r/MEPEngineering • • 6h ago

Question Engineering Retirement

13 Upvotes

Hello there!

I am an active electrical professional engineer in my state, licensed since 1999. I retire in a couple of years at age 65. I'm wondering whether to do a little electrical consulting work or something completely different. Several of my peers died shortly after they quit working completely.

What are your thoughts on this matter? Frankly, I love what I do, but dealing with customers is the hardest part of my work; I'm okay at that skill.

Thanks all and good luck.

Philip in Georgia


r/MEPEngineering • • 23h ago

I built a 3D + 2D browser simulator (with Gemini Argon) to visualize pump flow-stealing, the 3D separator rule, and why Qp > Qs kills boiler condensation

4 Upvotes

I put together a single-file 3D + 2D hydronic simulator (Three.js + 2D Canvas P&ID) using Gemini Argon to help visualize primary-secondary decoupling and low-loss header regimes for junior engineers and students.

**What is modeled and analyzed:**

- **Direct-Coupled Pump Conflict (No Separator):** A primary boiler loop (DN65) tied directly to 3 secondary zone pumps with different shutoff heads: Z1 Panel Radiators (55 kPa), Z2 AHU Heating Coil (110 kPa), and Z3 Underfloor/FCU loop (38 kPa). When primary flow lags and Z2 ramps up, manifold pressure drops to `-30.7 kPa`, starving Z1 to `56%` and pulling `-0.68 m³/h` backwards through Z3 (with a toggleable non-return check valve on Z3).

- **Caleffi 3D / 10D Sizing Rule:** Adjustable `DN50–DN100` headers and `1.5D–4.0D` separator body ratios showing internal velocity (`v = Q/A = 0.100 m/s` at `3.0D` vs `≤ 0.15 m/s` threshold), air microbubble venting, and dirt separation efficiency.

- **Coupled Enthalpy Balance across the 3 Separator Regimes:**

  1. `Qp = Qs` (`12.0 m³/h`): `70.0 °C` supply / `52.5 °C` return (`< 54 °C` flue dew point → condensing active at `91.0%`).
  2. `Qp > Qs` (`13.8 > 6.95 m³/h`): Hot downward bypass mixes `70 °C` supply into `46.4 °C` building return, raising boiler return to `58.1 °C` and killing condensation.
  3. `Qp < Qs` (`7.2 < 13.45 m³/h`): Upward return recirculation blends secondary supply down from `70.0 °C` to `58.9 °C`.

Live browser simulator (single HTML file, no install):

https://www.meptasarim.com/hydraulic-separator-simulator.html

*Disclaimer: Informational & educational model only — not for engineering design.*

For those of you commissioning condensing boiler plants: how often do you still find constant-speed primary pumps running in Regime 2 (`Qp > Qs`) and preventing the boilers from ever condensing?


r/MEPEngineering • • 23h ago

Steam Condensate Drain Below Pump Inlet

3 Upvotes

Title. I have 4 steam coils on the return of an AHU (don’t ask). The drain outlets on the bottom two sit about 6” off the ground and the inlet to my condensate pump sits about 18” off the ground. I do not have much experience with steam and haven’t had much luck asking colleagues. Would a solution be to drain the two coils into reservoirs and pipe that to the pump with a check valve downstream of the reservoir? Or do I need a pump for my pump…


r/MEPEngineering • • 1h ago

Tips on finding revit 2020 families for Hvac, fire protection and plumbing equipment

0 Upvotes

Hello there fellow engineers, I am mechanical engineering graduate looking forward to start a career in MEP and I would appreciate some advice as to how to obtain free equipment families if possible or if I should create a replica for the following equipment: 45 ton VRF unit + 20 ton unit VRF 500 GPM diesel and electric fire pump 50 gpm jockey pump. I want to make a decision between creating replicas identical to real life equipment incase i Don't find available models or if i can find catalogs online. Revit is currently a requirement as of date and i am grateful to learn from your experiences as to how i can navigate my way through it. Thank you in advance.