r/anime • u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • Apr 02 '23
Meta Meta Thread - Month of April 02, 2023
Rule Changes
Comment Karma Post Requirement
Users must have at least 10 comment karma on /r/anime in order to be able to make a post. Following last month's trial and feedback we voted to make this permanent, while exempting text posts using the [Help] and [What to Watch?] flairs from this rule. Attempting to deliberately bypass this rule by using those flairs instead of the appropriate one for the post's content is not allowed.
This is a monthly thread to talk about the /r/anime subreddit itself, such as its rules and moderation. If you want to talk about anime please use the daily discussion thread instead.
Comments here must, of course, still abide by all subreddit rules other than the no meta requirement. Keep it friendly and be respectful. Occasionally the moderators will have specific topics that they want to get feedback on, so be on the lookout for distinguished posts.
Comments that are detrimental to discussion (aka circlejerks/shitposting) are subject to removal.
Previous meta threads: March 2023 | February 2023 | January 2023 | December 2022 | November 2022 | October 2022 | September 2022 | August 2022 | July 2022 | June 2022 | May 2022 | April 2022 | Find All
New threads are posted on the first Sunday (midnight UTC) of the month.
•
u/DrJWilson x5https://anilist.co/user/drjwilson Apr 02 '23
Moshi mosh~~~
March Mod Report
March by the Numbers
24
u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler Apr 02 '23
You may have noticed the sidebar image changing more regularly. I have been playing with it daily the last two weeks now. The aim has been to make it more noticeable by rotating it more frequently. Also trying to give some love to upcoming rewatches and other things that are going on.
We don't have metrics on how much clicks it drives so its hard to know how much of an impact it has.
17
u/baseballlover723 Apr 02 '23
One minor thing I've seen on some What to Watch threads. Every once in a while theres a thread thats something like, "recommend me something with {broad tag}, don't recommend me anything mainstream because I've already watched them all" or "I've already watched 400 animes, but I'm it's too much work to list them or make a MAL".
The big issue with these posts is they end up being guessing games of what the person has watched. With the I've seen several hundred animes example, it feels rather disrespectful for people to admit that they've seen tons of anime, and thus common recommendations aren't valid for them, and yet, they're too lazy or don't care enough to list them out to filter out any recommendations they've already watched. With these I feel like they ought to be removed for low effort post, since 90% of the recommendations will just be "watched already".
With the mainstream example, I've often found that even when they say they've seen all the mainstream anime that doesn't really mean anything. Since what even counts as mainstream (/u/FetchFrosh this could be a fun idea to poll the subreddit about). Generally I find that a significant amount of these people have basically only seen like 5-10 of the most popular anime (which I would say is not even most of "mainstream" anime), and thus they artificially restrict recommendations to definitely not mainstream. These posts I don't think should be removed, they just kinda irk me when people use terms that are so biased to oneself.
Idk if theres really any actions that worth taking with these, kinda just a bit a of a pet peeve I see on a few What to Watch posts.
13
u/NegimaSonic :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/NegimaSonic Apr 20 '23
Not really something directly for /r/anime to do anything about but I became aware that Imgur is doing two things which likely affect various users beginning on May 15, 2023.
It's nothing new for images to die on the internet, but imgur has been pretty reliable for a long time and some people might not see these changes coming in time.
8
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Apr 25 '23
Another quarter, another million.
15
u/cppn02 Apr 02 '23
Already asked this in the March thread but since that was right before closing I'll try here again.
It's probably too late for parts 1 and 2 at this point but any chance that later when parts 3 and 4 release we can get a discussion post for the Kaguya special?
7
u/mysterybiscuitsoyeah xB:xC:B:x3:Y: Apr 23 '23
Requesting episode thread for Uma musume: road to the top please!
6
u/therealfosterforest Apr 15 '23
I'd like to double-check something for my upcoming Magia Record rewatch. I'm drafting a spoiler warning and a small question has come up where I'm not sure if my stance is in line with the mod team.
Magia Record is a spin-off of Puella Magi Madoka Magica. It very blatantly assumes that you have seen the main series: late reveals from PMMM are assumed knowledge from episode 1, MR takes for granted that people watching it are fans of PMMM. However, being a spin-off, it's not a sequel in the very strict sense of the word (it's definitely not a PMMM season 2).
For the MR rewatch posts, most participants will be coming directly from the PMMM rewatch. I would like to allow untagged PMMM spoilers in the MR episode discussion threads. If PMMM spoilers needed to be tagged, comments relating to the plot of MR would consist of nothing but black boxes. Looking at the original airing episode threads, discussions there seemed to work under the same assumption, which I find agreeable because watching MR without having seen PMMM would genuinely make no sense.
Does that sound like a good approach to you as well?
6
u/entelechtual Apr 24 '23
I’ve noticed a lot of issues with episode threads getting released. These are all being updated on legal streaming services on time—Crunchyroll for Raeliana and G Witch, YouTube for Umamusume, and Hulu/Disney for Heavenly Delusion. Is there an issue with how the bot is set up?
10
u/Terranwaterbender https://myanimelist.net/profile/Teranwaterbender Apr 13 '23 edited Apr 13 '23
Is there anything that can be done to mitigate the influence of source readers that plague the sub every time a remotely popular work gets adapted? Not talking about spoilers or anything since there are actual rules for that. It's more about how the entire vibe of the discussion is controlled by the manga readers and thus the low chance of actual discussion happening becomes nonexistent.
The sub has always had a problem when it comes to addressing source readers and their frankly overzealous fanboyism. The most recent example that comes to mind is Mushoku Tensei where the mods had to make a hard decision and just stop all semblance of discussions regarding that topic as it was very clear nothing was going to be accomplished during its airing. Of course once the show finished and all the fanboys scurried away, the sub went back to "normal" in my eyes.
Obviously we can just deal with it by just skipping the threads and say it just comes with the territory and I'm in that camp with Oshi no Ko but I'm curious if anyone has any ideas/rules that would help deal with source fans that come to /r/anime and end up controlling the pace of the discussion by controlling the topics and eliminating non-egregious critiques.
I will say that source readers controlling discussion isn't necessarily a bad thing. A positive example is /r/StarWars having interesting eye-opening discussions that result from lore users noting interesting details from other works and their significance. As a result, my experiences when watching The Mandalorian, Bad Batch, etc was actually enhanced. It just gets rather tiresome to read what feels like a copy/paste of /r/manga comments when they aren't blatantly spoiling/teasing information/fanboying. Yeah I can just ignore it but it would be nice to see the perspective from anime-only users and how it differed to /r/manga when the chapter first came out.
edit: The only solutions I can think of are blatantly subjective in nature which goes against the modding principles of this subreddit and would not be accepted (and frankly rightfully so). Temp banning users who "look" like they're source readers even if it's obvious is a recipe for future problems.
1
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan May 11 '23
This thread has been locked, please use next month's meta thread or find the latest thread.
5
u/Abyssbringer =anilist.co/user/Abyssbringer Apr 02 '23
Bounty Board:
The March Bounty Board went pretty well we added 44 new general flairs and 1 custom flair from it. Thank you to everyone who submitted!
General reminders and random thoughts:
April Bounty Board!
Submit Here
We need your help to make even more flairs for everyone on /r/anime! We have 5000 emoji slots we would like to fill up with a plethora of anime from all different types of genres and demographics.
The bounty board is a system that allows normal users to be able to submit a flair or flairs of their choice to be possibly added to /r/anime. To promote variety and make the system more interesting we will have various restrictions in place with the bounty board hopefully changing periodically.
Flairs will be chosen by the mods. Similar to how Comment Faces are currently chosen. We will be looking for things like overall quality, visibility, necessity, and creativity. Flairs chosen by this system won’t be guaranteed to exist on the subreddit forever. We are hoping to get to a state where unused/unpopular flairs can be retired once we hit the emoji limit.
The submission period will end on April 25th at 5 pm PST.
General Rules:
Categories (bold is new):
How to Submit a Flair
Please submit flairs to this Google Form. For any images please upload them to Imgur and give the appropriate link. If you aren’t very technical we don’t require users to crop and edit their submissions if they aren’t able to. Link the full uncropped image and we can handle the rest. If you do have the fully cropped and properly sized image please send that as well. It makes our lives much easier.
We will require:
5
u/Nebresto Apr 07 '23
Some time ago I asked if it was possible to update the Episode discussion threads a week after the final episode, to get the final poll score in the posts. Did that not work out?
5
u/Manitary https://myanimelist.net/profile/Manitary Apr 30 '23 edited Apr 30 '23
New horsegirls thread please
edit: thread is now up
4
u/Abyssbringer =anilist.co/user/Abyssbringer Apr 02 '23
/u/Tarhalindur
https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/11ihlcb/meta_thread_month_of_march_05_2023/jelj2jx/
Mai-Hime flair was broken because Reddit's emoji uploading is awful and will sometimes just not upload things when it says it does. This might've happened with others even though I double-uploaded most flairs to try and mitigate this problem. I have no clue about the weird oddities with its selecting and deselecting achievement flairs. Its probably fixed?
The Higurashi one is an interesting mess up. We used to have the old 6 million quiz reward flair as :SB: for its emoji code. When we switched to the new flairs we moved all 1 wide commonly used emoji's to a 1 letter emoji code since they were used widely used and we wanted to save character space for the vast majority of users. :SB: is now supposed to be allocated for general flairs but we ended up not removing the original SB when we swapped the system over. I'm kind of afraid of bricking a bunch of people's flairs who haven't updated them since the 6 million quiz so I just moved Hiurashi somewhere down the line.
4
u/chiliehead myanimelist.net/profile/chiliehead Apr 05 '23
I just came across a suspended account in another subreddit by a user who did helpful write-ups and the like and it all was removed. Seems like there was a change however long ago that suspended users get all their comments and posts removed. It appears they can be manually reapproved.
Did the mod team notice this and do you think this will have implications for the subreddit, e.g. Watch This or Rewatch posts being removed?
4
u/Manitary https://myanimelist.net/profile/Manitary May 02 '23 edited May 02 '23
Yesterday's daily thread does not have bot-chan linking today's just letting you know in case anything broke
(for a second I thought about the recent pushshift news, but iirc this kind of stuff uses praw so it shouldn't be affected)
4
u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler May 05 '23
The new seasonal faces have changed over. You can see them all on the wiki page. Or this image here.
#tomboyshadeshas been added as the seasonal hall of fame face for winter.3
u/Chukonoku :GS::GT::GU: Apr 03 '23 edited Apr 04 '23
Anyone using old Reddit and RES (Reddit Enhacement Suit)?
For some reason it hides the comments from the "Source Material Corner".
The automod comment shows up but all responses are hidden. It functions normally if i open up the thread using new.reddit or disabling RES.
EDIT: issue fixed with latest update as of 4/4/23
3
u/Abysswatcherbel https://myanimelist.net/profile/abyssbel Apr 05 '23
Recently I'm seeing people posting or commenting here and a few minutes later the user appears u[deleted] but the comment/post stays
Is that a Reddit glitch or it's the new bot control here?
3
u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler Apr 14 '23
Seasonal Comment face survey form. This is to see what faces were liked and how they compared to the season before.
(Results viewable here.)
Nomination thread scheduled for the 18th.
3
u/JollyGee29 https://myanimelist.net/profile/JollyGee May 05 '23
The WT! of the month sidebar still links to last month's winner.
5
u/No_Rex :Bv:Bw:Bx:By:x2 Apr 04 '23
Something I noticed yesterday that I thought would be worthwhile discussing here.
During the Animegataris rewatch yesterday, 3 comments were removed for spoilers, one by me, one by /u/xtsim, and one by /u/Shimmering-Sky. The interesting part is that we all put the same spoiler in our comments (regarding a reference to PMMM, you can guess what it was) and that all of us are very frequent rewatch participants. Neither of us falls under the "new user, does not know the rules" explanation.
What I believe has happened here is that the defacto culture towards spoilers has diverged in rewatches and new episode threads. Most rewatches, especially those of older and less popular anime, attract a crowd of veteran viewers, who already know a lot of anime (and often have participated in a lot of rewatches). One of the big things generating discussion during rewatches is comparisons to other anime: Which other anime did the VA appear in? What is the style of the director? What influences did this anime have on other anime? Where did these tropes appear in first? These kinds of questions. This discussion is impossible without referencing other anime, and the border between broad strokes comparison and directly discussing plot points is fluid. Of course, directly discussing plot points is otherwise known as spoilers when we talk about episode posts.
In rewatches, this has become normal, both because the standard canon of classic anime is known to a large majority of rewatchers and because we rewatchers might put more value on discussing references than on staying unspoiled for related shows (note that the tabu against spoiling future episodes of the anime currently rewatched is very much alife).
I am very sure that the type of spoiler via reference as in the example above is quite common in rewatches. However, we usually have very few interactions with mods in the rewatches (I guess there are few mod requests there, because we are generally a well-behaved bunch, but maybe the mods can elaborate on this point). I think that therefore, this divergence has slipped under the radar. Obviously, in a rewatch hosted by mods, where tons of mods participate, it would be noticed.
I do not have a direct recommendation for action here. So far, there seems to have been little problem with having slightly different cultures regarding spoilers and it only showed up because of the unusual mixing of mods and frequent rewatchers in the mod hosted rewatch. Never-the-less, I think it is worth thinking about it and whether it should be ignored, formalized or combatted.
4
u/ashxira Apr 23 '23
Good day guys, so for some context my post about choosing my favourite girls based on what anime people choose got taken down for being a shitpost, despite generating almost 300 comments in under 5 hours, with all of them being positive. The community seemed to like the post with a decent amount of discussion going on, however it still got taken down for breaking the rules.
I understand that the mods don't believe in any exceptions being made for the rules, but it does seem counter-intuitive to remove a post that's doing well with very good feedback, and a post that's overall healthy for the subreddit.
Any thoughts?
2
u/michhoffman :Ij::Ik::Il:https://anilist.co/user/michhoffman Apr 14 '23
The Mashle Discussion Threads have been over an hour late the past few weeks. I know this occasionally happens at the beginning of seasons so just wanted to bring it to your attention.
2
u/Avizie Apr 22 '23
Is it possible to include the following subreddits in their respective weekly discussion threads,
2
u/michhoffman :Ij::Ik::Il:https://anilist.co/user/michhoffman May 05 '23
With the new flairs being released today it got me curious whether there are plans to allow for people to select multiple flairs in the future. I've seen some of the mods with what looks like multiple flairs and thought it would be interesting. I'd be interested so that I could keep my custom Misaka flair while rotating around some others.
3
u/CT_BINO https://myanimelist.net/profile/CT_BINO Apr 09 '23
As anime only is quite hard to go to ep discussions when it feels some comments are just source readers pretending to be anime only. Maybe are lucky guesses and this stuff is tough to look for,because they can be anime only, but heard blue lock had ones and tengoku seemed to have, once again not sure, and with OnK coming might be better to just not enter those until the anime finishes
2
u/baseballlover723 Apr 05 '23
Something that I just saw, and might be a hole in the new karma requirements. Someone alleged that someone made a new account to ask for more recommendations (https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/12c9rub/finished_crunchyroll_anime_with_overpowered_main/jf0r5v7/). Regardless if this particular instance is true, the old karma rules should probably still apply to the What to Watch and Help flairs to avoid spam and ban evasion stuff.
2
u/Sparkletopia Apr 02 '23
With the new karma requirement now in place, are there any considerations to loosen the fanart rules? I feel like those have been pretty dead since they became required to all be text posts, maybe OC fanart could be exempt from that part?
1
u/CosmicPenguin_OV103 https://anilist.co/user/CosmicPenguin Apr 13 '23
Hi all, Idolmaster Cinderella Girls U149's EP2 discussion thread is missing despite Crunchyroll already has it (and EP1, 1 week late) for hours. Thanks!
1
u/gaunteyes Apr 10 '23
Has there been a discussion about encouraging users to use english names for anime in posts?
A good example of why it should be encouraged is the recent pseudo harem anime announcement post. It uses the Japanese name g-something harem. Which tells english speakers the completely wrong thing about the show. The show doesn't actually have a harem.
I know anime is a niche genre, so there's some expectation about researching things, but most people aren't going to do that. Using the english name will at least give people an idea if it's something they'd be interested in.
0
u/mr_beanoz https://myanimelist.net/profile/splitshocker Apr 09 '23
Lemme ask this again, how can I promote my survey here?
Our survey here is kinda like "best op/ed of the season" but limited to those performed by voice actors. If I could promote it, I want to also make one for "best of 2022".
https://s.surveyplanet.com/yvsvpv36
0
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment