r/anime • u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • Sep 07 '25
Meta Meta Thread - Month of September 07, 2025
Rule Changes
This is a monthly thread to talk about the /r/anime subreddit itself, such as its rules and moderation. If you want to talk about anime please use the daily discussion thread instead.
Comments here must, of course, still abide by all subreddit rules other than the no meta requirement. Keep it friendly and be respectful. Occasionally the moderators will have specific topics that they want to get feedback on, so be on the lookout for distinguished posts. If you wish to message us privately send us a modmail.
Comments that are detrimental to discussion (aka circlejerks/shitposting) are subject to removal.
Previous meta threads: August 2025 | July 2025 | June 2025 | May 2025 | April 2025 | March 2025 | February 2025 | January 2025 | December 2024 | November 2024 | October 2024 | September 2024 | August 2024 | July 2024 | June 2024 | May 2024 | April 2024 | March 2024 | February 2024 | January 2024| Find All
New threads are posted on the first Sunday (midnight UTC) of the month.
•
u/ZaphodBeebblebrox Y:A:https://anilist.co/user/zaphod Sep 07 '25 edited Sep 07 '25
August Mod Report
August By the Numbers
11
u/awesomenessofme1 https://myanimelist.net/profile/kta_99 Sep 07 '25
Since it's just about to start, I'm curious as to whether Fragrant Flower is going to get the Sakamoto Days treatment when it comes to discussion threads despite the extreme time gap, or what actually is going to happen.
11
u/cppn02 Sep 13 '25
Looks like we're in for another round of daily Demon Slayer box office news...
11
u/SmurfRockRune https://myanimelist.net/profile/Smurf Sep 16 '25
How come AutoLovepon threads don't get marked as FINAL on the final episode anymore?
10
u/Mitsuyan_ https://anilist.co/user/mitsuyan Sep 07 '25
One thing has come to me this month and it's an interesting question I hope. It relates to last month's talk on streaming services and as usual Pokémon and Beyblade doing something different to be cool and epic.
As it stands, some OPs and EDs are hard gated behind VPNs. That's fine for me, I live in the UK where it's pretty much mandatory to have a VPN nowadays if you want to get anywhere. But for a number of users here, VPNs may not be something they have, so I can't just, say, post GET BACK because only people with a Japanese VPN active can watch it.
So my question is - is it acceptable to repost OPs/EDs as a video instead of linking to the YouTube or Twitter? Openings with the lore of GET BACK or endings with the song quality of Stay Gold don't show up often and them being region locked, to me, prevents a lot of people from enjoying them.
There's always a few anime that have to be different aren't there?
10
u/Infodump_Ibis :JY::JZ: Sep 30 '25
Imgur is now blocked in the UK. (dodge a potential fine)
I was thinking what does this mean for comment face nominations. Annoyance as I can't see what most submissions are but also some confusion wrt to the "So how do I nominate a seasonal face?" section as I'll need non-imgur examples.
Likewise, as I migrate to another host are there any image hosts the comment face submission managers really like or dislike (e.g. catbox can be slow so might be disliked)?
10
u/baseballlover723 Oct 01 '25 edited Oct 01 '25
9
u/ussgordoncaptain2 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Edmund_Nelson Sep 07 '25 edited Sep 07 '25
The erotica post
(this is a 2 part post)
With the hubaloo around nukitashi I decided to actually take a look at classifying the "borderline hentai" (AKA erotica) shows
With MAL I decided an anime qualfiies if it was labeled "erotica", Anilist I decided an anime would Qualify if it was labled (Adult) and NOT labeled hentai (annoyingly Anilist does not let you search for a negative so this is actually harder than it sounds) So in Anilists case the "Labeled adult and not hentai" were "labeled adult and ecchi and not hentai".
If anyone can do something similar with Kitsu/Anime Planet/anidb I'd be all ears, but I literally have no clue how to do it. the best I could up with for Anidb was the "borderline porn tag with 83 entries, a Superset of the 11 shows mentioned below in my card but also Included Goblin Slayer AND Cross Ange!)
https://myanimelist.net/animelist/Eroticatesting?status=7 This MAL profile is the result.
A show labeled "dropped" is either a Dongua or wasn't on Anilist. But I kept them on the list for completeness sake (and maybe someone will find them on Anilist) A show labeled "on hold" airs on Television, if you plan on labeling manually for Kitsu/anime planet/animedb consider just doing those 11 shows as they are orders of magnitude more popular than all the others. (it would also be nice to do those 11+Please put them on Takamine San with High School DxD and A kite as reference material, DxD is a good frame of reference IMO.) The other 60 are much less important. Being only OVAs/ONAs and unlikely to have >100k viewers on MAL.
This leaves us with 71 total shows to choose from.
A show can have 3 labels Per Site
-1 means :"Show was considered not adult" (call it "normal anime)
0 means :"erotica on MAL or Adult and not hentai on Anilist"
1 means :"Hentai"
From here There is a theoretical 3x3 matrix but only 5 squares would be completely filled
The 4 ignored ones would be "normal, normal" EX High school DxD , "Normal, Hentai' and "Hentai, normal" (if anyone is a fan of Yaoi and wants to actually find examples of the latter 2 be my guest!) and Hentai hentai (ex Bible Black)
The 5 remaining categories
Erotica on Anilist, Normal Anime on MAL (11 Shows) (EX Yosuga No Sora)
Erotica on Anilist, Hentai on MAL (5 Shows) (EX Fencer of Minerva )
Erotica on Both (18 shows) (EX Redo of Healer)
Normal Anime on Anilist, Erotica on MAL (27 Shows) (EX, Valkyrie drive mermaid
hentai on Anilist, erotica on MAL (10 Shows) (EX, Yarichin Bitch Club )
Because Erotica is a created category out of negations and isn't a natural category it's smaller on Anilist in general as a concept (though the fact that I could extract examples was impressive!)
One other thing to note is that MAL only grandfathered in the Shows previously labeled "Ecchi" into the category "erotica" MAL mods might have grandfathered in some of the shows of the 5 otherwise.
From here it's time to look at "Was the show of each archetype discussed in /r/anime ?" Each archetype I will search for it will be given a 3/3 if it had a Rewatch 2/3 if it has discussion threads dedicated to it and a 1/3 if it is mentioned in discussion posts
Erotica Anilist Normal MAL: 3/3 (Yosuga no Sora Rewatch)
Erotica Anilist Hentai MAL 1/3 (Kakyuusei had a few threads but anything >10k popularity isn't going to get almost anything anyway)
Erotica Both 2/3 (Redo of Healer discussion thread)
Normal on Ani Erotica MAL 2/3 (Valkyrie drive mermaid discussion thread)
Erotica MAL Hentai anilist 1/3 (Multiple threads on Yarichin Bitch Club but no discussion thread by the mods)
Nukitashi the animation... is in category 4 a show that Anilist consideres "not even adult" the same as High school DXD, but MAL calls Erotica.
In general anime has gotten less horny over the past 10 years (from 2015 which was peak horny) For example Cross ange angel of rondo and dragon wasn't even given an Ecchi tag on MAL (it aired in 2014-2015)
High School DxD, To Love Ru, The Testament of Sister new devil, Triage X and Valkyrie drive Mermaid
What do these shows have in common? They are all extremely horny. They also all aired a season in 2015.
However starting in 2020 there were a small number of shows that bucked the trend. Those being interpecies reviewrs Peter Grill and The Philosophers time (s1/2) Redo of healer World's end harem , Harem in the labyrinth of another world and Nukitashi the animation
and while this one isn't listed as erotica it's critical to the story and it's Please put them on Takamine san
The first anime to annoy western licensers was Interspecies reviewers which starts this trend. Of course the 2nd lewdest of the 6 was the trend starter and funi's decision to remove it was highly critized (if anyone can find the actual article that would be great) What's interesting is that Harem Labyrinth, and Peter Grill release to much less fanfare 2https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/x58lz5/meta_thread_month_of_september_04_2022/. 3 Peter Grill gets very little "the sky is falling" and just is like "yep anime's at it again".
Checking Redo of healer I also see little in the way of fanfare. (And that was REDO OF HEALER) I really had to search to find much negativity, but there wasn't any complaining I could find (though better searchers than I exist) about it being on /r/anime
(It's important to not just cite singular examples but when N=6 n=6)
Now one of the most important events of this saga was actually happening inside crunchyroll which we saw in the broadcast of "please put them on Takamine san"
[Certain episodes had crunchyroll play the censored version that came out the tuesday a week later rather than the uncensored version of the wenedsday (causing the epic song and dance 3 5 and 10 Something within crunchyroll had them decide that certain parts of that show were "above the line" for them (Note Harem in the labyrinth of another world is also on crunchyroll but is partially censored). After this Fiasco there are some rumors that say that Crunchyroll is done with borderline stuff. (note all rumors are dubious and this rumor was by a member of Oceanveil Staff IIRC but basically don't trust the rumor much). But either way this whole fiasco highlights an important point, there are lines crunchyroll is unwilling to cross and those lines appear in some anime. (Interspecies reviewers and Please put them on Takamine San being notable examples)
part 2 in replies
9
u/baseballlover723 Sep 20 '25
Version 3.2.0 has been released for r/anime Enhanced 2.0.
Changelog:
New icons and also settings sync now between browser instances. Also I think I fixed some of the settings, cause I think disabled comment faces and anilist didn't work before.
Chrome (should be approved in a bit)
FireFox (already approved)
Will hopefully get the sub counter back tomorrow. Revamping the settings took longer than I expected because
Javascript sucksI insisted on making an infinitely recursively option setting (ok, it's not quite infinitely recursive, the formatting for options isn't, but the data underneath is).8
u/TheBlessedBoy99 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Amiibo Sep 07 '25
What's the satire flair? I see a lot about it.
8
u/Mitsuyan_ https://anilist.co/user/mitsuyan Sep 08 '25
https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/1nbka2q/comment/nd2fus1/
I imagine this has been a thing for a while but wow this is a great way to hit them with the "just watch the damn anime" and remove the thread. Almost to the point where we could automate the answer...
I recently pinned Watch the damn anime. to my phone keyboard because I use it so much
8
u/ZaphodBeebblebrox Y:A:https://anilist.co/user/zaphod Sep 09 '25
We just started a two week trial of allowing Discussion posts to bypass the karma filter. This will likely mean there will be some more really bad and rule breaking discussion posts on /new, and hopefully some good ones as well.
Help, What to Watch?, Watch This!, and Writing posts already bypass the filter, so this would bring Discussion more in alignment with them.
If you have any negative or positive experiences with this trial, please let us know.
8
u/baseballlover723 Sep 18 '25
The r/anime enhanced extension for Firefox has been approved.
Please let me know if you run into bugs.
8
u/BaytaCosmico https://myanimelist.net/profile/AnimeBayta Sep 21 '25
So I've been told that even saying that an adaptation has been done well and seems to be set to end at a good place (without even hinting at what that good place might be - note: good place doesn't necessarily mean a happy ending, just a good stopping point for the story, which is open to interpretation) is prohibited outside the source material corner. What's the logic behind this rule? Are source readers not allowed to participate in regular discussions period? Or if we want to participate, we have to pretend the source doesn't even exist? https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/1nmckdo/comment/nfe780s/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=mweb3x&utm_name=mweb3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button
8
u/qwertyqwerty4567 https://anilist.co/user/ZPHW Sep 22 '25
I thought I was going insane misremembering the name of a show the other day, but it turns out that wasn't the case.
Why are Kamitsubaki's threads called Kamitsubaki City Under Production and not [...] under Construction?
8
u/KiwiBennydudez https://myanimelist.net/profile/KiwiBen Sep 22 '25
Alright, there's been quite a lot of discussion around KnY and CSM posts, so I decided to crunch the numbers myself. This data was gathered by filtering by flair and manually counting each post from the last 6 months. Do note that the CSM stats are compiled from the last 3 months, as that's roughly when the news cycle for this film began.
Demon Slayer: Infinity Castle
Total: 33
Chainsaw Man: Reze Arc
Total: 24
Averages
Overall Stats
In the past month, we received 73 posts flaired as news. 13 of those posts were about either CSM or KnY, which means only 17% of News posts in the past month have been about either of these anime. This number is certainly a little high, but as others have pointed out, I think this is a combination of these two anime having news cycles that overlap with each other, as well as CSM and KnY being two extremely popular mainstream anime, so I also don't think it's unusual that they're so ubiquitous right now.
Personally speaking, I don't love the fact that these two anime dominate the front page at the moment, but I also do think that when you put things into perspective on the month-to-month breakdown, the problem is not as severe as it might seem.
To give another example, Re:Zero received 16 OM posts since the start of S3 (removing the episode previews and Break Time shorts). If you remove the S4 content as well, this number drops to 10 posts over its 16 week runtime. So I don't think KnY or CSM dominating a single flair is exactly unprecedented.
What exactly we will do about this (if anything) remains to be seen, but for now I think we're content with monitoring the situation to see if things continue at this rate or not. If they do, or if they continue to ramp up, then we can consider pulling some levers on the rules to try and throttle the frequency. But I think things are fine for the time being, though I'm rather wary of how long things will take to settle down.
7
u/DependentOnIt https://myanimelist.net/profile/Potatosalad1 Sep 17 '25
Why isn't the anime poster bot putting FINAL on posts anymore?
7
u/itsadoubledion Sep 22 '25
Hi, just wondering if anyone knows why the episode discussion threads stopped getting marked with FINAL for the last episode of the season? (eg. Grand Blue has 12 episodes according to MAL but the post doesn't specify that it's finished today)
I (and probably some other people) prefer catching up on shows when the season ends, and it's more difficult to keep track without the titles
Thanks!
7
u/qwertyqwerty4567 https://anilist.co/user/ZPHW Sep 23 '25
What is the reason for the current rules regarding mentioning piracy websites? Does it come from the reddit admins in order to keep the sub in the "good" tier or is there another reason?
7
u/Vatrix-32 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Vatrix-32 Sep 27 '25
The Broken Comment Face should be added to the source page for commentfaces. It has a source, it should be listed.
7
u/mekerpan Oct 03 '25
Is it possible to add an ep0 link in the episode discussion threads for Towa no Yugure. The ep list starts with ep1 -- and it looks like lots of folks are unaware that there was an ep0 (I do think this got an official discussion thread). Thanks
6
u/baseballlover723 Sep 07 '25 edited Sep 08 '25
if you use a third party app or browse reddit on something other than old reddit, sh reddit, mobile web (android and iOS), official Reddit app (android and iOS) and wish to help me out in testing if spoiler tags are respected on your platform (ie, if they are hidden). Please let me know what platform you have access to, and I'll send you a reddit post to gather some data from.
I am reevaluating our automated spoiler tag rules and checking if there are any we can remove, since it appears that reddit fixed a spoiler bug on old reddit in the recent past.
Edit, here is the full test suite, let me know which ones are fully hidden (and what platform) if you use a platform that isn't specified above.
Valid spoiler tag (control, this is the spoiler text used for all examples): [Spice and Wolf] Holo has a tail.
Valid spoiler tag (single new line): [Spice and Wolf] Holo has a tail.
Spoiler paragraph form: [Spice and Wolf] >!Holo
has
a
tail.!<
Spoiler single space after opening tag: [Spice and Wolf] Holo has a tail.
Spoiler multiple spaces after opening tag: [Spice and Wolf] Holo has a tail.
Valid Spoiler single space before closing tag: [Spice and Wolf] Holo has a tail.
Valid Spoiler multiple spaces before closing tag: [Spice and Wolf] Holo has a tail.
Spoiler nested tags: [Spice and Wolf] Holo has [spoiler] inception a tail.
6
u/baseballlover723 Sep 14 '25
The Google Chrome comment face extension was approved. I didn't change anything from Chariot's version, other than upgrading the manifest to version 3.
6
u/chiliehead myanimelist.net/profile/chiliehead Sep 17 '25
RIP subscriber count, any plans on new milestone metrics?
6
u/Rumpel1408 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Rumpel1408 Sep 18 '25
seasnonal reminder to post and highlight seasonal surveys in a timely manner
6
u/Silent_Ad379 Sep 24 '25
My post, posting a video uploaded by crunchyroll was deleted for poor quality or something. Is it because I chose "clip" flair or is crunchyroll uploads not up to spec these days?
6
u/Ashteron Sep 25 '25
Towa no Yuugure episode 0 discussion seems to be missing.
6
u/Verzwei Sep 26 '25
I sent a normal report on account of this post being low effort AF, but I'm also bringing it up here because auto mod should have kicked this to the curb due to insufficient length.
6
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Sep 27 '25
I just noticed the Anime of the Week links in the sidebar/dropdown (and on shreddit) are all pointing at an older thread, the last one made before this change to the schedule. I'm guessing no one updated the modbot cron schedule for the script that updates the links to match the new time now, so when it runs at the old scheduled time it doesn't find anything.
10
u/Ocixo https://myanimelist.net/profile/BuzzyGuy Sep 21 '25
I’m usually more laidback about this sort of thing, but the amount of posts about the success of these anime films is reaching silly territory now. It had barely been an hour before a new one got posted.
Between Demon Slayer and CSM, there have easily been ten official “News” posts in the last week. The entire frontpage is cluttered with them. A new one for every few million dollars/yen more in revenue.
Can’t we do something to cut back on all this blatant karma farming? Like adding a rule that a set amount of time must’ve past - a few days to a week for example - before another post regarding “news” on the topic can be created again?
1
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Oct 05 '25
This thread has been locked, please use next month's meta thread or find the latest thread.
5
u/Infodump_Ibis :JY::JZ: Sep 13 '25
The previous « Previous Thread link the daily OP has been going back to September 10th for a few days now.
5
u/shirts21 Sep 17 '25
I did a post and tagged it infographic and the post was a picture of an excel sheet of fall anime 2025. It was removed cause it was low effort for a info graphics. If I changed the tag to discussion or misc can I put my post up again?
5
u/Time_Fracture https://myanimelist.net/profile/Time_Fracture Sep 23 '25
Maybe a bit early, but when Tatsuki Fujimoto 17-26 got released will the short stories have their own discussion thread or grouped on one discussion thread?
5
u/cheesechimp https://myanimelist.net/profile/cheesechimp Sep 23 '25
is on the pages of comment faces sorted by show and by emotion, but not on the main wiki page for commentfaces
5
u/noheroman https://anilist.co/user/kurisuokabe Sep 26 '25
No thread yet about the new Cat's Eye?
u/zaphodbeebblebrox
5
u/Zeallfnonex https://myanimelist.net/profile/Neverlocke Oct 03 '25
is missing from https://old.reddit.com/r/anime/wiki/commentfaces, as I just found out while trying to find it. Not sure if there's other commentfaces missing, but I was looking for that one in particular...
5
u/mr_beanoz https://myanimelist.net/profile/splitshocker Oct 04 '25
Seems like the first episode of the Nohara Hiroshi show was released a few hours ago.
5
u/Emi_Ibarazakiii Oct 04 '25
I was talking about Tanya the evil in some thread, and given we had a discussion about spoilers recently, that made me wonder...
Would it be considered a spoiler to comment in AQRADT or wherever about how [Tanya the evil]Tanya could win the best boy contest?
I spoiler tagged it to be sure, because it does seem like a spoiler, but on the other hand, [Tanya the evil]everyone checking out the contest will be spoiled, with no tag or warning
8
u/cppn02 Sep 19 '25
Oof. Thank god we got a new movie to give us daily earning updates. I was already getting withdrawal symptons.
r/animeboxoffice truly is this site's greatest subreddit.
4
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Sep 09 '25
Proposal for the mods to do something I thought about but never bothered to: retroactively flair older Episode threads so you can find them more easily via search rather than needing to go to the wiki.
4
u/qwertyqwerty4567 https://anilist.co/user/ZPHW Sep 11 '25
formally requesting a new/updated version of r/anime enhanced.
4
u/ussgordoncaptain2 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Edmund_Nelson Sep 12 '25
Ok this is silly but what reporting reason are you supposed to give for "Civility violation"?
The recent reports I went Reports>Breaks>Custom response Violates "Please maintain a certain level of civility when interacting with the community." but is that the correct way to report?
4
u/Verzwei Sep 16 '25
Think I came across an improper spoiler removal. This help post looking for a show ID was removed for spoiler tagging. OP tagged the post as a spoiler and then the post was removed for not using inline tags. Except OP doesn't know the show name, so they can't follow the subreddit spoiler format anyway.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but proper procedure would have been to untag the thread but otherwise leave it up. If people are going into a help thread to ID something based on a description, there's an implicit assumption that spoilers could occur, and if the other users reading the thread don't know the show in question, then they have no idea what they're reading spoilers for, so they're still safe.
4
u/M8gazine https://myanimelist.net/profile/M8gazine Sep 18 '25
Are VNDB links allowed, assuming that the page the link directs to is SFW?
Just started wondering after I referred to a VN, thought about it, and opted to avoid linking to VNDB just now because I know there's a lot of NSFW on the site in general due to the nature of many VNs being eroges and stuff. There are plenty of safe VNs on the site too, but it's also a fact that you are also like 2 relatively simple clicks away from seeing straight-up hentai at any given moment.
I guess sites like MAL have 18+ things listed too, but it is also much harder to find them there.
4
u/baboon_bassoon https://anilist.co/user/duffer Sep 20 '25
I'm curious about the Baan post
I assume it was manually posted as its a one off. Why is it posted as an episode discussion and not just linking the anime under the new Short Film flair?
Instead of having to search for the film, could have just gotten linked to it from here + it shows off the new flair to people that dont check the meta thread
4
u/Verzwei Oct 02 '25
Has the [context tag] requirement been dropped for spoilers? The rules page looks the same so I assume not.
This post seems like it should have been popped by automod because there are three different spoiler tags in the post and none of them have a context tag. Moreover, multiple shows are soft-spoiled under those tags confirming a 1:1 romance ending and even indicating who the "winning" girl was for those harem series.
I get that it's a discussion post with a lot of upvotes and a ton of comments and both of those things are a rarity in Reddit's current landscape, but I don't think I've ever seen exceptions allowed to the [context tag] even for satirical/humor reasons, and in this case I'd argue there are some actual spoilers being discussed in this OP and thread and there's no way to know what shows are being spoiled until you've read them.
I didn't read every single reply fully, but at a glance it seems like a mod participated in the thread in an unofficial capacity, and one comment was removed for toxicity by a different mod. What was the basis for leaving the post up as it was, and how did automod miss it in the first place? I was pretty sure that automod re-checks edited content for certain rules, the spoiler rule being among them.
I ask because I've been pretty careful to tiptoe around some stuff in a thread for a recent adaptation announcement and making sure I properly tagged anything of detail. If I don't need to bother doing that, I won't in the future.
Since I know I ramble a lot, I'll try to make three succinct questions here so I can understand the rule application:
4
u/Zeallfnonex https://myanimelist.net/profile/Neverlocke Oct 04 '25
Did I do something wrong in this [WT!] submission? As far as I can tell, my profile claims I successfully posted it an hour ago... But I don't see it on the subreddit sorting by New, both on my own account or a browser without me logged into it? And staying with only my own upvote on it at 100%, implying that no one else can see it either? No message from an automod either, implying that it wasn't taken down as far as I'm aware of?
I am very confused if I messed up a setting somewhere... Flaired, meets the length criteria and no spoilers AFAICT...
Reddit being reddit, maybe? Or does it need to get approved or something?
6
u/ComfortablyRotten https://anilist.co/user/Leuwtian Sep 09 '25
Assuming there isn't anything like that already (doesn't seem to be but I could have missed it), I think there should be a "no major focus on or involvement from generative AI tools" clause or similar to the sub's definition of anime.
I don't think the tech will be adopted en masse by the industry anytime soon, but I also don't think stuff like this should ever allowed to be openly discussed in the same vein as any other anime.
3
u/Puddo x3https://anilist.co/user/STPuddo Sep 17 '25
With the whole short film thing. Uploading it to Reddit is fine if there are no legal alternatives? I assume with the standard clip rules, but does that also include the 5 min limit? Or can I for example just toss the entire 10 minutes of Yuureisen on the sub?
3
u/cppn02 Sep 23 '25
Just for clarification before I waste time reporting 30 comments, spoilers about the Infinity Castle movie should still be tagged in a KV post about said movie right?
Because some people seem to be treating this one as a movie discussion thread.
5
u/Zeallfnonex https://myanimelist.net/profile/Neverlocke Sep 16 '25
Haven't we seen previous posts about Texas' SB20 in the past, and deemed that people simply didn't understand that there's a specific legal definition of obscene and that people were fearmongering because certain distributors who also didn't understand the law properly were pulling material cuz they thought it would be banned? As it is, the current thread is just full of "Republicans and Texas bad" with all sorts of stupid political stuff that doesn't belong in this subreddit.
Like, this is already part of U.S. federal code:
Just seems like an fearmongering and incorrect article that doesn't even apply to anime as defined by this subreddit (it might apply to hanime, but that's not under the purview of this subreddit anyways.)
4
u/Verzwei Sep 16 '25 edited Sep 16 '25
Making the simple statement "I miss the karma rule" on an idiotic, worthless shitpost shouldn't be sufficient to qualify for a meta discussion removal, in my opinion. I was less harsh than the top comment you left up in that thread
5
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '25
This probably deserves in the meta thread but I will probably forget when it does come up so why don’t the mods just make a megathread for movie earnings of each season (three months) ? It’s quite boring to open up and the sub and see numbers for the same two movies.
For example, fall has these releasing
Just ask people to post the earnings of these movies in the megathread.
Copied my comment.
2
u/-i-n-t-p- Sep 08 '25
PLEASE ADD A DISCLAIMER: Sakamoto Days is 1 week behind on Netflix.
Hi, I really enjoyed the latest episode of Sakamoto Days so I decided to check this week's discussion. Turns out the Netflix stream (which is the only official stream) is 1 week behind, and I got spoiled hard.
Posting in hopes of helping someone avoid getting spoiled, and to hopefully get a mod to add the disclaimer.
Netflix lists it as episode 20, whereas the Discussion post lists it as episode 10 of Part 2. It's not obvious that we're 1 episode behind, unless we remember that Part 1 had 10 episodes. In other words, I should've been looking for episode 9 instead of 10.
2
u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ Sep 09 '25 edited Sep 09 '25
Should the Deca-dence episodes be in the 2020 episode discussion wiki list? An I blind? Am I fatally handicapped by trying to use reddit on my phone?
https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/hnih7t/decadence_episode_1_discussion/
/u/shimmering-sky
Also the daily thread is linking to last month's meta thread
Also I've posted this three times because I thought I was on the meta thread the first two times.
Also also, there are 12 episodes, but the discussion threads end at 11.
this is episode 12
What happened to the autoposting? A digital stroke?
2
u/rainzer Sep 22 '25
Removing posts with the blanket civility claim because someone's butthurt about disagreement and not replying to the inquiry for clarification is an interesting mod choice. Either remove all contextually or remove none because using the OP's wording either is civil or not instead of selectively civil.
2
u/Boris-_-Badenov Oct 04 '25
https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/s/5XOBEAqjJW
wtf. I didn't post anything about content that wasn't already released years ago.
can't reply to that comment, because it's locked. can't use the link to message, it tells me to chat.... can't send a chat............
4
u/Emi_Ibarazakiii Sep 11 '25
I don't imagine there ever was any discussion on this, but I was thinking about this during the previous best girl contest... Could we make an exception on the "Clip reposting" rule during that type of events (or hell, has it ever been considered to simply remove that rule?)
I did get flagged by that rule back then (trying to post a clip that was in the top 75 all time, and thus wasn't allowed to be reposted).
I imagine this rule is in place to prevent people from karma farming by endlessly reposting the top clips, but if someone was going for that, is there really that big a difference between reposting the 67th to clip of all time, and the 84th clip?
And while I'm not keeping track of it, just by the 'eye test' I'm pretty sure the overwhelming majority of the top available clips (76+) aren't reposted that often, so I wonder how big an issue it would be if that rule was completely lifted...
I did look at the clips posted since the contest ended (almost a month ago) and there were EIGHT clips posted that aren't from currently airing seasonals, that got at least 1k karma.
I did look at the account of the people who did post them, and even being generous with the definition of 'Karma farmer' (i.e. someone posting clips who doesn't really seem to care about anime that much), there were maybe 2 of them.
So I guess I'm wondering... Do we really need a rule like that to stop 2 karma farmers a month?
Also worth noting that while the #1 top clip of all time earned 31k karma, and the #75 clip of all time got 15k, the #225 clip of all time got 11.5k (for some reason I can't go past 225, I guess Reddit is Reddit'ing).
Which means there is at least 150 clips that have >75% of the karma count of the #75 clip. And almost 40% of the karma of the #1 clip of all time.
And these 150 clips are pretty much never reposted.
So are the top 75 clips not reposted because it's not possible to repost them?
Or are they not reposted because people simply aren't jumping at every opportunity to karma-farm clips?
Because if it's the latter, then perhaps doing away with the rule (during best girl contests, if not entirely) could allow for good participation in the sub, while NOT overwhelming it with countless clips.
I mean, if a karma farming account really wanted to do it, they could do it twice with a 11k karma clip, still worth it even if it's not the 30k karma clip, but they don't.
So I'm not sure why they would, simply for a little more karma per clip.
And even if they did, well it would still be limited to 2 clips a month, so it's not dealbreaking, AND worst case scenario, we could always do a bit of 'case by case' thing (like we do for cosplay), i.e. if someone is obviously just karma leeching and doesn't ever comment in r/anime in general, we can always just show them the door.
So with this in mind, and the fact that people aren't even bothering to repost all the available 10k+ karma clips, makes me think they wouldn't really bother for the 20k+ either.
And generally speaking, I'm not sure there is a big downside to people reposting top clips once in a while; People LOVE discussing stuff in clip threads, and while it may not be thesis-material discussions, it can't be worse than most of the random threads in here, right? Rec naime wth guns pls. I WATCH DEMON SLAYER!..
Sometimes clips do bring interesting discussions, and sometimes people watch a clip and go "Ok that looks fun, I'm gonna check it out" (People do post clips as PR sometimes, especially with seasonals, but could work for older shows as well!)
And it would give people a good opportunity to do it either for best girl contests, or in general (wanting to post a clip from an old show they now just watched and feel like gushing over, and clips are often a good way to do that, given random threads don't get the same attention).
All in all, I suppose it's not that big a deal, but it feels like a constraint that doesn't really achieve much either, when it even comes into play.
Like if we had a law about not crossing the streets at exactly 13:47. It's not a dealbreaker, just wait 13:48, but... What does it achieve?
That's how I see it!
Also, my clip 100% would've made Marin win, so if we could edit the winner's page to put her instead, that'd be nice!
4
u/max4citycouncil Oct 02 '25
Are cosplay spam accounts that link to OF still allowed? Really brought down the sub quality since they are basically just veiled ads. Thought they were prohibited a while back.
2
u/mr_beanoz https://myanimelist.net/profile/splitshocker Sep 17 '25
With the recent uptakes on post asking about "anime tourists" being posted and removed, I wonder if there should be a big post that would describe what that term supposed to be.
2
u/Verzwei Sep 19 '25
Has the anime-specific rule been relaxed recently? I would think this post fails to meet the threshold of anime-specific discussion since
Reported it hours ago. Looks like it not only remained up, but there are paragraphs upon paragraphs of arguing in it, some of which is coming from the moderation team in an untagged/personal capacity.