutoff heads: Z1 Panel Radiators (55 kPa), Z2 AHU Heating Coil (110 kPa), and Z3 Underfloor/FCU loop (38 kPa). When primary flow lags and Z2 ramps up, manifold pressure drops to `-30.7 kPa`, starving Z1 to `56%` and pulling `-0.68 m³/h` backwards through Z3 (with a toggleable non-return check valve on Z3).

- **Caleffi 3D / 10D Sizing Rule:** Adjustable `DN50–DN100` headers and `1.5D–4.0D` separator body ratios showing internal velocity (`v = Q/A = 0.100 m/s` at `3.0D` vs `≤ 0.15 m/s` threshold), air microbubble venting, and dirt separation efficiency.

- **Coupled Enthalpy Balance across the 3 Separator Regimes:**

  1. `Qp = Qs` (`12.0 m³/h`): `70.0 °C` supply / `52.5 °C` return (`< 54 °C` flue dew point → condensing active at `91.0%`).
  2. `Qp > Qs` (`13.8 > 6.95 m³/h`): Hot downward bypass mixes `70 °C` supply into `46.4 °C` building return, raising boiler return to `58.1 °C` and killing condensation.
  3. `Qp < Qs` (`7.2 < 13.45 m³/h`): Upward return recirculation blends secondary supply down from `70.0 °C` to `58.9 °C`.

Live browser simulator (single HTML file, no install):

https://www.meptasarim.com/hydraulic-separator-simulator.html

*Disclaimer: Informational & educational model only — not for engineering design.*

For those of you commissioning condensing boiler plants: how often do you still find constant-speed primary pumps running in Regime 2 (`Qp > Qs`) and preventing the boilers from ever condensing?


r/MEPEngineering • • 1h ago

Does MEP life good in india ?

0 Upvotes

I am a mechanical engineer with BIM MEP experience for 7 months , how is the stream going , does it pays well in positions ? And whata are the opportunitys out there , if you read please reply I'm very confused.


r/MEPEngineering • • 6h ago

Question Engineering Retirement

13 Upvotes

Hello there!

I am an active electrical professional engineer in my state, licensed since 1999. I retire in a couple of years at age 65. I'm wondering whether to do a little electrical consulting work or something completely different. Several of my peers died shortly after they quit working completely.

What are your thoughts on this matter? Frankly, I love what I do, but dealing with customers is the hardest part of my work; I'm okay at that skill.

Thanks all and good luck.

Philip in Georgia