r/anime • u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • Oct 05 '25
Meta Meta Thread - Month of October 05, 2025
Rule Changes
- No new rule changes.
This is a monthly thread to talk about the /r/anime subreddit itself, such as its rules and moderation. If you want to talk about anime please use the daily discussion thread instead.
Comments here must, of course, still abide by all subreddit rules other than the no meta requirement. Keep it friendly and be respectful. Occasionally the moderators will have specific topics that they want to get feedback on, so be on the lookout for distinguished posts. If you wish to message us privately send us a modmail.
Comments that are detrimental to discussion (aka circlejerks/shitposting) are subject to removal.
Previous meta threads: September 2025 | August 2025 | July 2025 | June 2025 | May 2025 | April 2025 | March 2025 | February 2025 | January 2025 | December 2024 | November 2024 | October 2024 | September 2024 | August 2024 | July 2024 | June 2024 | May 2024 | April 2024 | March 2024 | February 2024 | Find All
New threads are posted on the first Sunday (midnight UTC) of the month.
•
u/MyrnaMountWeazel x2 Oct 05 '25 edited Oct 05 '25
September Mod Report
Heya everyone~
I hope everyone is enjoying the Fall seasonals. For me, I’m going to be hibernating till that sweet, sweet Winter 2026 arrives. Ikoku Nikki, my beloved.
September by the Numbers
15
u/MyrnaMountWeazel x2 Oct 05 '25 edited Oct 06 '25
If an anime releases on the internet and no one is around to see it, does it receive a discussion thread?
So every so often things will slip through the cracks, where users, mods, and even Bot-chan will fail to notice that no episode discussion threads were created for a select few OVAs/movies. Normally we’d catch this through modmail, a comment in the Meta Thread, or by ourselves, but in the case of these eight anime, no one noticed as they breezed by without a thread.
By the time we realized this oversight, it was already the middle of September. While our official policy is to create a discussion thread as soon as subs of reasonable quality are available, we felt that dropping eight threads on a random September day wasn’t the best course of action. And since we had already missed the train for when they should be posted, we’re opting to do what I like to call Clean-Up Week.
Clean-Up Week is when we’ll release discussion threads for these anime that slipped through the cracks. By announcing the threads in advance, we’re hoping to give people the chance to participate in the thread rather than just dropping them out of the blue.
Here is the proposed schedule for them:
October 10th: A Few Moments of Cheers
October 11th: Batman Ninja vs. Yakuza League
October 12th: Fuuto PI: The Portrait of Kamen Rider Skull
October 13th: Fureru
October 14th: Inazuma Eleven the Movie: Prologue to the New Heroes
October 15th: Nintama Rantarou Movie: Dokutake Ninja Tai Saikyou no Gunshi
October 16th: LUPIN THE IIIRD: Zenigata and the Two Lupins
October 17th: Binan Koukou Chikyuu Bouei-bu Eternal Love!
October 18th: 100-nichikan Ikita Wani
October 19th: Strawberry Prince the Movie
October 20th: i☆Ris the Movie: Full Energy!!
October 21st: Miru: Paths to My Future
October 22nd: Touken Ranbu Kai Douden
October 23rd: Collar x Malice Movie: Deep Cover
October 24th: Touken Ranbu - Hanamaru Season 3
October 25h: Pui Pui Molcar the Movie: MOLMAX
If there are any other anime that we missed, please tell us so that we may add them to Clean-Up Week.
15
u/Elimin8r https://myanimelist.net/profile/Ayeka_Jurai Oct 06 '25
Lengthy post incoming alert:
Okay, I've been debating whether to say something in the daily thread, CDF, or here, but I'm going to post here (unless told otherwise), because it feels like this is sort of a r/anime meta concept.
What do we think about rewatches and rewatch culture?
I'm currently participating in a couple of rewatches, and have participated (and sometimes failed) in many more. They've been one of my most enjoyable part of r/anime for several years now, and lately I've been thinking that it might just be time for me to give back and host a rewatch of my own.
That said, I've previously mentioned a couple of things I might be interested in doing a rewatch for, and received a bit of a warning on one (Onimai), I suspect in large part because I had mentioned it in reference to a previous rewatch host, who while entertaining, it seems wore out his welcome, so to speak. I suspect that I'd rather not follow in his footsteps.
That, and referring to that particular show, well, you know ... I'm not sure I really want to deal with the kind of attention that kind of rewatch might gather, from - on the one hand, the gooners, and -on the other hand, the neo-puritans. You know what I mean.
Yeah, I probably don't need that in my life.
At the same time, I realize that my own personal tastes in anime tend (often) toward the obscure, and while I might think a Moldiver might be delightful, I'd probably be the only one there. Yeah.
Additionally, a poster (and host) from the past whom I have greatly appreciated has returned from the nether, and speaking of the desire to give back, I want to (if possible) host something that we, and as many others as possible can enjoy.
(Within reason, I don't need no Eva rewatch 100+ post threads to deal with. Cozy, but not empty would be my goal.)
That said, I hope that u/Siegfried72 doesn't mind me naming a name, but we've both noted certain things in the ongoing K-ON! rewatch, that as a host (and potential, in my case) I find ... well, I'm just not sure how to deal with. Which brings me to the next thing on my mind here: (See next)
25
u/cppn02 Oct 11 '25 edited Oct 11 '25
I don't know how I would have made it through the day without knowing that the CSM movie is now the 9th highest grossing anime movie in South Korea.
12
u/Nebresto Oct 18 '25
In an attempt to gain access to seasonal flairs slightly more quicklierly I prepared some candidates. All 256 x 128, except for one 384 x 128
pls flairs before we're more than halfway into the season again
10
u/_Ridley https://myanimelist.net/profile/_Ridley_ Oct 08 '25
On old reddit, there's currently no link anywhere to the seasonal survey. I know the old reddit users are the extra motivated sickos, but it'd be nice to see at least a link in the daily thread.
18
u/chilidirigible Oct 05 '25
A moment to flip this comment from the weekly karma rankings over here as a general discussion; in short, anime's popularity is up, discussion and engagement in the subreddit is down.
Reasons suggested in the replies include the end of the pandemic, the userbase aging out, other social media of less textual format, and the userbase aging out.
Which brings me to the immediate question as a reaction: Is that bad?
It is, as too much userbase loss turns a community into a very small circle that gradually fades out.
But, is it that bad?
A smaller userbase that sticks around and has significant interest in a topic is better for focused discussion than trying to engage with everyone who drops in for one question and is never seen again.
Provided that the userbase can be maintained, which still requires some level of replacing those who age out or get bored.
Though Reddit®, the corporation seeking SHAREHOLDER VALUE and constantly trying to turn itself into a scrolling visual feed endorphin machine, works against its own interests there, or at least against the interest of subreddits with a long history and a unique style. Can't do much about that when Reddit itself alienates old redditors.
Anyway, that's my meta thought for this hour of the morning.
9
u/Emi_Ibarazakiii Oct 09 '25
For future reference if nothing else, I'd like to know why this isn't a spoiler;
I reported it when I saw it, thinking it was an obvious spoiler (even though I haven't watched that other show), then I saw it again a couple days later, so I researched the character, their status (deceased) and then looked up the death scene, and yeah I can see where they're coming from... So I reported it again, thinking maybe the first one didn't go through, but it's still there so I guess it's not a spoiler...
Isn't it like, I don't know, say if Batman got decapitated in The Dark Knight, and then you watch some anime and a character gets decapitated, and you say "Oh my god, they actually went full Dark Knight. Bro got fucking Batman'd!"
That'd be a Batman (Dark Knight) spoiler, right?
9
u/thekoreansun https://anilist.co/user/ReturnByDeath Oct 13 '25
(At u/baseballlover723's request, I have moved the following paragraph from my comment in the latest Isekai Quartet episode discussion thread to here.)
By the way, I know that the episode discussion threads don't usually include a Source Material Corner when the anime is an original work, but I think that this might be the one case when an original anime needs a Source Material Corner. There are four entire light novel series worth of lore that Isekai Quartet has constantly referenced and hinted towards, sometimes even prior to them being referenced in their original shows. The moderation team would do well to add one to these threads, u/baseballlover723.
8
u/Verzwei Oct 05 '25 edited Oct 05 '25
Got any data to share?
The gist of this line of questions is how many viable (even if not valuable) posts did we get specifically because of the trial, and how much extra work was created (both for users having to report bad posts, and mods who had to investigate and remove them) during that time.
My personal opinion and gut feeling hasn't changed since what I said in the last meta thread during the trial. Yes, we did get more [Discussion] posts, and yes those did dilute the glut of [Help] and [What to Watch] when sorting by new. However, very, very few of the discussion posts we did get were worth much of anything. The trial increased the noise, not the signal.
Of the stuff that didn't break other rules, the biggest "offenders" to me were the super lazy /r/askreddit style open questions where the OP just asks people for their most-favorite or most-hated [blank] and then lets the thread ride while giving none of their own examples nor engaging with the prompt in any meaningful way. Sure, some of those posts generated a lot of comments, but in most cases it was just single-line replies answering the question, and it was rare to see any sparks of discussion nested any deeper within. I regularly see more involved back-and-forth in the Daily Thread, albeit from probably a smaller pool of users.
I think an important question to the mod team (and the community, but decision is obviously up to the mods) is what is the intended purpose of the [Discussion] flair? I'd argue that a couple short lines of a prompt from an OP isn't a "discussion" in the first place. The mid-trial 200-character requirement upgrade helped a little, but still felt too low. At a glance, the site formerly known as Twitter has a limit of 280 characters unless you pay for enhanced approved free speech, and Bluesky is capped at 300 characters. I think 300 is a more-appropriate target for a "Discussion" post on Reddit - if it can fit in a message on one of those other social media platforms, then it doesn't need to be a post here and can be sent to the Daily Thread.
In order of my preferences, not all necessarily all at once:
8
u/qwertyqwerty4567 https://anilist.co/user/ZPHW Oct 06 '25
/u/baseballlover723 enhanced doesnt properly load when clicking "load more comments" such as the one above my comment.
8
u/RedNovaDay https://myanimelist.net/profile/RedNovaDay Oct 17 '25
So I stumbled upon the Legal streams page from the wiki a few days ago. I also discovered 2 youtube channels that could be added to the list. Who among the mods should I message about this?
The channels that I’m talking about are:
It’s Anime powered by REMOW and the other one is Tropics Anime Asia
(btw I’m from Southeast Asia, sorry but I don’t know about the availability in other territories)
Anyway, here are some shows available in them:
It’s Anime powered by REMOW
1.) My Daughter Left the Nest and Returned an S-Rank Adventurer
2.) I'm Giving the Disgraced Noble Lady I Rescued a Crash Course in Naughtiness
3.) Under Ninja
4.) The Vexations of a Shut-in Vampire Princess
5.) Pon no Michi
6.) My Deer Friend Nokotan
7.) Hell Teacher: Jigoku Sensei Nube
8.) Tasokare Hotel
9.) Uma Musume: Cinderella Gray
10.) There’s No Freaking Way I’ll Be Your Lover! Unless…
11.) Chitose is in the Ramune Bottle
12.) Fermat Kitchen
(and there are others that I haven’t included, feel free to check the channel for more info)
Tropics Anime Asia
1.) Demon Lord, Retry! R
2.) Dungeon People
3.) Welcome to Japan, Ms. Elf!
4.) Me and the Alien MuMu
5.) Kinnikuman Perfect Origin Arc
6.) A Ninja and an Assassin Under One Roof
7.) Welcome to the Outcast’s Restaurant!
8.) Grand Blue (season 1 and 2)
9.) Teogonia
10.) Dusk Beyond the End of the World
11.) Summer Pockets (currently releasing, one episode every night)
7
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Oct 05 '25
Subscriber count's gone, 15 million celebration never?
Probably better to shift to the sub anniversary for that kind of thing anyway for a consistent schedule, except it's also right in the middle of awards season so it makes for some tricky timing juggling posts.
7
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Oct 07 '25
Random stats question: how many unique users have posted comment faces outside of CDF, meta, or the daily thread in the past year?
7
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Oct 07 '25
As /u/InfamousEmpire mentioned sometimes the flair site adds extra characters to your list username. I haven't gone digging into the code but I think when it parses your current flair (to select the elements on the page) it doesn't correctly strip everything before the username so a few characters get left over and added to the text input, which some people won't notice before saving.
7
u/tripleaamin https://myanimelist.net/profile/tripleaamin Oct 21 '25
There doesn’t seem to be a thread for the dragon maid movie that was released in theaters tonight.
6
u/Insecticide Oct 05 '25
Earlier this week, I had the following commented removed (link)
The author must be extremely happy because this supposed to be a suffocating story with ocean themes and they nailed it. It feels even heavier than the manga.
The rule that I supposedly broken, which I don't agree with, was the following
This belongs in the Source Material Corner at the top of this thread. In discussion threads for currently airing anime, discussions about source material, spin-offs, mangaka comments and unadapted content must be posted there, and not outside it. This applies specifically to comparisons to the anime or hints about future events, even if such hints are vague. Please note that you still have to tag your spoilers in the source corner.
The comment was removed by u/ussgordoncaptain2 . After **questioning why it had been removed** (because the original comment didn't spoil anything about the series and talked exactly about the atmosphere of the show, set by episode 1, and how it was like what the author envisioned), the moderator told me
This applies specifically to comparisons to the anime
So, the sentence that broke the rule was the following:
It feels even heavier than the manga.
Can you guys tell me how on earth does this comment warrant any removal? Why was this rule made and who is this rule meant to protect? Tell me about the **spirit** of the rule. Why do you guys have it? I think that this removal was absolutely ridiculous and that type of comment doesn't hurt anyone.
It would be one thing if I was talking about elements not yet shown in the story, or author comments about something in the future (plot-wise), but here I was simply saying "oh yeah, the author said that they wanted this and the anime team nailed it in episode 1, it feels even better than the original". I was just very excited about what I had seen in episode 1 of the show in question. It doesn't make sense to me.
6
u/tripleaamin https://myanimelist.net/profile/tripleaamin Oct 12 '25
There seems to be no thread on 100 meters which released today in theaters.
6
u/_Ridley https://myanimelist.net/profile/_Ridley_ Oct 13 '25
Out of curiosity, does the spoiler rule apply to everything, or just anime?
6
u/cppn02 Oct 31 '25
Working my way through the new Star Wars Visions season and as I check out the episode threads I realise they are completely out of order.
What happened there?
5
u/ussgordoncaptain2 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Edmund_Nelson Oct 05 '25
/u/Insecticide /u/hiimneato and /u/yukiaddiction you were in my "ping for the next meta thread" group
5
u/Puddo x3https://anilist.co/user/STPuddo Oct 07 '25
Got a message that the WT image in the sidebar links to an error. Guess it's the double / in the end.
Also TIL new.reddit can switch between sidebar images on refresh. Guess it does have 1 improvement.
5
u/Cyclone_96 Oct 13 '25
I just have to know, am I alone in that whenever I get a quick glance at the small version of the new sub icon it kind of just looks like a brown haired guy with a goatee?
At least until it comes into focus and then it's fine, but it's been throwing me off a little since it got changed. I assume it's just gonna be this until after Halloween?
5
u/cppn02 Oct 20 '25
New Daily Thread where?
5
u/Charmanders_Cock Oct 25 '25
So I know that posting links to pirate sites or the like is prohibited, but what about tracking sites that don’t host any pirated content themselves? In the case I’m thinking of specifically, it used to be an aggregate site that was shut down and reopened purely as a tracking service. The site tracks releases by scanlation groups and the like, but no pirated content.
My initial thought was “probably not because they technically point toward pirated content,” but at that point it’s not really any different than users being able to name specific groups here so I figured I’d ask.
5
u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ Oct 27 '25
Ahem.
/u/baseballlover723 has told me to tell you that today's daily thread is linking to last week's CDF instead of this week's CDF.
This is a pretty typical, reoccuring thing. I only notice because I am using the pinned daily thread to get me a shreddit link to CDF on my phone, which I haven't had to do this weekend, so only noticed today.
9
u/Prince_Uncharming https://myanimelist.net/profile/sirsimpleton Oct 16 '25 edited Oct 16 '25
“Should I watch X” / “Is X worth watching” threads are almost always zero value posts that serve no discussion purpose and should be deleted or re-routed to the daily questions thread.
Go through any of these threads and they’re filled with almost exclusively top level comments, half of which are sarcastic (guilty), redirects to the “Watch the damn anime” thread, or something else.
These aren’t discussions. These are almost always users wanting to be spoonfed an answer because they can’t make a decision for themselves, as they rarely provide any meaningful context as to why OP is even asking this question to begin with other than “is this worth my time”.
Example: https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/s/HUGccBMgwU
8
u/Dreamcatcher-innight Oct 06 '25
I’ve been trying to make a post but it says I don’t have enough karma points in the /anime how do I know how many I’ve accumulated through this thread only? It says I have 13 and I’ve been commenting everywhere so I can make my post in here about yona of the Dawn 🙂↕️
8
u/TakenRedditName https://myanimelist.net/profile/TakenMalUsername Oct 09 '25
should be categorized with the other thinking comment faces. Look at him. He is plotting, he is scheming, he is thinking about coffee jelly.
4
u/Rumpel1408 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Rumpel1408 Oct 05 '25
Ok, not very meta, or maybe it is. Already asked this /u/baseballlover723 earlier over in CDF
For some time spoilers seem to have broken for me, but only on r/anime.
When seeing a spoiler with the context in [ ] and then the spoiler between two !, the brackets and the space between it and the actual spoiler gets hidden (on old.reddit)
Example
before clicking spoiler
after clicking spoiler
How I made it and how it looks everywhere else on reddit
4
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Oct 12 '25
Looks like the daily thread rotation script didn't run correctly today.
4
u/Infodump_Ibis :JY::JZ: Oct 18 '25
Apart from Batman Ninja vs. Yakuza League was the rest of Catch-up week(s) meant to be absent from Other Discussions? I can get not including all of them at once as it'll bump down/out anything in the last 6 months including 100 meters.
4
u/PauseEither4144 Oct 28 '25
Am I allowed to post my commissions here and advertise?
7
u/Vatrix-32 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Vatrix-32 Oct 05 '25
Since I never got a response last meta thread, I am again reposting my request for
Broken Comment Face
to be added to the Comment Faces Sources page.
3
u/mr_beanoz https://myanimelist.net/profile/splitshocker Oct 28 '25
Should animations from video game, if they're made by Japanese studios, be allowed? Case in point is the newest opening for the Nikke mobile game that is made by A-1.
5
u/mekerpan Oct 13 '25
I enjoyed seeing the human moderator's apology to the autolovepon bot for removing its post about this weeks mangaka episode discussion due to the fact that CR's English subs didn't actually exist on the purportedly English-subbed streaming version. ;-)
5
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '25
So is any mention of the word Zionist even in relation to an on topic post about Crunchyroll switching to an Israeli company for subs just going to get removed lmao
5
u/theshinycelebi https://anilist.co/user/Phosphofyllite Oct 27 '25
Is there any point where we consider limiting or consolidating film box office posts into a megathread? Not even trying to hate on any particular film but with so many threads the discussion inevitably becomes repetitive.
Original discussion threads receive the bulk of the insightful analysis and review, but in contrast the comments in the box office posts are mostly variations of "movie was good."
3
u/GlibGrunt Oct 06 '25
Mildly curious about episode discussions for The Fated Magical Princess: Who Made Me a Princess. Its currently releasing on Crunchyroll but I can't see any posts for it like with other shows. Is there a reason? I know it released slightly earlier in China from the wiki but there don't appear to be posts for that either.
3
u/Kindly-Eagle6207 Oct 17 '25 edited Oct 17 '25
Since this is supposed to go here:
This clip was posted earlier today by another user and was removed by a particular mod for breaking these two rules:
• Clips must not have artificial black bars or unofficial watermarks.
• Clips must be of high visual fidelity and represent the original anime accurately.
Lets start with the latter as it will inform the former:
FLCL originally aired between 2000 and 2001. Like many anime of the time, it used an entirely digital process and was mastered only for its intended display resolution: Standard Definition TVs. That means there are no film negatives or cells or any other analog content that can be remastered for HD. The only HD versions of FLCL that will ever exist are upscaled versions of the SD master. That includes the Blu-ray release, streaming versions, and any "super special HD++, no really" versions you might find on pirate sites. There is no HD source so there will never be a non-upscaled HD version.
And unfortunately those upscaled SD versions are far from perfect. Here's a frame from the same clip posted above. You'll note some pretty obvious color banding on the back of Naota's shirt and pants. That's not imgur's compression algorithm, that's how it appears straight from the Blu-ray encode. I know, because that's how I created the clip.
You might notice the video clip posted above is worse in some ways than that frame. Some of the color banding has blurred together and blocked out, and there are additional compression artifacts. That's for two reasons:
The video clip above doesn't have black bars encoded as part of the video itself like you might see as part of some 4:3 content in order to fit common 16/9 HD aspect ratios. Depending on the screen resolution and app you're using to view the clip, you might still see black bars to the left and right. That's not because they're in the video, that's just how shapes work.
Why does that matter? Because unlike the clip above, the Blu-ray release version of FLCL does have black bars encoded into the video. Which means in order to comply with the rule above, the video needs to be cropped. Because of the way video encoding works, cropping a video means re-encoding it. There's no way around that. Additionally, no matter your quality settings, or encoding algorithm, or the mightiness of your rig, encoding is a lossy process. Every time you re-encode you lose visual fidelity. There's no way around that, except not re-encoding, and not cropping, at all.
This clip is the best, or close to it, that this scene from FLCL will ever look on reddit due to the issues mentioned above. And honestly? It doesn't look that great. Nor does it look much better than the clip shared earlier today. Any improvements to the quality of this clip are going to come from two places:
Hopefully this is a learning experience for the mods and a better understanding of the limitations imposed by the two rules above will lead to fewer clips being removed due to ignorance.
If that's not the case, then that leaves us with a sub where sharing a staggering amount of good anime is soft banned because of the technical limitations of early 2000s digital animation and the two rules above being enforced in an asinine manner.
EDIT: Since the mods banned me after making their half-assed response:
The size of a losslessly encoded H.264 video, or any other codec for that matter, would be ludicrously large. You would balloon the size that clip to be an order of magnitude larger, and for no benefit because it was already encoded with a lossy algorithm.
To suggest this as a solution shows you have absolutely no idea what you're talking about.
At no point did I mention 480p video, nor the resolution of the previously removed post. You're the one repeatedly mentioning 480p video. I'm betting because you binged a bunch of Wikipedia articles to try to prove yourselves right and got some strawman stuck in your head while "researching."
It's beyond obvious that you don't give a rat's ass about video quality nor reasonable standards for it. Your comment is a badly rushed attempt to prove yourself right and hide the fact that you're removing posts arbitrarily.
And I can tell now why you were so desperate to have this hidden in the megathread: because you'd be getting absolutely eviscerated for being so transparently in over your head. The moderation here is truly pathetic.